News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by rayiner on Sunday April 19, 2015 @11:58AM (#9403606)
I always give cash if I have some on hand. Good odds they'll use it to buy a drink, which is fine because hell, I need a drink after a long day and I'm not even homeless. And there is a non-zero chance he or she really does need it to get food or get in from the cold for the night. Wouldn't want to risk not giving money when there was a genuine need because I'm worried about the case where there isn't.
Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by marcusgarvey on Sunday April 19, 2015 @12:21PM (#9403688)
>Good odds they'll use it to buy a drink, which is fine because hell, I need a drink after a long day and I'm not even homeless.

Thanks for saying this. The homeless and the poor are human beings and should not be demonized for having the niceties that make anyone's life more joyful. (Kansas, I'm not so sure you're doing it right [1].)

I once read about and have since admired a very enlightened approach to this, in the UK: when measuring the average cost of living in addition to things like food and shelter they will also include the money that a household would need to take a one-week vacation.

[1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/govbeat/wp/2015/04/06/ka...

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by IkmoIkmo on Sunday April 19, 2015 @02:16PM (#9404137)
> they will also include the money that a household would need to take a one-week vacation.

Pretty standard (Western) Europe welfare model afaik. Here in the Netherlands it's called 'vacation money', and if you don't have a job and can show you're applying for one, you'll get a minimum wage income and vacation money is indeed included in that as a bonus once a year.

> the poor are human beings and should not be demonized for having the niceties

Absolutely, but you mentioned the UK. I visited the Emmaus centre in Cambridge a few years ago, all the lads there (ex homeless often for more than a decade) told me to never give money because buying alcohol isn't just 'nice', it's a disease that destroys people and there are alternative solutions. They all lived that life.

I'm not going to say 'don't give', but if you somehow know for certain it's spent on alcohol, I definitely would say don't give. At least, taking it from ex homeless guys who still struggle with alcoholism and the life they live now at Emmaus.

Perhaps it's different in various shitholes in the world where there is nothing to rely on, I can imagine alcohol being a sensible temporary relief, but in cities with capacity for homelessness issues, it's not a good choice. And if you look at Europe for example, you'll find that e.g. the Council of Europe has ruled various times now that not just citizens, but also refugees, all of them, without fail, are to be provided a minimum of shelter, food and clothes.

Not saying it's a perfect situation, far from it, and sadly professional homelessness relief still relies way too heavily on charity and voluntarism, but in many cities giving money for alcohol is simple not the best thing to do at best, and harmful at worst.

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by hueving on Sunday April 19, 2015 @02:04PM (#9404084)
Alcoholism doesn't make life more joyful. That's the level of drinking many homeless people do.
Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by marcusgarvey on Sunday April 19, 2015 @04:26PM (#9404742)
I'm not condoning the encouragement of alcoholism. But I absolutely applaud anyone or any policy that recognizes that poor and homeless people are...people.
Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by cynicalkane on Sunday April 19, 2015 @12:18PM (#9403678)
I'm not an expert, but I've heard from authorities on the subject that the "deserving homeless" is almost entirely a myth. The scenario of someone who is down on their luck and has to beg is rare, and they tend to do that for a relatively short amount of time. The odds are strong that you are giving your money to a person suffering from substance abuse or mental illness.

Then again, I just moved to New York, and I'm naturally biased towards interpretations that match my recent personal experience.

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by foldr on Sunday April 19, 2015 @12:55PM (#9403824)
People with mental health problems and drug addictions also "deserve" to have enough money to live on. Even if you insist on seeing these things as moral failings, aren't they already being punished enough?
Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by cynicalkane on Sunday April 19, 2015 @03:03PM (#9404345)
You are arguing against a very insulting straw man, and I would ordinarily not consider you not worth addressing except that a lot of people apparently think along the same ridiculous lines.

Panhandlers in major cities are at low risk of not having food available to them. The idea of the 'starving homeless' is another counterfactual myth, just as much as the 'deserving homeless'--but if it really concerns you, there are far more directly expedient ways of helping them than giving away money. Services and shelters for the homeless are pretty terrible, but I've never heard anyone credible say that these services are worse than the shortsighted, feel-good solution of giving people money they are fundamentally incapable of spending correctly.

By contrast, it is common for the homeless to die of exposure--not because they had no shelter available, but because they are mentally ill and fell into a pattern of denying it to themselves, even on the coldest days.

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by tptacek on Sunday April 19, 2015 @04:34PM (#9404773)
Look. If you want to give cash to homeless people, do that. If you want to give to shelters instead, do that. If you want to send your money to Partners in Health to provide medical care for innocent people in other countries far worse off than homeless in the US, do that. If you want to give your money to the Republican party so they can pass legislation restricting same-sex marriage because that is truly what you believe in, do that. If instead you want to save your money and ensure your children have an easy time getting through college: fine. If instead you want to keep it for yourself for your retirement to ease the burden on the rest of us: also OK. Want to buy 6 PS4 consoles so you can use an HDMI switch to select different games without reloading them or physically getting up to insert a disk in their drive? Fine too. Nachos. Fine. Guns. Fine. Meth. Sandwiches. Ferrets. Lightbulbs. Nobody cares.

Where you lose people is telling other people that they're wrong to give cash to homeless people.

What's worse is, this thread kicked off with someone laying out in very simple terms --- terms you didn't really address --- the logic behind giving money on the street despite not knowing the purposes to which the money would be put.

You can argue however you want, including that people are wrong to give money on the street, and that it's not OK for them to give to homeless people or buy ferrets or whatever. But you shouldn't act hurt when people argue back at you.

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by TulliusCicero on Sunday April 19, 2015 @05:27PM (#9404946)
> Where you lose people is telling other people that they're wrong to give cash to homeless people.

Why not? We encourage other people to do things all the time. I certainly encourage people to vaccinate their kids. Donating money to people who will immediately spend it on substance abuse is harmful to them. You're making yourself feel better about how you're SUCH a compassionate person at their long-term expense.

I laugh at people going, "b-b-but they're still human!!!" Like, do you donate cash on the street to non-homeless/non-panhandlers too? Yeah they're still human, why does that mean it's bad if I think about what they'll use my money for before >>donating<< it? Now if they want to earn money by working for me in some capacity, sure, they can spend it however they want. That's a completely different type of transaction.

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by tptacek on Sunday April 19, 2015 @06:12PM (#9405077)
You may have replied to the wrong comment.
Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by cynicalkane on Sunday April 19, 2015 @11:06PM (#9405925)
I disagree with rayiner in that I think the things he thinks are good are actually bad, not worth feeling good about, and furthermore bad for society. Whether or not you agree, I think this is a pretty meaningful point of difference, and not sure what variety of alternate interpretation led to your epic rant.

We're not talking about Pareto-optimal market transactions here; the externalities are the point of giving money away or not giving money away. So it's an interesting position, telling me I am "wrong" for being concerned about whether one is purposefully helping or harming others. It's probably a good thing that most of the world does not share your interesting perspective.

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by foldr on Sunday April 19, 2015 @03:24PM (#9404442)
Speaking of straw men, please note that I didn't say anything about people starving.

By all means, give money to shelters etc. But why not also give money to homeless people? The two are not mutually exclusive. You are repeating the usual mean-spirited argument that we shouldn't give homeless people money because they might spend it on things we don't approve of. But so what? It's their life, not ours. Charity with strings attached isn't charity.

I find it a useful exercise to imagine applying the same logic in dealing with comfortably well-off middle class people. If such a person has an alcohol problem, the usual reaction amongst reasonably enlightened people is to try to find that person help. We don't try to cut off all of their sources of income on the grounds that they'll just spend it all on booze. Now, perhaps some of them will spend all of their income on booze, but since we aren't so much in the habit of completely dehumanizing them, we recognize that this is still their choice to make.

The bottom line here is that drug and alcohol habits don't cost infinite amounts of money. You can perfectly well spend some of your money on drugs and the rest on food, etc. Unless you have some kind of moral objection to people using drugs, why should you care if a homeless person is spending some of their money that way? It's judgmental and mean to refuse them money because you suspect that they might be going to do this.

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by cynicalkane on Sunday April 19, 2015 @03:40PM (#9404529)
Enabling the patterns of mental illness and addiction is linked to negative outcomes, not positive ones. These negative outcomes include death from voluntary exposure.
Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by foldr on Sunday April 19, 2015 @05:09PM (#9404891)
So would you apply the same logic in the case of middle class people? Should we also try to ensure that they receive no income if they are drug addicts?

If you are absolutely sure that you know what's best for homeless people, and that they don't, then don't give them your money. Personally, I am not so sure.

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by rayiner on Sunday April 19, 2015 @02:02PM (#9404079)
Does the fact that they may not "deserve it" mean that they don't get satisfaction from it?

Something my wife and I have been mulling lately is the concept of "grace." She has concluded that means being able to be generous to people who don't necessarily deserve it. I'm not quite there yet but I'm trying to get there.

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by jarin on Sunday April 19, 2015 @12:39PM (#9403764)
The "deserving homeless" are generally able to take advantage of resources that are available, like shelters, soup kitchens, etc.

Although I hate that term, because it's bad enough that we're already divided by class in this country, and now we have to impose our own classes on the homeless?

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by noir_lord on Sunday April 19, 2015 @08:03PM (#9405415)
My mother was homeless for 6 months due to mental illness and an inability to access services (such as they where) so trust me when I tell you this is a truly heartfelt fuck you.
Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by dghughes on Sunday April 19, 2015 @10:36PM (#9405849)
This is the modern problem though at least in my region, most people don't carry any cash at all not even coins. Everything is bought using debit cards even credit cards are not as common as debit.

Even the parking meters here have stickers with numbers on them and you use an app (Hotspot) to add money to that meters, although you can still use change of course.

Elderly people are the only people I know of who use coins and cash.

Re:Homeless Millennials Are Transforming Hobo Culture by beachstartup on Sunday April 19, 2015 @02:30PM (#9404193)
i usually don't give money to homeless people although i will help them if they need something specific.

i don't judge them at all because i (we all) have the same vices just in less debilitating incarnations, but at the end of the day... well, i don't hand out cash to non-homeless strangers either.