Re:What we know about the EmDrive and Cannae Drive
by gus_massa on Friday May 01, 2015 @04:46PM
(#9474405)
Quantum Mechanics is weird but it's not magic. One of the most unintuitive effects is entanglement.
Almost all the entanglements and weird things of Quantum Mechanics are local. The electrons in a molecule have weird antisymmetric properties that mix different configurations (the easy picture is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resonance_(chemistry) the mathematics is more complicated).
You can entangle a few particles and move them at long distance, but if the particles hit another particle, the entanglement goes away. (You can transfer the entanglement, in very specific setups, but it's difficult, usually you get decoherence.)
I don't know a way to transfer a lot of momentum form one point to a very distant point using entanglement.
For example, you can put a box of particles in a rocket and each particle in that box in entangled with a particle that is in a box in Earth. When you measure the momentum of the particle in the rocket, it "changes" the momentum in the particle in Earth, so you can think that some momentum was "transferred". (This is not technically correct, but is a good enough approximation.)
The problem is that the momentum that you measure is in a random distribution, and half of the time you'll "transfer" momentum in one direction to make your rocket faster and the other half of the times the momentum will go in the other direction to make your rocket slower. It's impossible to transfer information using entanglement, and it's impossible to select the direction of the "transferred" momentum, in particular because that could be used to transfer information.
Almost all the entanglements and weird things of Quantum Mechanics are local. The electrons in a molecule have weird antisymmetric properties that mix different configurations (the easy picture is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resonance_(chemistry) the mathematics is more complicated).
You can entangle a few particles and move them at long distance, but if the particles hit another particle, the entanglement goes away. (You can transfer the entanglement, in very specific setups, but it's difficult, usually you get decoherence.)
I don't know a way to transfer a lot of momentum form one point to a very distant point using entanglement.
For example, you can put a box of particles in a rocket and each particle in that box in entangled with a particle that is in a box in Earth. When you measure the momentum of the particle in the rocket, it "changes" the momentum in the particle in Earth, so you can think that some momentum was "transferred". (This is not technically correct, but is a good enough approximation.)
The problem is that the momentum that you measure is in a random distribution, and half of the time you'll "transfer" momentum in one direction to make your rocket faster and the other half of the times the momentum will go in the other direction to make your rocket slower. It's impossible to transfer information using entanglement, and it's impossible to select the direction of the "transferred" momentum, in particular because that could be used to transfer information.