News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @10:49AM (#9408431)
Thank goodness that didn't happen. Tesla is doing amazing things and is on track to seriously shake up the automotive industry. I can't imagine that would be true under Google.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by stevoo on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:45PM (#9409273)
I disagree here. It made me wonder how much more Tesla could have been with Googles power. As the article states, Elon Musk would keep on working on his project for 8 years with extra funding to create the same cars he is now.

If that was the case and with Googles money and power, they might had a better chance of creating a better car as well as adding self driving in the car much faster if we look at google car. ( offcourse that is still years away )

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by freyr on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:22PM (#9409520)
Tesla's goal seems to be making the best electric car they can possibly make, and it shows in their results. We can never know for sure whether Google would have interfered with that goal or diluted their focus, but that's how acquisition stories often turn out.

Funnily enough, having loads of cash doesn't always result in a better product. The awful products that cash-rich companies have churned out in the past decade are too numerous to mention (including several examples from Google).

Also, it's not obvious that a software company can build a great car, or a car company can build great software. User-facing car software has been uniformly awful. Google's self-driving car prototypes, while cute (in the so-ugly-its-cute way), aren't particularly inspiring as automobiles. This separation of concerns lets both companies focus on their strengths (which can be combined down the road, as long as the self-driving technology becomes licensable). Although I imagine Tesla will still build its own self-driving technology, and Google will build more buggies. But even that's preferable to acquisition, because it allows cross-pollination of ideas from two separate entities.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by Crito on Monday April 20, 2015 @03:31PM (#9410304)
> "We can never know for sure whether Google would have interfered with that goal or diluted their focus, but that's how acquisition stories often turn out."

There would be a short production run of small cars with cheerful color schemes (not dissimilar from Car2Go styled smartcars) sold as "development" units. Car journalists would have a difficult time getting their hands on them, but google woud ensure that SF tech bloggers would get them. These cars would stand out in public in all of the wrong ways, and soon anyone driving one would be labeled a techie asshole. Future revisions would never materialize.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by seanp2k2 on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:36PM (#9409598)
Well, considering Google would have done the Model S release with 500 units (as part of an "EV explorers" program), then stopped updating the software, waited 9 months with no news whole competitors built competitive products, then wrote it off as a loss and announced that they're deprecating the product in favor of their new line of RC cars, I think it's good that they haven't sold.

TL;DR name one company Google acquired where they didn't kill that company's awesome product within a couple years, regardless of how awesome / market-leading / profitable it was.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by magicalist on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:21PM (#9409894)
Just going off the ones I recognize from this list[1], older than "a couple years" but since, say, 2009: On2, reCAPTCHA, AdMob, ITA, Widevine, Motorola (though arguably it had no awesome product to maintain), Waze.

But more than half the companies in that range I don't recognize, so maybe their product is still around (or is fully functional, but only within Google Docs or something).

You're also ignoring the fact that many acquisitions wouldn't have survived without being acquired and their products would have shut down (or "pivoted" until they were unrecognizable). Tesla obviously wasn't in that category, but that actually makes it harder to compare to historical data, as few companies really parallel it well.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisition...

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @03:21PM (#9410240)
Waze is a great example. They've basically gone full-on vampire on that one, sucking out all the delicious (user-generated!) data and presumably headed for leaving Waze itself as a desiccated husk.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by magicalist on Monday April 20, 2015 @03:31PM (#9410305)
A great example of what? It hasn't been quite two years (June 11, 2013), but it's still around.

Presumably you mean if it's shut down it will be a great example, but right now it's actually a great example of the opposite: improving the products of the acquiring company while keeping the acquired product going. You could put up more walls between the two, but at some point that becomes just investing, not acquisition.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @03:54PM (#9410450)
I think it's a great example right now. I don't see any benefits from the Google acquisition, and the product is slowly stagnating. The iOS app doesn't even have native iPhone 6+ support yet! Meanwhile Google is making great use of Waze data in Google Maps. The current state of things is great if you're a Maps user, less great if you're a Waze user, and I don't see any indication that's going to change.

Put the Waze acquisition onto Tesla. Google buys Tesla just as the Model S is coming out, and starts using the technology to benefit their own products. Which products it would benefit I'm not sure, but maybe they improve the batteries for Android phones, or start using the Model S as the testbed for their self-driving cars, or something. Meanwhile the Model S stays as it was in 2013, with some minor improvements. This would be a terrible outcome!

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by magicalist on Monday April 20, 2015 @04:12PM (#9410571)
Waze does need to update for the iPhone 6 even (not just the plus), but there are many non-Google apps that need to do the same, and it does still get updates. Supposedly they're working on a UI refresh[1], but that's what everyone who hasn't updated yet says.

I'm not arguing that a Tesla acquisition would have been better than the outcome we got, there's almost no way it would have been, but I would argue that that would be true for any company doing the acquiring. Acquisitions are just really tough for the identity of a product by their very nature.

[1] https://twitter.com/waze/status/584435142040690688

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @04:21PM (#9410635)
"I would argue that that would be true for any company doing the acquiring."

Well then, we agree. I'm not saying, "Thank goodness Google didn't acquire them." I'm saying, "Thank goodness they weren't acquired" and it just happens to be in the context of a story about Google doing the acquiring.

I can't think of any company that could have acquired Tesla where the outcome would have been favorable for the things I personally want. There were rumors going around a while ago about Apple buying them, and my reaction was the same there.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by DavidAdams on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:50PM (#9409690)
Youtube
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:24PM (#9409910)
They're slowly strangling it now with obnoxious ads. These days I typically get an awful video ad before the actual video, a pop-up ad that obscures the video during the video, and I've even started to see cases where they interrupt the video in the middle for another awful video ad. I get that they have to make money somehow, but I think they're going to start strangling the goose that lays the golden eggs if they don't back off some.

It's not yet bad enough to say that they killed YouTube, but I'm afraid they might get there.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by magicalist on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:30PM (#9409940)
Most ads I see are skippable these days, and the uploader can't set an overlay ad and a video ad on their videos. Vevo videos has those annoying "check out this other artist" thing on the side, but I assume they have some special deal in their contract, because no one else seems to be able to do that.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by awad on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:04PM (#9409772)
Android
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by untog on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:55PM (#9409716)
Android?
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:55PM (#9409342)
Tesla's development doesn't look to be particularly constrained by money at the moment. I'd worry that getting a bunch of cash from Uncle Google to expand rapidly would ultimately destroy the company, as compared to organic growth where they can take things at a proper pace.

I also find that eight-year guarantee to be rather unimpressive. The Model 3 will be the true start of Tesla's game changing, and the deal was basically that Tesla could be broken up or killed once the Model 3 showed up.

This deal was only on the table because Tesla was in crisis. The moment they recovered, it went away. Clearly they thought that they could do better on their own than they could if they were part of Google, and I see no reason to disagree.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by aerovistae on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:25PM (#9409537)
Your thoughts seem based on incorrect information.

A. Musk has stated self-driving cars would be essentially finished by this summer, and only the laws and policies are lagging behind and keeping it from being fully released.

B. "How much more they could have been"? They're expanding at a ridiculous pace and are on-track to release a main-stream affordable car within a few years, something the established automakers have evidently been unable to do at all despite all their resources and established infrastructure.

C. "A better car"? What exactly are you comparing it to? Objectively the Model S has gotten the highest scores ever on nearly every single survey it's been part of. If you have a personal quibble with it, don't make out like that's the car's fault. If you're not happy with it "merely" being the best car on the market, I really don't know what you're looking for.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:33PM (#9409584)
Regarding A, are you sure about that? Autopilot is supposed to be essentially finished by this summer, but it's not even close to full self-driving capabilities. The Model S currently doesn't have the necessary sensor suite for full self-driving, and the software side is still deeply unsolved.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by aerovistae on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:45PM (#9409657)
You're correct, my mistake. He said a few years. I misrecalled, so to speak.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:25PM (#9409916)
Confusion about what autopilot can actually do is pretty widespread, and autopilot is announced for the summer, so it's an understandable mixup.

Even a few years would be pretty cool. I hope he's right!

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by Leszek on Monday April 20, 2015 @11:44AM (#9408846)
Out of curiosity, why not?
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:36PM (#9409225)
Acquisitions in general are often bad for the product being acquired. It often gets dismantled for the technology and re-incorporated into different products, or stagnates because the parent company's priorities are different, or just falls victim to internal politics as it becomes just one part of a larger company with many different priorities.

Google seems like a particularly bad acquirer for this as well, since they have no relevant expertise, market position, interests, etc. They don't manufacture anything, they don't sell physical products, they don't even really sell nonphysical products other than ads.

Look at what happened with Motorola Mobility, for example. Google paid a ton of money for it, basically dicked around for a couple of years with it doing nothing of note, then vomited it back up again. Thankfully Motorola Mobility was not terribly remarkable to begin with so it wasn't a big loss.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by dragonwriter on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:56PM (#9409352)
> Look at what happened with Motorola Mobility, for example. Google paid a ton of money for it, basically dicked around for a couple of years with it doing nothing of note, then vomited it back up again.

Google fairly overtly bought it for the patent portfolio and had the plan to resell most of the rest from day one. The thing Google was buying was the patents, the rest of Motorola Mobility was packaging.

Contrast with Android, YouTube, or anything else where Google wasn't buying patents or doing an acquihire, but actually buying a company for a product.

(Google probably looks worse in some respect for products because it has the kind of reserves that let it spend money for big acquisitions when all it wants is an acquihire or some resource like Motorola's patent portfolio and doesn't have any plan or concern for the main product, but I think that's an indication that it is bad when it actually is buying for product.)

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by magicalist on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:43PM (#9409643)
> Look at what happened with Motorola Mobility, for example. Google paid a ton of money for it, basically dicked around for a couple of years with it doing nothing of note, then vomited it back up again

Motorola went from phones I would advise everyone to avoid to phones I actually advised family members to purchase in that time. They're basically the low cost nexus at this point.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by repsilat on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:57PM (#9409368)
> they have no relevant ... interests

I don't know how big a deal the self-driving cars thing is at Google, but a giant car/battery company sounds pretty complementary to that.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:18PM (#9409872)
They're both related to cars, but I don't think they're that complementary. Google's self-driving car project is a moonshot R&D thing that just piles on a ton of computers and sensors to an existing car. It's pretty much unrelated with designing and producing the actual car. To the extent that they would go together, presumably so they could build an integrated self-driving car from the ground up, it fits in to my worries: rather than continue to improve and sell the Model S, the acquisition would tie into another project with a significantly different goal in mind.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by kbenson on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:50PM (#9409319)
Google acquired Motorola for its patents as ammunition in a larger war. I agree it supports your main point about acquisitions in general, but I'm not sure it's indicative of what being bought by Google is like in the general case.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:56PM (#9409353)
It seems like that is the default case for acquisitions with just about any company, and ones where more interesting stuff happens with the acquired company are not the norm.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by virtualSatai on Monday April 20, 2015 @11:56AM (#9408934)
I'm pretty sure it has been seen before that Google or another big tech company buys a smaller up-and-comming company/great idea, and it is never heard from again.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by dragonwriter on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:22PM (#9409138)
> I'm pretty sure it has been seen before that Google or another big tech company buys a smaller up-and-comming company/great idea, and it is never heard from again.

I'm pretty sure the opposite has also been seen [0]; what's the basis for concluding a Google acquisition would have put Tesla closer to the "never heard from again" side?

[0] Google's acquisition of Android, for instance.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by jkestner on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:11PM (#9409055)
Sibling: Google has made a prototype that drives on a virtual track. That's far away from manufacturing a car, let alone a self-driving one.

Relevant: http://www.asymco.com/2015/02/23/the-entrants-guide-to-the-a...

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mschuster91 on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:00PM (#9408963)
Well, Google has fairly much experience in the automobile sector with their self-driving cars.

Shit, a self-driving Tesla, now that is a car worth saving every penny for...

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by eclipxe on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:23PM (#9409141)
Tesla's upcoming autopilot feature is part of the way there. Only a matter of time.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:04PM (#9409422)
In the context of self-driving cars, autopilot is in the category of "we're 90% done, only 90% to go!" Except much worse than that, because that implies you're about halfway there, and autopilot is maybe 10% of the way towards full self-driving.

Don't get me wrong, autopilot is super cool and really useful. The autopilot features that are currently enabled in my Model S are wonderful, and I can't wait until they're all there. But they won't be even close to full self-driving. All it will do is maintain speed intelligently based on the car in front of you, automatically stay in your lane, and switch lanes on command. It won't switch lanes on its own, it won't stop at stoplights, it won't make turns for you, or do any of the hundred other really difficult (for computers) things that are part of everyday driving.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by eco on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:19PM (#9409114)
Haven't you heard what happened to Google Reader? If Google can't even keep small projects with no revenue stream going then how can we trust them with much harder projects for which they will have invested billions of dollars? They'd probably buy Tesla then shut it down immediately. Even if they didn't shut it down Google is an ad company which means it is incapable of deriving profit from anything but advertisements. Google Tesla of today may have been nothing more than a company that sells in-home battery backup for AdWords.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by eco on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:03PM (#9409764)
It's hard to tell if I flew too close to Poe's law, failed at sarcasm, have an minority opinion, or just wasn't contributing to the conversation. Probably a combination.