News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by Balgair on Monday April 13, 2015 @01:10PM (#9368900)
Necessity is the mother of invention. The Chinese had very high grade porcelain for many of their household needs. As a consequence, they never bothered to invent glass for these needs. Europe and the Middle East did, and also discovered the telescope and microscope along the way. Porcelain is arguably better for mugs and bowls and can be made much thinner than glass can. However, that happy little accident of history gave the western barbarians a slight edge in one realm of civilization.

So, could we rebuild our civilization without fossil fuels? Maybe. Likely no, it would be different and very strange to our eyes. Heck, it might even be 'better', as they then would not be dealing with our particular type of climate change. Though, they may have their own problems to deal with.

The grass is always greener...

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by contingencies on Monday April 13, 2015 @06:47PM (#9371029)
For the record, the earliest known (Nimrud or Layard) lens came from naturally occurring rock-crystal and was recovered in Iraq, which is between China and western Europe. (Also, the Egyptians had lenses.) Also, Chinese astronomy was far more advanced than western astronomy until recent times, even without telescopes (introduced in the 17th century), in part due to cross-pollination with Persian, Indian and Islamic astronomy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nimrud_lens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_astronomy
Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by tripzilch on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:23PM (#9384263)
Wouldn't one rather grind such a transparent material to a thin bowl (which would be much clearer) and fill it with a tiny amount of clear water?
Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by api on Monday April 13, 2015 @03:07PM (#9369693)
I also sometimes wonder if we might create a slower buy culturally deeper and more contemplative civilization without the crystal meth that is fossil fuel.

But then again maybe not. Maybe we'd never overcome the activation energy for innovation. You can't do true experiments in history.

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by vacri on Monday April 13, 2015 @09:58PM (#9371646)
'Culturally deeper'? Western civilisation is the most complex culture the world has ever known.

There seems to be this strange idea that 'culture' means 'has a religious festival' or somesuch. You hear of some traveller lionising a travel destination as being so culturally deep because they happened to visit when a festival was on. Then, because the home country doesn't have that festival or ritual, it's seen as culturally bereft.

There is a ridiculously wide assortment of activities you can get involved in when you're not a scratching at the earth for subsistence - including debating the difference in what 'culture' means with someone on the other side of the world. Whether you're seeing a movie, running a fantasy football league, doling out soup in a soup kitchen, filibustering to stop some random law, fishing through your credit cards for one the plane's entertainment system will accept, chewing the fat with a passerby while sitting on your stoop on a hot night, spending a Saturday doing a gastro-tour of a great vineyard region... pretty much any activity you can think of, right down to submitting your tax forms... these are all culture. The more different kinds of people you throw together, the greater the variety of cultural activities available.

The idea that we are culturally bereft is just plain wrong. We may not have our priorities right with certain aspects of our culture, but we are drowning in culture. I just don't see how culture would be 'deeper' with less interaction between people from the removal of fossil fuels - we had that for human history up until a couple of hundred years ago, and culture was both slow to change and quite unfair, without being any deeper than it is now.

/rant

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by fleitz on Monday April 13, 2015 @06:08PM (#9370837)
We exist because our ancestors fucked up our nice nitrogen only atmosphere by polluting with deadly reactive oxygen.

Damn cyanobacteria thinking unsustainably and killing the planet for everyone else...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by InclinedPlane on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @02:33AM (#9372456)
Nature is opportunistic and, to some degree, utterly immoral. The "pollution" of cyanobacteria creating an Oxygen rich atmosphere or of lignin rich trees littering the world with their branches, trunks, and stumps that wouldn't be biodegradable for tens of millions of years, all of that pales in comparison to the raw brutality of the food chain. Organisms murder one another in cold blood to steal the nutrients of their bodies. It doesn't get more opportunistic and selfish than that, but that's nature. It's only since mankind got the upper hand on nature that it's been possible to view nature in any other light than primarily harsh and uncaring (like a supernova or volcano). Humanities tendencies towards selfishness and opportunism are perfectly natural, asking us to be different is actually asking humans to be unnatural.

Which I think is justified, but we should make clear what is being asked and not painting humans as being something their not (i.e. uniquely exploitive, violent, selfish, etc.)

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by fleitz on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @07:27PM (#9377986)
Exactly, nature does what works.

The biodegradability thing is pretty funny too, again human waste absolutely pales in comparison to trees and lignin, at least water bottles can't reproduce.

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by joe_inferno on Monday April 13, 2015 @06:37PM (#9370982)
I can't tell if your post is sarcasm or not, but I'd just like to point out that while not perfect we have 1) intelligence as individuals and 2) political mechanisms as a species that would enable a change of course (if one is possible to begin with) whereas the cyanobacteria lacked both of those things.
Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by fleitz on Monday April 13, 2015 @08:50PM (#9371439)
It's the satirization of the idea that 'mother nature' is some kind of right thinking steward of life on this planet that you commonly find amongst people who call fossil fuels meth.

Similar to the way one might satirize traditional marriage by pointing out that tradition advocates a lot of things that traditional marriage people would find abhorrent, if you take a view of tradition that extends past the start of the industrial revolution.

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by Jedd on Monday April 13, 2015 @08:13PM (#9371337)
I don't think fleitz was being sarcastic per se - certainly I didn't read it as suggesting human evolution was a 'bad thing'.

Rather pointing out that (at the time) oxygen in the atmosphere was hostile to more complex forms of life. As we know, oxygen is a pretty unpleasant element in its raw state - but we managed to work around that particular problem.

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by houk on Monday April 13, 2015 @08:15PM (#9371345)
it was sarcasm.
Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by cma on Monday April 13, 2015 @04:46PM (#9370377)
They still might have come up with glass for other reasons... porcelain windows?
Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by kijin on Monday April 13, 2015 @09:34PM (#9371581)
Chinese windows used to be covered with paper. Plenty of light gets through, although you'd have to open the windows or actually go outside to see what's outside. (Apparently, viewing the outside in the comfort of your bedroom is a luxury that most people don't need.)

In warmer regions, people would just tear out the paper in the summer and apply new paper before winter.

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by will_work4tears on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @10:55AM (#9374704)
I may have glass windows, but usually they are covered up with blinds and or curtains. Especially in the bedroom. It's nice to be able to open them up and let light in when I need to, but I wouldn't put it on a list of necessities.
Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by ctdonath on Monday April 13, 2015 @05:17PM (#9370577)
IIRC, the Incas did pretty well for not inventing the wheel.
Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by ctdonath on Monday April 13, 2015 @10:49PM (#9371849)
Downvoters: seriously, the Incas didn't invent/use the wheel. Go google "inca wheel".
Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by tsotha on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @12:20AM (#9372084)
They probably could have used that wheel when Pizarro showed up.
Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Monday April 13, 2015 @03:47PM (#9369950)
How would you be able to make glass without fossil fuels?

We've already deforested the planet... you don't get to burn biomass.

A modern, technological civilization gets one bite at the apple, no more (unless they can manage to make it to another planet, where they have all the starting blocks to work with). You don't even get to salvage much from the previous civilization, since all but the crudest products go stale pretty quickly.

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by Balgair on Monday April 13, 2015 @04:26PM (#9370208)
Oh, for a post-apocalyptic world? There, of course, would be challenges to 're-do' the world to where we are now. Hopefully it never comes to that, but those people will probably be a lot different than we are now. Heck, we are a lot different then our grandparents are in terms of tech and what we think is obvious as a tech.

Also, I dont think most of the material will be lost. Take aluminum. It's nearly un'rust'able and really doesn't degrade over the time spans we are talking about. Making it from scratch is not obvious, you need electrolysis [1] and some other not terribly clear ideas. That said, you can do it in a garage; you don't need a foundry. And those ideas are likely to survive the end of the world, seeing as aluminum is so useful.

Overall, ideas are like genetics, once you get one great working thing it's hard to loose that mechanism. Give yourself more credit, you are smarter than you think.

[1]http://www.chemguide.co.uk/inorganic/extraction/aluminium.ht...

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by visarga on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @12:46AM (#9372155)
We could also cultivate algae. There is the "open-pond" system and the "vertical growth" system where water is cycled into an installation made of transparent bags. Algae take nutrients from the water (and light from the sun) to develop and are then filtered out as they grow. They turn the algae into biofuel (algal oil).

http://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/green-science...

and

http://www.biofuelsdigest.com/bdigest/2014/10/13/where-are-w...

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @01:34PM (#9375900)
No, we couldn't cultivate algae. You don't get good at that stuff until after you've already had an industrial civilization for a hundred or more years.

Where will you get the "transparent bags", for instance? Sure after the algae fuels are going good, presumably you can make anything you need... but that's the bootstrapping problem again.

Do you know what you needed to start using petroleum? 18th/19th century pumping equipment. Can you bootstrap biofuels with that?

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by tsotha on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @12:24AM (#9372095)
We have not "deforested the planet". What are you running on about?

You can make glass without fossil fuels. If you have energy you can make fossil fuels from air. The key part to replacing fossil fuels is having the energy. Hopefully cheap and in great supply.

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @01:37PM (#9375919)
> We have not "deforested the planet". What are you running on about?

Take a look at the before and after pictures. Forest covered half of North America. It's all gone. Prior to that, covered most of Europe, the British Isles.

We've deforested it. It takes something on the order a million years for that to recover, supposing it does.

> If you have energy you can make fossil fuels from air.

We're talking about a scenario where they won't have the energy to do that. It's a bootstrapping problem. Everyone commenting here is saying "but that's ok, we'll have all we need to make this fancy stuff"...

When the problem itself is posed as "what if we no longer have all we need to make fancy stuff".

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by tsotha on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @04:40PM (#9377171)
>Take a look at the before and after pictures. Forest covered half of North America. It's all gone.

Pictures of North America? What pictures? North America is more heavily forested than it was 100 years ago.

>We're talking about a scenario where they won't have the energy to do that. It's a bootstrapping problem.

We can do it with nuclear power. Maybe even renewables, depending on what happens with battery technology.

>When the problem itself is posed as "what if we no longer have all we need to make fancy stuff"

That will never happen. There are options. It's just a question of what makes the most sense.

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @01:36PM (#9375912)
> We have not "deforested the planet". What are you running on about?

Take a look at the before and after pictures. Forest covered half of North America. It's all gone. Prior to that, covered most of Europe, the British Isles.

We've deforested it. It takes something on the order a million years for that to recover, supposing it does.

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by InclinedPlane on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @02:39AM (#9372471)
Care to back up your deforestation assertion with research?

The reality is that there's been a significant amount of reforestation around the world. Some parts are better off than others, but in the US and Europe, for examples, there is more forest today than there was in the late 19th century.

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @01:41PM (#9375952)
The late 19th century was already how many centuries into the industrial revolution?

If you're just going to pick irrelevant, arbitrary comparison points, why not claim that it's gotten better since 1982?

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by tripzilch on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:30PM (#9384314)
Slightly more than one century. Definitely not centurieS.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Industrial_Revolution

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by PepeGomez on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @09:16AM (#9373942)
>How would you be able to make glass without fossil fuels?

I think that glass is much older than you think.

Re:Could we reboot a modern civilization without fossil fuels? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @01:40PM (#9375942)
I think you're being disingenuous.

Can a caveman melt some sand in a woodfire? Yeh probably.

That glass will be worthless for any sort of technology. And by the time he can make better glass, he's all out of stuff to burn.

You don't get to do technological civilization twice. The first one uses up all the easy-to-use resources, and supposing there is anything left at all, it won't be usable without the technology that they won't have.

Europe got to use glass because it had plenty of forests to burn. Those are gone. They won't be coming back any time soon.