News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peak car by jgrahamc on Sunday May 03, 2015 @05:23AM (#9480622)
I'm part of this phenomenon. I don't own a car but instead cycle to work, use public transport a lot, taxis, and, on the rare occasions I need to drive myself, Zipcar. There are a lot of things I like about Zipcar but I'll point out two that are not directly economic: I don't need to worry about the car once I've finished with it (a real concern in a big city with vandalism, theft) and I can rent different size cars (5 seater for normal times, 7 seater if I have lots of guests).
Re:Peak car by djthorpe on Sunday May 03, 2015 @06:32AM (#9480764)
I fear we are part of a small self-selecting group that has chosen the convenience to living in densely populated, well connected cities and are relatively well-off. I doubt you'll hear a lot about "peak car" outside these small groups or areas.

For many, I suspect the car represents a great deal of freedom in exactly the same way that not owning a car means to this self-selecting group: making a decent living, access and comfort, etc.

The real aim to force the decline of car use is sustainability, efficiency and equality. It's not going to happen without huge investments and will affect the whole economy negatively for decades, which is why Governments shy away from doing anything very serious about it.

In the meantime, I'm also happy to not own a car, cycle to work, etc. But if I lived outside central London I would get one immediately.

Re:Peak car by vinceguidry on Sunday May 03, 2015 @09:35AM (#9481210)
> I doubt you'll hear a lot about "peak car" outside these small groups or areas.

On the contrary, I think the prosperity evident in rural areas that can afford high ratios of car ownership is itself a small, self-selecting group of very well-off countries. If you broaden your view to the rest of the world, peak car doesn't look so silly after all.

A car is a much bigger investment in the developing world than it is in developed nations. Technology will enable more and more people in these nations to get more and more of their life done without the need to own an automobile.

We may see a saturation profile in the small part of the world where cars are both small investments and big conveniences, and a peak profile everywhere else. Which is, on the whole, a peak profile.

Re:Peak car by Shivetya on Sunday May 03, 2015 @05:13PM (#9483073)
Yet in nations that have recently moved into the income levels needed for automobiles their usage has exploded. China, India, and a few others, all seem to be burgeoning car markets.

I think one area over looked in their study of people streaming into and out of cities is the less need for the city itself to provide for the needs of the people. Combine that with all the congestion style pricing and it drives development outside of the city where those who cannot afford the entry costs.

Re:Peak car by zachalexander on Sunday May 03, 2015 @10:17AM (#9481346)
Reminds me of desktop computers vs. smartphones. Laptops may soon be a luxury/tool for techies that most people just don't need.
Re:Peak car by zippergz on Sunday May 03, 2015 @06:55PM (#9483402)
I fear we are part of a small self-selecting group that has chosen the convenience to living in densely populated, well connected cities

I think there's also the issue of differing definitions of "convenience." I used to live in a city where I walked or used public transit to get everywhere. Now I live in a suburb and drive everywhere, and I find most of the things I like to do MORE convenient. Yeah, in the city it was easy to walk to bars and restaurants, but I don't eat out that much, and I'm beyond the age where I want to hang out in bars.

As just one example, I like to cook at home, and grocery shopping when I have to carry everything in my arms is a pain in the butt. I know people like to talk about how much fresher your food is when you buy just what you need every day, and that sounds great, but I have a lot of other things going on in my life. Having to plan time to go to the grocery store every day after work is a hassle. Being able to drive five minutes to the store, park easily, and carry my stuff home in my trunk, is vastly more convenient than what I did when I lived in the city.

Having lived both ways for several years, I will never willingly go back to living in a densely populated city.

Re:Peak car by saurik on Sunday May 03, 2015 @09:12PM (#9483817)
I agree with this. I can drive to a store, buy what I want, and then drive home faster than friends of mine who live in San Francisco can even get on a bus to get to their destination. Walking around through crowded urban streets carrying valuable items you just purchased is also sub-ideal. I can buy things that are large or small, or that require refrigeration: no difference. I can make multiple stops without having to carry a ton of stuff through all my subsequent stops, as I can leave the stuff in my car.

My car is essentially a portable home I get to take with me wherever I am: it has first aid equipment, it has water and snacks, and secure storage. If you are optimizing for convenience, the correct choice is to separate things by networks of roads and use cars: that's why they exploded in popularity. You do want to live near where you work, but most of the people commuting long enough distances to make that matter are doing that due to economic issues (cost of living), not due to fundamental requirements for car deployment.

The issue is just that it isn't sustainable: it uses too much energy at too high an externality cost for us all to have this amazing level of convenience. It requires too much land to be paved and too much oil to be burned. But people should not confuse sustainability with convenience: dense urban areas that are not conducive to cars are not "convenient". To the extent to which people who live in them think they are convenient, it is because they don't understand most of the downsides they know about to cars are caused by dense urban environments.

Re:Peak car by avn2109 on Monday May 04, 2015 @12:09AM (#9484260)
>> '...dense urban areas that are not conducive to cars are not "convenient'."

I'm carless here in the city, and my very heavy groceries from two different stores are about to be delivered by Instacart. I'm lounging around in my PJ's. If this isn't convenient I don't know what is.

Re:Peak car by egypturnash on Sunday May 03, 2015 @09:03PM (#9483789)
On the other hand, if you can walk five minutes to the store, it's insanely easy to keep a tiny pantry full of fresh stuff. Especially if, like me, you're lucky enough to have a weekly farmer's market two blocks from your place.

But like you said, different people have different definitions of "convenience".

Re:Peak car by saurik on Sunday May 03, 2015 @09:16PM (#9483830)
It certainly is no easier than someone who can drive less than five minutes to a store: that person can both keep a tiny pantry full of fresh stuff or buy massive loads of bulk items without issue. Essentially, you have made an argument for why "it isn't so bad, as you can mitigate some of the downsides", but haven't shown a situation where it is actually more "convenient" (which I emphasize, as it is all sorts of other things, such as more "sustainable").
Re:Peak car by emj on Monday May 04, 2015 @02:50AM (#9484673)
Five minutes is too little time too warrant a car drive, usually it's actually 10 minute door-to-door when you are talking about a car transportation. But sure if you live in a wasteland of parking spaces and highways I guess it might be faster.
Re:Peak car by sounds on Sunday May 03, 2015 @08:20PM (#9483659)
Would a same-day delivery service change that for you? (I'm thinking of Amazon's offering but there are others.)
Re:Peak car by seanmcdirmid on Sunday May 03, 2015 @08:28AM (#9481028)
There are also those that live in developed world selected groups. I live in Beijing and would love a car, but a parking spot goes for a few hundred thousand dollars, the car itself would be $50-60k, and I would still need to get lucky in the license plate lottery. Well, at least taxis are cheap and ubiquitous.
Re:Peak car by rwmj on Sunday May 03, 2015 @10:40AM (#9481432)
I wonder why you would love to own a car, given the other problems you've pointed out.
Re:Peak car by toomuchtodo on Sunday May 03, 2015 @12:49PM (#9481998)
Freedom and convenience compared to other transit options.
Re:Peak car by more_original on Sunday May 03, 2015 @07:42AM (#9480936)
You're absolutely right. I understand "peak car" as trying to get away from unreasonable car use. Like in the US where one has to use a car for trips that one could easily walk, if only there were sidewalks.
Re:Peak car by lotharbot on Sunday May 03, 2015 @12:00PM (#9481789)
I think one of the major causes of "peak car" is that, as cars become saturated, alternatives begin to come online as cities try to relieve pressure -- and once those alternatives (sidewalks, public transportation, bike lanes, etc.) have a critical mass of users, they enter the public consciousness as acceptable alternatives, and they begin to have more resources poured into them. When your area gets adequate sidewalks, you can get away from unreasonable car use, and your use of the new sidewalks encourages more sidewalk construction, etc.
Re:Peak car by more_original on Sunday May 03, 2015 @12:38PM (#9481969)
I think you're right that this is a factor. What it doesn't quite explain is the decline of car usage in European cities that have always had sidewalks and good public transportation and where cycling isn't much easier now than it was 30 years ago. There seems to be a cultural change in attitude too. Cars are not as cool anymore as they used to be.
Re:Peak car by tonfa on Sunday May 03, 2015 @12:58PM (#9482031)
I think many European cities have seen changes in the past twenty years. Better cycling lanes, easy bicycle rental, increased public transit density and availability (eg late at night).
Re:Peak car by semi-extrinsic on Sunday May 03, 2015 @02:41PM (#9482446)
Not to mention lots of financial discouragement (i.e. tolls and taxes) for driving inside the city.
Re:Peak car by more_original on Sunday May 03, 2015 @03:23PM (#9482621)
Yes, I forgot about petrol prices, which have increased substantially.

I'm not so sure about infrastructure improvements, at least here in Germany. I have been cycling for more than 20 years, and the infrastructure has not changed that much. Some places have improved a bit (especially in the last 5 years), but some are worse too. I feel that the experience is largely the same here. It may be different in places like Paris or London, though.

Re:Peak car by dasil003 on Sunday May 03, 2015 @04:03PM (#9482795)
I lived and cycled in London the last 3 years, and there is a steady drumbeat of cycling improvements at all levels. Whether it's the congestion charge, cycle hire scheme, bike lanes, or even physically reconfiguring junctions with an explicitly stated goal of improving bicycle safety, there are major changes happening there.

I'm not sure how much change is happing on the continent, but based on some stories I've seen, there are many cities pushing the envelope, I think even within Germany (probably depends on the city?).

Re:Peak car by semi-extrinsic on Sunday May 03, 2015 @04:32PM (#9482898)
Even with the improvements you mention, London is still not exactly the most bicycle-friendly city in Europe, which is a little surprising since it's flat as a pancake. You should try cycling in Amsterdam or Copenhagen for a comparison.
Re:Peak car by zachalexander on Sunday May 03, 2015 @10:18AM (#9481347)
> small self-selecting group that has chosen the convenience to living in densely populated, well connected cities

Urbanization is steadily increasing worldwide.

> and are relatively well-off.

If you live in a city, owning a car is more expensive than not.

Re:Peak car by _yosefk on Sunday May 03, 2015 @10:38AM (#9481424)
Living close enough to the places you want to get to, however, often means buying/renting more expensive housing. This can more than offset what you save by not having a car.
Re:Peak car by kleiba on Sunday May 03, 2015 @06:29AM (#9480757)
I used to be part of this phenomenon. First, I lived in the city center where owning/using a car is just a drag. Then I moved to the suburbs and still resisted buying one as a matter of principle. But a little less than two years ago, I made the transition and now I happily own a car.

The reason?

1) Public transport in my city sucks.

2) The shopping infrastructure has moved out of the center of my community to the edges.

And it's not like I didn't try. As I said above, for quite a number of years I refused to use a car even after I moved out of the city center because I was convinced that individual car usage just isn't sustainable. But as I get older, I feel my spare time becoming more and more valuable. And in my particular case, going to and from work takes >1h each way, while with the car it's a good 20 minutes drive, saving me about 1h20 per day. This is because my work is in another suburb which by public transport you can only get to by first going into the city center and then out again. With the car, you can circumvent the city completely. (Unfortunately, the part of town where my work is is not a very nice place to live, or else I could probably bike.)

The second part is shopping. When I was younger, I would just walk to the next store and buy the few items I would need that day. But I was single back then. Now, there aren't any stores in walking distance any more, but my partner and I also require more stuff than when I lived alone.

I still believe it's a bad idea that every household owns more than one car on average. And I've always wondered: of all of the privately owned cars in this country, how many are actually moving at any given point in versus how many are parked?

But I have kind of given up hope that broad acceptance of public transport would become the norm "automatically", simply because people should realize that individual traffic is unsustainable. Now I think the only way this will ever become a reality is through force -- namely, governmental regulation. Of course, this is not on anybody's agenda at this point (anybody in power, I mean) and will not be in any foreseeable time. I don't believe individual car use will experience a measurable reduction in my life time, sadly.

Re:Peak car by whichfawkes on Sunday May 03, 2015 @12:32PM (#9481948)
What's so bad about a household owning more than one car? Suppose I work 20 miles North of where I live, and my SO works 20 miles South of where we live. Should we really carpool that?

If you're talking about individual traffic being environmentally unsustainable, I'd argue that we should focus as much on improving car/energy technology as we should on developing public transit. People do not want to commit or be forced into lifestyle changes. Rather than trying to make them drive less, it makes sense to reduce the impact of driving.

Re:Peak car by toomuchtodo on Sunday May 03, 2015 @12:50PM (#9482003)
> Rather than trying to make them drive less, it makes sense to reduce the impact of driving.

You can only build so much road. After that, you start increasing the cost of using shared infrastructure to drive down demand (congestion tolling).

Re:Peak car by johansch on Sunday May 03, 2015 @08:38AM (#9481051)
> how many are actually moving at any given point in versus how many are parked?

Doesn't most (like >80% in normal usage) of the depreciation cost incur while the car is moving, as opposed to being parked?

Re:Peak car by more_original on Sunday May 03, 2015 @06:03AM (#9480701)
I live in Europe and have never even considered getting a car. In cities the bike is the fastest mode of transport anyway, and for longer distances it's quite convenient to take the train.
Re:Peak car by pkorzeniewski on Sunday May 03, 2015 @06:29AM (#9480756)
I live in Europe and I can't imagine not owning a car. My city has quite good public transportation, but the flexbility and independence of car wins all the time. Using bus+train it takes me 1h to get to work one way, while by car it takes me 15m, additionally I do grocery shopping and other things on the way home. Time saving isn't however the major reason, but the feeling that I can go whenever I want, wherever I want.
Re:Peak car by more_original on Sunday May 03, 2015 @06:37AM (#9480784)
Fair enough. What you describe sounds much like I feel about bikes. Taking the bus and train to work takes over 30 minutes, while the bike ride is just 10 minutes. Going by car would certainly take more than 10 minutes here.

Someone once said to me that he feels amputated without a bike, which really hits the nail on the head.

Re:Peak car by atirip on Sunday May 03, 2015 @08:39AM (#9481055)
I live in Europe and i own a car, but don't use it to commute. It takes 10 minutes by bus and 15+ by car. Plus it takes min 10 EUR a day to park my car in the city. And the bus is free.
Re:Peak car by pmontra on Sunday May 03, 2015 @05:59PM (#9483257)
Where do you live and have free buses?
Re:Peak car by emj on Monday May 04, 2015 @03:03AM (#9484716)
Residents of Tallinn doesn't pay for public transport in the city.
Re:Peak car by barrkel on Sunday May 03, 2015 @06:44AM (#9480806)
It's hard to beat a motorcycle over longer city distances, however.

IMO a scooter is the best city transportation. I can pretty much get anywhere from anywhere in London in under 30 minutes. My commute from Victoria Park to Clerkenwell is 13 minutes. Google suggests 20 minutes to cycle; I reckon an athlete who ignored red lights could just about keep up, but they'd be sprinting in between the places they'd have to give way.

Re:Peak car by lancewiggs on Sunday May 03, 2015 @07:10AM (#9480864)
Electric bikes make that sprinting easy - so easy it feels like walking. I walk, (e)bike, motorbike and drive my car. Short trips are almost all bike now, car is for transport of large things and motorbike for longer trips.
Re:Peak car by peatmoss on Sunday May 03, 2015 @09:54AM (#9481282)
As an urban planner (well, PhD student now), the utility of electric bikes strikes me as obscenely high. We know that the vast majority of urban trips are < 3 miles--with a goodly portion under 1. Yet, so many people make these trips by car. A bike is very much more efficient, and often much faster if there is any congestion.

Electric bikes remove one major barrier people have, namely the arrive sweaty after a hill climb factor. I hear other bicyclists claim that this is less karmic because of exercise, but I view it differently. We know that, controlling for type of infrastructure, the prevalence of bicycling is strongly correlated with improved safety. The plausible explanation I subscribe to is that, with increased numbers, drivers are more accustomed to looking for bicyclists, and that bicyclists are better able to establish good group norms about how to ride safely. And of course increased numbers also mean that there is more political will to add more bicycling infrastructure, which in turn generates more bicycling. Electric assist bikes help with all aspects of this, with the exception of getting the maximum amount of exercise on every trip.

I'd love to see a business model that figures out how to 1. create a desirable electric bike brand 2. Have a low-barrier-to-entry rental or lease mode 3. Handles maintenance in a frictionless, reassuring way--perhaps with roadside emergency support 4. Has great on boarding for how to ride safely and confidently, perhaps coordinating with local bike clubs for instruction and personalized route planning.

Re:Peak car by tkoski on Sunday May 03, 2015 @07:36AM (#9480921)
This is not really taking the original discussion forward, but 20 minutes vs. 13 minutes is quite a difference when calculating average speed.

I probably made a mistake here, but using "google", distance from Victoria Park to Clerkenwell is 3.2 miles, 5.14km. If it takes 13 minutes, the average speed is about ~24km/h. To make the same distance in 20 minutes, you can drop your average speed down to ~15.5km/h. And that is not so "high speed" for cycling.

Funny fact, I put "average biking speed" to "google" and it told me that: For cyclists in Copenhagen, the average cycling speed is 15.5 km/h.

So I guess google uses 15.5km/h to calculate the time used to move the distance by bike.

Re:Peak car by nawitus on Sunday May 03, 2015 @07:40AM (#9480930)
I live in Europe and while I can get around without a car, owning a car improves my standard of living quite a lot. I guess the point is "I live in Europe" says nothing about how easy it's to get by without owning a car.
Re:Peak car by more_original on Sunday May 03, 2015 @07:53AM (#9480954)
Yes, that was poorly worded. Europe is big. I meant to say that there are places (specifically in Europe), where it's perfectly possible to go through one's whole life without a owning car and without missing out.
Re:Peak car by jmspring on Sunday May 03, 2015 @12:00PM (#9481791)
My in-laws live in a village a bit outside Nuremberg. In the 11+ years visiting them on a regular basis, I've seen the closing of small markets in favor of US style supermarkets. These stores are often further outside the town/city center. What was walkable becomes less so.

I've seen a similar trend where my brother-in-law lives outside Munich as well as some other towns where friends are.

For things like commuting, the train can make some sense, but for short trips to a market that is no longer walkable? A car may be more desirable.

Re:Peak car by edw519 on Sunday May 03, 2015 @08:44AM (#9481066)
Me too. 1972 to 2014: 1 million miles driven. 2015: 0.

Separately, my bicycle & public transport are poor alternatives. But combined, they are incredible. With my bike & a metro pass, I can get anywhere, sometimes more quickly than with a private car.

And now I never worry about: going to the gym, car payments, insurance, maintenance, gas, parking, and most of all, other drivers on their cell phones.

Re:Peak car by gerad on Sunday May 03, 2015 @12:05PM (#9481813)
You should definitely worry about other drivers on their cell phones if you're on a bike. If another driver hits you while you're driving, it damages the car. If that driver hits you while you're biking, it damages you.

I'm fortunate enough to be able to walk to work, and never drive, but also stopped biking because it is so dangerous. Not only do you need to be doubly wary of other drivers, you need to watch for people getting out of parked cars, other cyclists, and pedestrians only paying attention to their phones.

Re:Peak car by lkbm on Sunday May 03, 2015 @12:37PM (#9481968)
Thing is, I should probably be most worried about heart disease, but because I bike to and from work, that's not a major risk factor for me.

Traffic injuries/fatalities are more likely if you bike, cariovascular disease is less likely if you bike. I suspect my overall annual risk of mortality drops when I make the trade-off, as my bike commute isn't along any particularly dangerous roads.

Re:Peak car by Zarel on Sunday May 03, 2015 @01:52PM (#9482224)
At least MMM agrees that your overall mortality risk drops when biking:

http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/06/13/bicycling-the-safe...

Re:Peak car by lkbm on Monday May 04, 2015 @03:21PM (#9488410)
Mikael Colville-Andersen's TEDx talk is what first got me thinking about this: http://tedxtalks.ted.com/video/TEDxCopenhagen-Mikael-Colvill...

(I don't think biking without a helmet is better than biking with, as the title suggests, but I wouldn't be surprised if helmet laws/media campaigns are harmful.)

Re:Peak car by manmal on Sunday May 03, 2015 @09:21AM (#9481162)
No gym because you cycle, or because it's easy?
Re:Peak car by mod on Sunday May 03, 2015 @05:50AM (#9480670)
I'm part of it, not because I don't own a car, but rather because I drive it very little.

I work from home and I'm a bit of a recluse--but even those places I do travel with any frequency are all within probably 3 miles.

I think I probably average about 20 miles per week.

Re:Peak car by tomjen3 on Sunday May 03, 2015 @07:32AM (#9480914)
I am soon going to be out of this - I have more money now and while a car isn't required for daily transportation I have family outside the city that I want to be able to visit more often and moving larger purchases in a bus is a real pita.