I have two brothers in the California Highway Patrol, including one that's an instructor at the academy.
CHP officers go through a rigorous 1 to 2 year application process that includes background checks and psych evaluations. After they are accepted, they live on premises at the academy for 7 months where they are instructed in the law (academically) as well as high speed driving, weapon handling, how to properly make a traffic stop (like coming up on the passenger side, not the driver side), how to investigate a crime, etc.
My brother that's an instructor says that CHP officers are well aware that sheriff deputies and city police officers do not have a rigorous selection process and only receive 1-2 months training and that their interactions with them make that difference in training obvious.
It's too bad there isn't a standard certification process to become a police officer like there is for many professions. Your manicurist likely had more training a tougher certification process than some police officers.
In my encounters they've always been right, always been fair, and have never escalated a situation. They're genuine professionals.
Our police, in my experience, are the opposite.
That's why I'd rather see them just get rid of it entirely while also cutting back on the War on Drugs.
http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/04/why-rules-bend.html > An obvious enabler of police corruption is the fact that internal affairs units, tasked with exposing corruption, usually report to the same police chief that would be embarrassed by such exposure, and who may also be corrupt. An obvious solution is to make internal affairs more independent, e.g., reporting directly to a city council or even a governor. In the US the FBI sometimes serves in this role, though rarely at the request of local governments, and within the FBI its internal affairs still reports to FBI’s chief. Why don’t more governments create independent agencies to investigate corruption, to assure citizens that corruption is not tolerated?
I'd argue that it would be even better if they reported to a separate authority in most cases (obviously, for some agencies this is impractical at some level, but I think the norm for, e.g., local agencies should be for a state oversight body to oversee police misconduct rather than a local agency parallel and subject to the same local government.)
Where this isn't practical (state and federal law enforcement agencies of general jurisdiction), a parallel and organizationally co-equal agency doing misconduct investigation makes sense.
> In the US the FBI sometimes serves in this role, though rarely at the request of local governments
The FBI doesn't actually serve this role except insofar as the primary authority for investigating most federal laws, when alleged police misconduct happens to involve violating federal laws (often, civil rights laws), the FBI ends up investigating, not as part of a "oversee the police" role, but as part of its general "enforce federal law" role.
most u.s. police forces recruit from a similar pool of people as enlisted armed forces (and less selectively), they are: 1. HS/GED + potentially a couple years of college (its my understanding that most police officers don;t hold four year degrees) 2. Pass a drug test 3. Pass a criminal background check 4. Pass a rudimentary psych/aptitude test 5. Meet a minimum level of physical fitness
A friend who was a marine and did recruiting estimated that about 20% of a graduating U.S. high school class could meet those requirements - you then had to compete with other jobs and trades that were potentially more lucrative/appealing - and in the case with the marines (and i suspect it is similar with police forces) had a couple of motivations for joining (despite what they might say) 1. kill people/beat ass 2. Serve their country community 3. family tradition 4. need a job/job security 5. Challenge 6. uniform and toys
when viewed in this context one may not be too surprised at the actions of some portion of police officers
[0] http://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/community/miami-dade/a...
No amount of training is going to overcome the recruit pool you get by advertising "want to feel like a big man? Work for us!"
Of course states and cities will be free to turn down the dollars if they want, but the incentives will be strong for them to comply.
The changes that the article talks about would take decades to push through such a system
Maybe it wouldn't be too popular in the States, where everyone from the Mayor down to the city hall janitor (and including the sheriff) is elected. But it seems to work fairly well in Canada. Jurisdictions too small to warrant their own regional force contract the RCMP or provincial force (e.g. OPP) to serve as the regional force.
The flip side is that it can lead to a certain detachment (no pun intended) from the community because the officers consider it a "tour of duty" to serve at a tiny outpost before graduating to a "real" position.
In my area towns with less than 10k residents have been outsourcing policing to the county sheriff instead of continuing to staff their 1-2 officer police departments.
That single officer should receive the same level of training or better. I don't see lack of backup being a good argument for those officers receiving LESS training, which is your implication.
Now if you give them MORE training, then I'm all for it. I just said a minimum level of training and continued education.
I understand what you're saying in general, but there are a lot of universals that would apply across all kinds of jurisdictions.
With the exception that rural people probably have more and bigger guns than NYC people.
A very small department probably needs higher minimum standards, but there's also a minimum viable size, greater than 1, for a separate department.
http://blog.simplejustice.us/2011/06/19/the-first-rule-of-po...
I have no idea if what I am about to suggest is even legal, but I'd like to see congress pass a reform bill which contains:
- A minimum level of training and minimum continuing education requirement for all levels of police (state, county, federal, etc). Similar to No Child Left Behind (but for cops).
- Civilian oversight of police complaints (akin to what other countries have). Or failing that federal oversight.
- Federal funding to develop better officer education programs (with goals including officer safety, de-escalation, alternatives to use of force, and ethics).
- Reform asset forfeiture. All funds now also have to go to local education, homeless shelters, or similar. Nothing officer benefiting can be funded. Also someone has to have actually committed and been prosecuted for a crime(!).