I think if you stick to any given topic (hacking, politics, biotech, environmental, etc.) you have a lesser chance of the site becoming a giant cesspool of repeated lame topics.
The editors seem like great training wheels and a good sanity check over time. But I'm really curious if they become irrelevant as the community takes on life. Seems like you could test this hypothesis by using karma-votes to predict edited-votes. Drift could then be measured as that prediction varies from the edited standard.
My personal tactic is to be nasty to posters of crap. It has more impact than some mere 'point', and gives them guidance as to what's wrong.
There is not, IMO, a great technical "solution". There are technical things that need to be in place to put a floor in - to keep things from going to pot, but the most important thing is to put a lot of emphasis on creating a good community and communicating its values to new members. Some aspects of that that I think are valuable:
- No politics. I think it's even worthwhile to sacrifice things that are (to me) potentially interesting, like economics, where they get too political. As long as we keep things on the subset of subjects that we know about and are interested in (tech, startups, defined broadly), we're more likely to find common ground, and be able to comment intelligently.
- Don't vote people into oblivion unless they're being seriously lame, on purpose. A 0 or -1 is enough to indicate disapproval.
- Don't say things you wouldn't say to someone's face.
- If you see something by the user 'pg', be sure to vote it up;-)
http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Has some others.
And the beauty here of karma is that it inherently isn't just activity. Fundamentally it is a gauge of quality because people make informed decisions on what to value when they vote. For instance, you could submit every story, every day, from digg's front page and this community won't reward you (much). Better to make more informed decisions about what to submit, if you value your time. The goal isn't submission - it's submission to a community standard.
I was asking for ideas for future reference regarding sites with social components. It seems to be a common problem online: how to avoid the troll issue and signal to noise degradation issue.
I was thinking that votes could be weighted based on length of stay, or karma or both. Users who've been around longer and who had higher karma are obviously more invested in the site than hoards of users that just started.
@PG: I really hadn't thought of weighting everyone's votes similar to the editors. A nice, elegant solution I think.
I don't have this turned on, but I do have something in the code that shows me where stories would rank if I did. The good news is that, as of right now, the front page wouldn't look significantly different if vote weighting were turned on.