I'm not saying anything about the experiment, but I think your statement that "conservation of momentum is more deeply embedded..." isn't quite so accurate.
[0] http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2010/02/22/energy-i... [1] http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Relativity/GR/energy_g...
It's important to note that these are separate questions. The inventors of these devices seem to have their own theories, but these may be wrong even if the devices do work.
At this point this is interesting but I won't get excited unless there are more replications. I would say that it seems to not be an "e-cat" situation. There are a minimum of two independent replications. So it would likely be error rather than fraud if it is mistaken.
Conservation of momentum is not more deeply embedded than c in that it isn't even a law (outside of classical mechanics) to begin with.
Edit: elsewhere in the thread you explain that yes, it must be local.
So if this isn't experimental error or some other minor effect, it seems safe to assume that however it works it is not violating conservation of momentum. Either that or the universe is much weirder than we thought.
Besides, classical mechanics is one of the assumptions of quantum mechanics.
All that being said I agree extreme skepticism is healthy here, though arrogance or dismissal doesn't seem quite appropriate as these results continue to be reproduced.
Local momentum conservation is foundational to all of physics: it is embedded in Newton's laws, and you can't get much more foundational than that. As such, if anything violates it the degree of "extraordinary" would be beyond anything ever seen. Far beyond superluminal nuetrinos.
So the previous posters are correct: momentum conservation, which is generally used to mean "local momentum conservation", is as deeply foundational to physics as Newton's laws, and the kind of observable-only-by-statistical-inference non-locality seen in QM is not known to have any impact on it.
As such, it would be earth-shaking at the deepest possible levels of physics if this result were correct. That does not mean it is wrong--although that is certainly my bet and that of virtually every other working physcist--but it's important not to understate what a big deal it would be, because understanding that opens up alternative ideas regarding how to test it.
This is neither arrogance nor dismissal, but an understanding that anything that violates local momentum conservation, via QM or anything else, and also lets the rest of physcis sail blithely on, manifesting no measureable effect of any kind on any of the millions of diverse and precise experiments that have been performed, is astonishingly implausible.
Could it happen? Sure. But it's really easy for laypeople to radically underestimate the implausibility of such claims, as was done all the time in the cold fusion community.
Nor does reproduction of the effect say anything very much about either the underlying theory (such as it is) or the actual cause. Lots of things can create forces of micronewtons, and given how utterly implausible the claim is, most physicists are starting with a prior barely above epsilon. As such, the amount of evidence required to update our belief to something close to unity is going to be huge. Laypeople, who start with an unreasonably large prior because they are ignorant of how fine-tuned such novel physics would have to be to never show up anywhere else, will require less evidence.
Almost all the entanglements and weird things of Quantum Mechanics are local. The electrons in a molecule have weird antisymmetric properties that mix different configurations (the easy picture is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resonance_(chemistry) the mathematics is more complicated).
You can entangle a few particles and move them at long distance, but if the particles hit another particle, the entanglement goes away. (You can transfer the entanglement, in very specific setups, but it's difficult, usually you get decoherence.)
I don't know a way to transfer a lot of momentum form one point to a very distant point using entanglement.
For example, you can put a box of particles in a rocket and each particle in that box in entangled with a particle that is in a box in Earth. When you measure the momentum of the particle in the rocket, it "changes" the momentum in the particle in Earth, so you can think that some momentum was "transferred". (This is not technically correct, but is a good enough approximation.)
The problem is that the momentum that you measure is in a random distribution, and half of the time you'll "transfer" momentum in one direction to make your rocket faster and the other half of the times the momentum will go in the other direction to make your rocket slower. It's impossible to transfer information using entanglement, and it's impossible to select the direction of the "transferred" momentum, in particular because that could be used to transfer information.
Local conservation of momentum is a fundamental property of any translation-invariant model in the framework of quantum field theory. All this means is that the (vector) momentum flowing into any point in space-time must equal the momentum flowing out plus any increase in "stored" momentum at that point (whatever that might mean).
Quantum mechanics is a "local" theory in the formal sense, at least in any halfway mainstream formulation (from Copenhagen to many-worlds). Even the "spooky action at a distance" that folks talk about in reference to quantum phenomena is never capable of transmitting information outside of the "cone of causality" in space-time (which is the "light cone" in most relativistic theories: information can't travel faster than light).
That's not what the pages you linked to are saying. They are saying that there are solutions in GR where there is not any well-defined notion of total energy, as in "total energy of the universe". But GR certainly does require local energy and momentum conservation, which is what EmDrive would violate if it worked.
The folks at the OPERA experiment stated that they found something that needed further testing. They even said that they doubted faster than light particles. They wanted their experiment audited and repeated and stated that they wanted help from the scientific community.
The media is who turned it into a circus.
We spent a great deal of time trying to figure out how the mechanism worked, and about half the team were theoreticians who would try and posit theories, or evaluate theories posited by other teams, and the the other half of the team spent time either testing the new theories, or experimenting to try and improve the results of previous experiments.
Y1B2C3O is not even a metal, but a ceramic crystal. This was kinda mind blowing at the time. It shouldn't even conduct.
IIRC the best theory at the time was that it was superconducting because of particular errors in the formation of the crystal due to the production process. But I left the lab in the early 1990s.
But maybe non-physicists don't have a sense of the range of meanings that "that isn't possible within current theory" can have. High-Tc might have been "impossible" under basic BCS superconductivity theory, but BCS theory itself taught us that it was possible to find novel theoretical mechanisms generating zero resistance, so needing a new one was surprising but not unprecedented. "Standard" low-Tc superconductivity appeared "impossible" under the usual models of materials' resistivity, but even that was merely a violation of a well-tested model when it was extended to a previously untested very-low-temperature regime. Resolving that apparent impossibility didn't require rewriting any fundamental principles, it just required very careful application of the existing theoretical framework.
These speculative new propulsion theories appear to violate the conservation laws underlying all of our existing models of physics, and in an experimental regime of size/temperature/etc. where (I believe) they have been very well-tested in the past. Any calculation within the framework of quantum field theory or general relativity will inevitably result in momentum being (locally) conserved: it's unavoidably built in to the formalism. So as I said to begin with, although it's obviously not truly impossible that some entirely different framework could turn out to be correct, that is an enormously bigger jump than any stage of the discovery and explanation of superconductivity.
A long time ago, people thought that the faster than sound planes were impossible, perhaps some wrote that formally. The materials didn't have enough strength, it would become too hot, the pressure at some point would be too high, ... To model a faster than sound plane you need to model a lot of complicated interactions between a lot of atoms, and then you need some simplifications, and with the simplifications used at that time it was impossible.
The conservation of momentum is a very low level result, so you don't need to put a lot of simplifications to prove it or measure it. For example you can measure the conservation of momentum when a photon hits an electron almost directly: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compton_scattering
I'm no physicist but this guy[1] is, and his paper — which is based off of research with evidence backing it up in the 1970's — suggests that the EmDrive creates propulsion from Unruh radiation[2].
[1]http://physicsfromtheedge.blogspot.co.uk/2015/04/light-in-bo...
(I'm not sure about Unruh radiation, but the nice thing about radiation is that when you see it far enough, it doesn't depend on the details of the source, it's simple a bunch of photons. (Well, the color of the photon depends on the details of the source, but they are undistinguishable from other photons.))
If this is consistent with special relativity, and the particles are mass less, then the Force/Power ratio is at most 1/c, that is 0.0033 uN/W = 0.0033 mN/KW.
If the particles are not mass less, and you just create them at the moment to emit them, the ratio is even smaller, much smaller.
If the particles are not mass less, and just accelerate them from a reservoir, the ratio can be much bigger, but now you have a standard rocket, not a fuel-less rocket.
Someone compiled here a list of experiments, with the Force/Power ratio: http://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=36313.msg13...
They vary from 3x to 200000x the theoretical maximum if we assume that this doesn't break the conservation of momentum, special relativity and quantum mechanics.
(Perhaps it's not necessary to use quantum mechanics, because the classical electromagnetic waves have the same Force/Power ratio, because they are actually a good approximation of the quantum electromagnetic waves. But the photons picture makes all clearer.)
This would just be a standard photon rocket--the cavity would eject photons out one end and move in the other direction. AFAIK all the EmDrive experimenters are claiming that no radiation is coming out of the cavity.
You make it sound like the scientists reporting it didn't doubt it.
But on the other hand, they were willing to make that public announcement in the first place. If they'd really felt the same level of skepticism that most of the rest of the community did, they might have done the tests that eventually found that loose cable before they stuck their necks out. (But then, part of their intent was clearly to get help and suggestions in figuring out what the lingering errors might be, and to get broader input on how feasible superluminal neutrinos might be theoretically. I can't judge them too harshly, even if they did wind up looking a step or two more willing to believe than they should have been.)
See this paper: http://pus.sagepub.com/content/5/2/121.short (unfortunately behind a paywall)
After a few years, it was no longer socially acceptable for respected scientists to work on cold fusion. It didn't matter anymore how good your reputation was as a researcher, or how carefully designed your experiment was--if your research was in cold fusion, it would get largely ignored.
Unfortunately, this happened around the time a couple groups of respected researchers with good experiment design were getting interesting results pointing to real new phenomena, and perhaps explaining why prior results had been so erratic.
David Goodstein around this time wrote a great article [1] looking back at cold fusion, which included a discussion of these later results, and how socially science had reached a state where they could not be considered. Here are the last few paragraphs.
All of this was much less important than the fact
that Cold Fusion experiments, if they gave positive
results at all, gave them only sporadically and
unpredictably. When Bednorz and Mueller announced
the discovery of high-temperature superconductivity
in 1986, no one carped about control experiments,
because, once the recipe was known, any competent
scientist could make a sample and test it and it
would work immediately. If, at their press
conference, Pons and Fleischmann had given a
dependable recipe for producing excess heat, they
very likely would be Nobel Prizewinners now (as
Bednorz and Mueller are) rather than social outcasts
from the community of scientists. The essential key
to the return of Cold Fusion to scientific
respectability is to find the missing ingredient
that would make the recipe work every time.
Experiments done in the U.S. and in Japan, and
reported at the Maui meeting indicate that the
missing ingredient may have been found. In all the
various Cold Fusion experiments, the first step is
to load deuterium into the body of metallic
palladium. The issue is how much deuterium gets into
the metal. The ratio of the number of atoms of
deuterium in the metal to the number of atoms of
palladium is called x. It turns out, by means of
electrolysis, or by putting the metal in deuterium
gas, that it is rather easy to get x up to the range
of about 0.6 or 0.7. That is already a startlingly
high figure. If there are almost as many deuterium
atoms as palladium atoms in the material, the
density of deuterium (a form of hydrogen) is
essentially equal to that of liquid hydrogen rocket
fuel, which can ordinarily exist only at extreme low
temperatures. In other words, palladium (and certain
other metals including titanium) soak up almost
unbelievable amounts of hydrogen or deuterium if
given the chance. This is far from a new discovery.
However, according to the experiments reported at
Maui, x=0.6 or 0.7 is not enough to produce Cold
Fusion. Both the American and Japanese groups showed
data indicating there is a sharp threshold at
x=0.85. Below that value (which can only be reached
with great difficulty and under favorable
circumstances) excess heat is never observed. But,
once x gets above that value, excess heat is
essentially always observed, according to the
reports presented at Maui, and recounted by Franco
Scaramuzzi in his seminar at the University of Rome.
The audience at Rome, certainly the senior
professors who were present, listened politely, but
they did not hear what Franco was saying (that much
became clear from the questions that were asked at
the end of the seminar, and comments that were made
afterward). If they went away with any lasting
impression at all, it was just the sad realization
that a fine scientist like Franco had not yet given
up his obsession with Cold Fusion. They cannot be
blamed. Any other audience of mainstream scientists
would have reacted exactly the same way. If Cold
Fusion ever gains back the scientific respectability
that was squandered in March and April of 1989, it
will be the result of a long, difficult battle that
has barely begun.
Recently, I told this story in a Philosophy course
we teach at Caltech called "Ethics of Research." The
first question, when I finished my tale, was, do I
believe in Cold Fusion? The answer is, no.
Certainly, I believe quite firmly the theoretical
arguments that say Cold Fusion is impossible. On the
other hand, however, I believe equally firmly in the
integrity and competence of Franco Scaramuzzi and
his group of co-workers at Frascati. I was disturbed
when I saw that Franco had gotten caught in the web
of science-by-news conference in April 1989
(although I was truly pleased that he finally got
the long overdue recognition his agency ENEA owed
him), and I was even more distressed when I learned
that Franco and his group had observed excess heat
(the "bad kind" of Cold Fusion). However, I have
looked at their cells, and looked at their data, and
it's all pretty impressive. The Japanese experiment
showing that heat nearly always results when x is
greater than 0.85 looks even more impressive on
paper. It seems a particularly elegant, well
designed experiment, at least to the untutored eye
of a physicist (what do I know about
electrochemistry?) What all these experiments really
need is critical examination by accomplished rivals
intent on proving them wrong. That is part of the
normal functioning of science. Unfortunately, in
this area, science is not functioning normally.
There is nobody out there listening.
I suppose that, if nuclear fusion really does take
place whenever x is greater than 0.85 in palladium,
the world of conventional science will eventually be
forced to take notice. If not, then the whole story
I have told you is nothing but a curious footnote to
a bizarre and ugly episode in the history of
science. Either way, I think the story illuminates
the inner dynamics of the scientific enterprise in a
way that few other stories have done. For that
reason alone, it may be worth telling.
[1] http://www.its.caltech.edu/~dg/fusion_art.htmlTotal measured neutron output, best case, appeared to be twice background. That's small enough that people moving around (people are mostly water) was enough to cause such variation. So they moved the experiment to a "neutron cube", a big box built of lead bricks where few background neutrons penetrated. Then there was no significant difference in neutron levels between "off" and "on".
They also tried heat generation measurement. Because you have to put power into the Pons/Fleischman apparatus to get anything to happen (it's not self-sustaining) it's a difficult experiment to do accurately. It requires water jackets, insulation, and lots of measurements. They were unable to detect any heat output above measurement noise.
Challenging group think and being skeptical is part of being a proper scientist. Perhaps they end up learning something entirely new from all of this.
A few years ago, the enormously more respected folks at the OPERA experiment were willing to announce that they had seemingly detected neutrinos moving faster than light. Despite this coming from a large group of scientists with top-notch credentials, that was immediately doubted by almost the entire physics community, and sure enough, the observed effect turned out to have been caused by a bad cable connection.
If anything, conservation of momentum is more deeply embedded in the structure of known physical principles than the speed of light limit. And this little group within NASA doesn't have remotely the level of credibility that OPERA had. So it's even easier for me to believe that this measurement is due to some loose cable or improper calibration or failure to isolate the test environment, too.