News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:36PM (#9409225)
Acquisitions in general are often bad for the product being acquired. It often gets dismantled for the technology and re-incorporated into different products, or stagnates because the parent company's priorities are different, or just falls victim to internal politics as it becomes just one part of a larger company with many different priorities.

Google seems like a particularly bad acquirer for this as well, since they have no relevant expertise, market position, interests, etc. They don't manufacture anything, they don't sell physical products, they don't even really sell nonphysical products other than ads.

Look at what happened with Motorola Mobility, for example. Google paid a ton of money for it, basically dicked around for a couple of years with it doing nothing of note, then vomited it back up again. Thankfully Motorola Mobility was not terribly remarkable to begin with so it wasn't a big loss.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by dragonwriter on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:56PM (#9409352)
> Look at what happened with Motorola Mobility, for example. Google paid a ton of money for it, basically dicked around for a couple of years with it doing nothing of note, then vomited it back up again.

Google fairly overtly bought it for the patent portfolio and had the plan to resell most of the rest from day one. The thing Google was buying was the patents, the rest of Motorola Mobility was packaging.

Contrast with Android, YouTube, or anything else where Google wasn't buying patents or doing an acquihire, but actually buying a company for a product.

(Google probably looks worse in some respect for products because it has the kind of reserves that let it spend money for big acquisitions when all it wants is an acquihire or some resource like Motorola's patent portfolio and doesn't have any plan or concern for the main product, but I think that's an indication that it is bad when it actually is buying for product.)

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by magicalist on Monday April 20, 2015 @01:43PM (#9409643)
> Look at what happened with Motorola Mobility, for example. Google paid a ton of money for it, basically dicked around for a couple of years with it doing nothing of note, then vomited it back up again

Motorola went from phones I would advise everyone to avoid to phones I actually advised family members to purchase in that time. They're basically the low cost nexus at this point.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by repsilat on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:57PM (#9409368)
> they have no relevant ... interests

I don't know how big a deal the self-driving cars thing is at Google, but a giant car/battery company sounds pretty complementary to that.

Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @02:18PM (#9409872)
They're both related to cars, but I don't think they're that complementary. Google's self-driving car project is a moonshot R&D thing that just piles on a ton of computers and sensors to an existing car. It's pretty much unrelated with designing and producing the actual car. To the extent that they would go together, presumably so they could build an integrated self-driving car from the ground up, it fits in to my worries: rather than continue to improve and sell the Model S, the acquisition would tie into another project with a significantly different goal in mind.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by kbenson on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:50PM (#9409319)
Google acquired Motorola for its patents as ammunition in a larger war. I agree it supports your main point about acquisitions in general, but I'm not sure it's indicative of what being bought by Google is like in the general case.
Re:Elon Musk Had a Deal to Sell Tesla to Google in 2013 by mikeash on Monday April 20, 2015 @12:56PM (#9409353)
It seems like that is the default case for acquisitions with just about any company, and ones where more interesting stuff happens with the acquired company are not the norm.