Doctors are not infallible, but neither are they idiots. Before suggesting a radical departure for how medicine works, it may be worthwhile to learn a lot more about why it is the way it is right now.
>Just methodically working through the safe, first-line treatments to the major disease classes, taking each for a month or so and seeing what happens, would probably fix 90% of people's chronic illnesses.
90% huh? I'm in no way confident that we have a diverse enough set of interventions in our medical toolkit to fix that much, or that we could find the proper one in a suitable amount of time.
I say this because the causes of idiopathic diseases, when revealed, seem to be similar in structure to the causes of idiopathically failing companies, or idiopathically broken computers, or idiopathically recidivist criminals: namely, that there is some obvious-after-the-fact property of the environment, which combines with a person who never learned how to deal with/be hygienic in the case of/avoid that property. Computers choke on dust; criminals have friends/family who are in debt and need money; companies hire workers based on status rather than efficacy. None of the subjects of these forces realize that they need to do something about them (clean the computer; get their family to declare bankruptcy; give objective tests to their workers), so they get worse and worse until someone who actually knows enough about their life, while also not being immersed in the subculture that is missing the hygienic knowledge, comes along and helps them.
For the case of criminals (and bad parents), this is the job of social workers. For dentistry, you've got dental hygienists. But who is supposed to teach people how to avoid fungal infections, if it's not part of their implicit cultural package of knowledge? Who's supposed to teach them why they should care about the effects of their diet on their blood pressure, if hey have no family history of hypertension? Etc.
And because of that gap in cultural hygiene-knowledge transmission, I have a strong feeling that a few interventions that directly target the knowledge gaps equivalent to "have you tried blowing compressed air into the computer's vent?" Would have an extremely outsized impact in these cases.
Then nobody would do the first line, and the whole point would be moot.
Doctors are rightfully conservative. There have been eras (the '50's, for example) where this was not such a big deal, and the results were generally not good. Today's doctors are still working in the shadow of those events, with even more powerful tools.
So while I do see the point you are making, it isn't really that odd that doctors are loathe to treat in the absense of a diagnosis.
This is a principal-agent problem. Doctors don't have much incentive to cure you. They have a strong incentive to avoid malpractice lawsuits. Thus they are extremely risk-averse.
http://thehealthcareblog.com/blog/2015/04/05/radiologists-vs...
In addition I think he's just ridiculing whatever Mark Cuban said and not really engaging with it.
All in all I'd say that article is an example of what health care professionals can say that makes people doubt their ability to think outside any sort of box.
Edit: Coming back to say that I've just reread that article again and want to downgrade my summary to say that it is a really really terrible piece of writing contributing nothing at all to any debate.
A particular course of action can sound unscientific by the standards of research where you are trying to to solve the disease, but something that sounds like a shot in the dark when nothing else is working could advance the primary goal of improving the patient's health as long as close attention is paid to increased risks.
Actually the IOM says that the best practice is to try different treatments first, and then try to figure out the cause later. (You can see this in their report on pain management.) But the government continues to pass new laws to criminalize the suggested best practices of its own top doctors and medical researchers.
Sure! Except the corner pharmacy has literally thousands of different pills in it. How does your daring doctor know where to start? How do they know where to go next, if that doesn't work?
It makes sense if you're dealing with hypochondriacs or drug-seekers, and it makes epidemiological sense to withhold some treatments from prophylactic use (like antibiotics) to preserve their efficacy. But if you're dealing with an idiopathic illness for over four years, I would think there would come a time where you'd ask the doctor, "can I just try some antibiotics to see what happens? And how about some antiretrovirals, antiparasitics, and antifungals while you're at it?"
Just methodically working through the safe, first-line treatments to the major disease classes, taking each for a month or so and seeing what happens, would probably fix 90% of people's chronic illnesses. Even if it didn't, paying attention to people's reactions to being on various medications are some of the best diagnostic tools there are—which second-line treatment regime to pursue would likely become rapidly apparent.
But instead, people can go years slowly dying from something that they could fix with a few pills from the corner pharmacy, if a doctor would deign to "tinker" rather than working from theory.