News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chile is introducing free higher education by the_af on Friday May 08, 2015 @07:47PM (#9514781)
Yes, it's fair. Just like a lot of public works and services are funded by taxes even if you in particular don't use them.

More importantly, fairness is a trade-off. Granting free universal access to certain things benefits the poor and those with lower incomes, even if it's not particularly beneficial for people with higher incomes. That's a good trade-off in my opinion, and in the opinion of progressive governments.

Re:Chile is introducing free higher education by Daishiman on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:35PM (#9514914)
> . Granting free universal access to certain things benefits the poor and those with lower incomes, even if it's not particularly beneficial for people with higher incomes. That's a good trade-off in my opinion, and in the opinion of progressive governments.

This is patently, obscenely false.

A value-added economy depends on qualified, skilled labor. If the pool of people with higher education is smaller, you will have less potential to develop industries with that requirement. Training costs will fall on companies (which will be onerous and will not supplant a 4-year degree), and costs for the smaller labor pool go up.

It is in the interests of all developing economies to have talent in their workforce. It's a significant limiting factor in many industries in Latin America.

Re:Chile is introducing free higher education by the_af on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:43PM (#9514930)
Oh, no disagreement here. My comment was poorly worded. I meant "even if it didn't particularly benefit", but like you said, it's in the overall best interest of everyone in the country that the majority of the population has access to good quality education. And this is true even if you don't think in terms of the workforce.

With an exception, of course: some people would rather the rest of the people weren't as well educated as themselves. That way they can continue paying them miserably low salaries. It's a self-destructive behavior, but it still happens, because some people don't think long term. I didn't want to address this in my original comment.

Re:Chile is introducing free higher education by oldmanjay on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:13PM (#9514858)
My main gripe with the language of progressive politics is the redefinition of words like "fair."

Intellectual honesty demands that you call things what they are. Marketing demands you redefine things to make people feel the right warm-and-fuzzies. What you did is the latter.

Re:Chile is introducing free higher education by nmrm2 on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:51PM (#9515116)
"What is justice/fairness?" is one of those philosophical questions that will never be closed. Claiming that there exists some ground truth definition of fair is, frankly, naive.

Terms like "just" and "fair" are over-loaded and refer to an ephemeral concept for which there are multiple, competing explanations and theories. No consensus or ground truth exists, so it's always fair game to introduce new explanations and theories. This has been the case for at least thousands of years.

Progressive politics didn't "redefine" fairness in any meaningful sense. Whose definition of "fair" isn't a "redefinition"? Rawls? Plato?

Re:Chile is introducing free higher education by the_af on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:30PM (#9514902)
How so?

It is fair to the country that a greater number of people have access to good quality education. The lesser unfairness that this causes in the people who don't care about public education is acceptable. Same as the lesser unfairness that public roads cause to people who don't use roads is also acceptable. This is the greater good we are talking about.

Re:Chile is introducing free higher education by iamcurious on Friday May 08, 2015 @08:29PM (#9514898)
I'm curious. What is the definition of fairness and how does it not apply in that comment?
Re:Chile is introducing free higher education by contingencies on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:22PM (#9515036)
Icing on the cake: by offering something universally you remove a layer of bureaucracy and hassle that someone was paying for anyway.
Re:Chile is introducing free higher education by mason240 on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:50PM (#9515112)
So no, it's not fair at then.
Re:Chile is introducing free higher education by the_af on Friday May 08, 2015 @09:56PM (#9515135)
Read my reply to Daishiman. In the longer term, it's fair to them as well. And in any case, fairness is a relative term. It's fair to the country as a whole.