News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by dagw on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:04AM (#9379706)
Come on. Nokia was doing a fine job of lowering the value of their handset business on their own.
Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by pavlov on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:44AM (#9379844)
Yeah. It wasn't Elop who created one of the most dysfunctional software development units ever. He was brought in when the damage of previous bad management was just becoming fully apparent.

Nokia in 2007-2010 was spending many times more than Apple on R&D. For that money, they got multiple infighting operating system teams each developing their own half-baked thing (Symbian, MeeGo, Qt, S40) and device teams that were building uncompetitive devices on top of 3-year-old software.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by josh2600 on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @08:25AM (#9380450)
Two words: burning platform.

http://communities-dominate.blogs.com/brands/2012/06/the-fin...

There was just no reason to write a memo like that. It destroyed their business, almost singlehandedly, and no, I'm not exaggerating. The consequences of that memo were insane: Nokia's handset sales died all over the world all at once.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by pavlov on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @10:25AM (#9381137)
We don't have more than quarter-level visibility. All we know is that Q1 2011 sales crashed and Elop wrote his memo. Which is the cause and which the consequence?

In Q4 2010, Nokia stuffed the channel with outdated products. In a market that was growing accustomed to iPhone and Android, Nokia tried to sell consumers products based on the first touch edition of Symbian S60 -- the same software that was considered outdated when it first shipped in Nokia 5800 years earlier. (Because of the way Nokia's product development pipeline worked, the mid-range phones they released in late 2010 contained software that was several years old.)

Isn't it possible that Nokia's Q1 2011 sales crashed simply because the channel was full of Symbian phones that just were not selling? As CEO, Elop would have visibility into that when he wrote his infamous memo.

A point against the "evil memo destroyed sales" theory is that purchasers at large operators don't turn on a dime. When they stopped buying Nokia's phones in Q1 2011, the decision was already made earlier.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by josh2600 on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:32PM (#9384325)
The fallout from that memo was instantaneous and widespread. I worked in wireless at the time and everyone I knew at all of the carriers began to pull Nokia inventory. This was not true in many markets.

Even if the burning platform concept was correct, releasing it in a companywide email instead of strategically shifting the company and then announcing the change in a measured, considered fashion would've been much better for their cash flows.

Purchasers at large operators don't turn on a dime, usually, but I would argue that the CEO of a handset manufacturer declaring their entire existing lineup of products is going to be discontinued in viscerally graphic terms is one of the things that might spur such quick change.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by zokier on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @12:22PM (#9382062)
> There was just no reason to write a memo like that

There was a very good reason to write it. Internally Nokia was delusional and confused, and desperately needed a wake-up call. Nothing less would have sufficed.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by josh2600 on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:24PM (#9384269)
Nokia was delusional internally, but can you really make an argument that what they did was reasonable? Is there any world where it was better for them to choose Windows over Android?

That only happened because of Elop's previous Microsoft connections and it was clearly the wrong decision for the shareholders of the company.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by cwyers on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @03:32PM (#9383490)
"By every measure that the industry uses, Nokia Symbian smartphone sales grew from Q3 of 2010 to Q4 of 2010, literally the last full quarter before Elop released his Burning Platforms memo."

Q4 sales were higher than Q3 sales? I'm, uh... how about year-over-year comparisons? A seasonally-adjusted smoothed trendline? Anything OTHER than comparing sales figures in one quarter where there's Christmas and one quarter where there isn't?

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by digi_owl on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @09:30AM (#9380806)
Qt was bought in part to attempt to bridge Maemo/Meego and Symbian. Problem, in part, was that previous Maemo versions, as well as Intels Moblin project, used GTK. With Maemo5 you had a massive culture clash, that pretty much ripped the community down the middle.

Then the CEO was ousted, Elop brought in, and shit really hit the fan.

Then again, maybe Maemo should have just died at that point, rather than be resurrected as Mer/Sailfish. The whole thing produced ripples that seems set to yank the larger Linux community apart.

While Maemo was Debian in a mobile device, Mer/Sailfish at this point is as close to that as Android is.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by mikegioia on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @07:26PM (#9384935)

    While Maemo was Debian in a mobile device, Mer/Sailfish at
    this point is as close to that as Android is.
Which is truly tragic. I'm not sure if many have experience using Maemo5 (especially the community build) but it represents the apex of phone operating systems in my opinion. Nothing is as pleasant to use, and to think that devices it was built for max out at 256MB of memory.

This is why the Neo900 is so interesting and needed because for the first time, we could get modern hardware in the n900's perfect case, with the community Maemo OS. I just wish it was easier to develop for that operating system >_<

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by mikegioia on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @08:17AM (#9380409)
For anyone interested in this (very good) story, you can read about it here: http://taskumuro.com/artikkelit/the-story-of-nokia-meego
Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by Aoyagi on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:56AM (#9379880)
Yes, but Symbian development was spinning up again, MeeGo had an amazing potential. WP was absolutely not ready to be sold.
Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by dagw on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @06:19AM (#9379956)
I was working at a place trying to do smartphone type stuff with symbian way before it was cool and have been a MeeGo fan since the days when it was called Maemo so I'm about as a big a fanboy of both as they come.

But the truth is that Symbian had simply been stagnant for too long and would never catch up and MeeGo for all its potential was just another platform with even less backing than WP and even less ready to be sold. Had they decided to really go for it with on of Symbian or MeeGo a few years earlier and gotten on the smartphone bandwagon then I might have my MeeGo Lumia device I so wanted, but they didn't and by the time they realized their mistake it was too late. As much as I hate to admit it and as much as it didn't necessarily work out very well, going with WP was probably a good decision at the time

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by Aoyagi on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @06:31AM (#9379984)
Yeah, it's true that the stagnation was a huge letdown, but when N8 and later 808 came out, I strongly believe the OS was (and still is to a degree) competitive. Incomparably more so than WP7 devices which first came out around the time of 808 as well.

Just out of curiosity, what do you mean "smartphone type stuff"? Symbian has been a smartphone OS since its inception.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by Aoyagi on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @07:21AM (#9380153)
@Sammi

Did not compare in speed/pretty animations, collection of "apps", and marketing. What else? Would you like me to list how doesn't the latest iOS compare to latest Symbian?

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by pavlov on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @08:07AM (#9380347)
Did not compare in speed/pretty animations, collection of "apps", and marketing.

So you're saying it was slow, kind of ugly, had no apps and the brand was so tainted that nobody wanted it.

Don't you think those are good reasons for abandoning Symbian?

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by Aoyagi on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @08:32AM (#9380504)
No, I'm not saying that. It's "slow" in comparison with whatever iPhone was out back then, but hardly slow in general. The same as Android is "slow" compared to latest iOS and WP. That argument is silly, sorry. Not to mention the speed was in part due to the low-performance hardware they used. I don't care about "pretty", I care about "functional". It had majority of necessary features built in. It wasn't tainted and nobody wanted it (the 808) because there was virtually no marketing for it and because it was simply unavailable on some major markets. Almost as if they didn't want it to sell.

So no, I don't think those are good reasons for abandoning any OS. Not for power-users anyway. iPhone is better in media consumption, that's it and that's what majority is after. And bandwagons, obviously.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by Sammi on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @07:14AM (#9380124)
The iPhone set a new standard for smartphones. Symbian did not compare.
Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by digi_owl on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @09:36AM (#9380846)
A new standard in "feed me entertainment!" perhaps.

At launch of iPhone Nokia had featurephones that were more capable.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by yrlson on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @10:36AM (#9381223)
You are maybe talking past each other a little. It wasn't case the case that the phones just lacked an app store. What really sucked about Nokia's symbian phones was the UI and the price tag. Now that's the fault of dysfunction within Nokia and not the fault of Symbian per se, but the fact remains if Nokia had just switched to Android it would likely still exist as a mobile phone company.
Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by digi_owl on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @11:14AM (#9381479)
The argument against going Android was to avoid being another "me to" company. Back then the mantra of the Nokia leadership was "differentiation" (it was basically their response to why they could not open source the power management on the N800).

And if one look at the current Android market, they may be right. Samsung is only where it is right now because of a massive marketing push in the last few years.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by digi_owl on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @09:33AM (#9380823)
Symbian may have been stagnant, but unless you are a Wall Street day trader you didn't much care. Symbian could demo capabilities that iOS and Android are just now sprouting (and the press is going gaga about it as if it is something completely new groan).
Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by amyjess on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @11:02AM (#9381396)
My best friend got an E90 shortly after it came out. I was so jealous of him for ages.

The dialer was particularly awesome. It was the first time I saw a dialer that a) had untrained voice dialing and b) had vocal caller ID.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by aduitsis on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @06:03PM (#9384500)
+1

I had untrained voice dialing IN GREEK for years on my Nokia 701. And it actually worked correctly!

My brand new kitkat-soon-to-be-lolipop device cannot even voice dial English names.

Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @08:11AM (#9380375)
Every little bit helps!
Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by bitL on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:22AM (#9379773)
He is absolutely right.
Re:Nokia Agrees to Buy Alcatel-Lucent for $16.6B by bitL on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @11:51AM (#9381768)
For those of you in the downvote mood please search about the hidden bonus given by NOKIA's board to Elop in his original contract for selling off phone division and then carefully evaluate the steps he did. His execution was almost perfect in the light of this "small part" of his contract.