Re:Police Start to Reconsider Longstanding Rules on Using Force
by dragonwriter on Monday May 04, 2015 @07:12PM
(#9489842)
> Total separation of those who investigate complaints against the police from the police themselves, with separate organisations, recruiting, promotion and the chief of said investigations reporting directly to whoever the relevant chief of police reports to.
I'd argue that it would be even better if they reported to a separate authority in most cases (obviously, for some agencies this is impractical at some level, but I think the norm for, e.g., local agencies should be for a state oversight body to oversee police misconduct rather than a local agency parallel and subject to the same local government.)
Where this isn't practical (state and federal law enforcement agencies of general jurisdiction), a parallel and organizationally co-equal agency doing misconduct investigation makes sense.
> In the US the FBI sometimes serves in this role, though rarely at the request of local governments
The FBI doesn't actually serve this role except insofar as the primary authority for investigating most federal laws, when alleged police misconduct happens to involve violating federal laws (often, civil rights laws), the FBI ends up investigating, not as part of a "oversee the police" role, but as part of its general "enforce federal law" role.
I'd argue that it would be even better if they reported to a separate authority in most cases (obviously, for some agencies this is impractical at some level, but I think the norm for, e.g., local agencies should be for a state oversight body to oversee police misconduct rather than a local agency parallel and subject to the same local government.)
Where this isn't practical (state and federal law enforcement agencies of general jurisdiction), a parallel and organizationally co-equal agency doing misconduct investigation makes sense.
> In the US the FBI sometimes serves in this role, though rarely at the request of local governments
The FBI doesn't actually serve this role except insofar as the primary authority for investigating most federal laws, when alleged police misconduct happens to involve violating federal laws (often, civil rights laws), the FBI ends up investigating, not as part of a "oversee the police" role, but as part of its general "enforce federal law" role.