Pressure altitude is fundamental for the performance of airplanes because you fly in a known estable layer of the atmosphere that keeps your drag, lift and thrust almost constant (there are temperature changes but it takes docens of miles to change a single degree).
Also if you select the standart atmosphere you know you are flying the same layer system of all the other airplanes in the air, with a fully autonomous, relatively cheap, and non electrical device. Also it's easy to calibrate on your own if you want to fly in a local airport and have no access to a weather report. It's hard to beat a conventional altimeter.
Other reasons are: the transponders that ATC (and other aircraft) interrogate report pressure altitude (uncorrected, meaning using 29.92 inHg as the standard).
A sensitive altimeter can be had for a few hundred dollars and requires no electrical power (unless lighted) and basically no service throughout its life.
To your last point, anywhere it matters (below the flight levels), pilots are using a local altimeter setting on the altimeters, often from the ATIS (automated terminal["airport"] information system) or from ATC. Of course, for takeoff, it doesn't matter. You're generally climbing at max available power or are doing a reduced power takeoff in aircraft so certified and on runways without obstacles to worry about.
On approach, you're typically following a precision approach path provided by a radio signal (ILS includes lateral and vertical guidance beams) or that is GPS-based (where you have similar navigation performance levels provided by WAAS augmentation). There are non-precision approaches where the altimeter setting is more critical, but I can't recall the last time I had to fly one of those for other than training purposes.
In the southwestern US, especially, GPS often becomes unusable due to military activity. It isn't uncommon for an airliner to experience a loss of GPS signal mid-flight when operating near military exercises. It's just the nature of our system.
It was a good article. I enjoyed the allusions to ships on a sea, and moment before landing described as an unanswered question. I'm wondering if this will be passed along much in the pilot community. The most popular 'pilot life' creation in recent memory seems to be this Lego parody - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rNxz2hhSXuY.
There are ways to supplement the precision of GPS altitude with ground-based stations (WAAS), and this is indeed used to construct GPS-based instrument approach procedures which are comparable in accuracy to traditional means (ILS). But these require ground-based transmitters; impractical to implement worldwide.
The GPS most of them use is almost as old, a $20 Garmin handheld could navigate circles around it.
Probably not, as it will refuse to work at both the altitude and speed of an airplane ;-)
EDIT: I stand corrected. Neither the speed nor the altitude will be a problem.
It's also trivial to obtain unrestricted GPS devices.
Well sub in the garmin with one of the other low cost consumer units that work at those altitude and speeds then!
There should be enough checks for setting the proper baro setting - both pilots check the setting individually when changing it and it's reported to them a number of times throughout descent. Even if they do manage to get it wrong through all that, the GPWS should notify them if they get too close to any obstacles.
"True" altitude requires you to both have an excellent fix on the satellites and have a very, very good reference geodetic model (which you probably don't). Also depending on the quality of your fix, you'll have different altitudes to the rest of the people around you.
It makes more sense to have two pilots independently check the pressure settings (and that's why you have a checklist).
This isn't a real answer. I hope someone with a real answer comes along!
GPS is not the only system. We currently have about 2.7 global satellite navigation constellations available for use.
The American GPS and the Russian GLONASS are both complete. The Chinese Beidou system is about 40% complete. The European Galileo system is about 30% complete. Each system also has about 20% redundancy in the form of on-orbit spares.
Dual-system GPS/GLONASS receivers are now nearly everywhere. I was just looking at a phone that has a triple-system GPS/GLONASS/Beidou receiver. In a few years, quad-system receivers will be commonplace.
A rogue nation would have to shoot down about 1.9 constellations, or about 60 satellites, before we drop below full coverage.
The American, Chinese, and European systems have the same orbital inclination. If a gap opened, any satellite from any of these three systems could theoretically fill that gap. It would take some time to reposition the satellites, though.
There is also additional redundancy in the eastern hemisphere. India and Japan have satellites that provide regional coverage. Part of the Chinese system also operates as a regional constellation.
At this point, the rogue state is at war with the US, Russia, China, the EU, India, and Japan. They might as well just surrender.
In any case, disrupting satellite-based navigation is the simplest kind of rocket science: a missile that just has to go up and then detonate, no aiming required.
A nuclear weapon detonated in low earth orbit would not destroy a single global navigation satellite. They are not in low earth orbit.
A nuclear weapon detonated in medium earth orbit would wipe out between 0 and 1 navigation satellite, depending on how close you get. The satellites just aren't that close together.
An EMP would destroy electronics on the ground, but this will be a systemic effect. Satellite navigation would be collateral damage. When the ground-based electronics are replaced, though, the satellites will still be working.
> In any case, disrupting satellite-based navigation is the simplest kind of rocket science: a missile that just has to go up and then detonate, no aiming required.
Nuclear weapons are powerful, but they still have to obey the laws of physics. If you get far enough away, the inverse-squared law makes even a nuclear explosion look like a firecracker.
A 1 megaton nuclear weapon would have to be detonated within half a kilometer to damage a satellite physically: http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/spacegunconvent...
The shielding needed to protect a satellite against EMP only adds 5% to the cost of the satellite: http://fas.org/spp/starwars/congress/1997_h/h970716u.htm
So basically, it's going to take one nuclear warhead to destroy one navigation satellite. If a rogue nation has 60 nuclear warheads, it's hardly going to waste them to take out 60 navigation satellites.
Information on this is distributed to pilots (in the US) via NOTAMs, and you can use this information to decide whether it's safe to use GPS navigation for your flight.
Practically speaking though, aviation GPSs have a function called RAIM that continuously monitors the integrity of the position information and will inform you on a loss of precision. I believe most GPSs also allow predicting RAIM along your time and route of flight to make sure you'll have integrity from takeoff to landing.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radar_altimeter#Civil_aviation_...
I can understand relying on airspeed instead of GPS-measured groundspeed, because airspeed is important. But I can't think of a justification for not using true altitudes, especially during takeoff and landing. What happens if the pilots punch in a wrong number for the destination air pressure?