Take a look at just one of gulp's dependencies (and arguably one of the most important) vinyl-fs which it uses for file watching. This is the actual chain of abstractions for the file watching functionality in gulp.
vinyl-fs < glob-watcher < gaze < graceful-fs
* gulp.watch uses vfs.watch provided by vinyl-fs
* vfs.watch is actually just glob-watcher (lol)
* glob-watcher is a simple 20 line wrapper around gaze watch
* gaze uses graceful-fs to watch full paths
4 levels of library abstraction for file watching. Something that the built-in fs.watch handles natively.Here's the actual description of the gaze library "A globbing fs.watch wrapper built from the best parts of other fine watch libs."
Yet apparently that wasn't enough as the gulp authors had to toss in 2 more layers on top of it. And at the end of the day gulp still sucks for watching files on linux.
I understand that there are other pieces of vfs that are being used by gulp...but it still doesn't make any sense to me how there can be SOOO many accepted libraries dealing with just file watching. And instead of making a pull request for new features on existing libraries, developers are just building other libraries around them to do what they want.
There's so much fragmentation in the JS world and no one can seem to ever agree to work together on anything. In comparison, in the Python world there's pretty much one agreed upon library for something like file watching "watchdog". There are alternatives but it stands out above all the rest.
I actually had a really interesting conversation with Bert Belder about some of the lower level problem with file watching. It came up that perhaps there could be a working group around fixing this issue.
Broccoli (https://github.com/broccolijs/broccoli), the build tool written by Jo Liss and supported by the Ember community, is truly an asset pipeline tool. It is concerned with transformations to filesystems and file contents, not tasks.
This makes Broccoli a faster and easier to use tool for implementing complex asset pipelines. The main domain object is "trees". A tree represents a directory hierarchy of files that will be regenerated on each build. Broccoli uses directories of symlinks in tmp/ to cache un-changed files from step to step, allowing it to restart a build at any depth and only process those files that change.
Some links you might enjoy on Broccoli:
* http://aexmachina.info/intro-to-broccoli/
* http://moduscreate.com/better-builds-begin-with-broccoli/
* http://hashrocket.com/blog/posts/broccoli-the-build-tool-not... (how Broccoli is used in Ember-CLI)
I can't speak to the weariness, but I can say that Broccoli is completely unlike Grunt, Gulp, or Yeoman and without it (or something like it) Ember-CLI and the next generation of build tools would be impossible. Broccoli has been in development since fall of 2013, and been used aggressively by Ember-CLI users since summer 2014. Give it a look!
In a way, it makes a lot of sense that broccoli is part of the Ember-CLI system - I found broccoli to be the most opinionated of the runners. As long as your structure mapped easily onto the opinions of broccoli, things were easy and speedy. If you want to do something not supported, or customize how things work, not so much. As an example, I submitted a PR to configure where and how broccoli stores its temp directory structure a year ago (./tmp wasn't right for my project), which is still open (and admittedly wasn't the most elegant solution).
Gulp and Grunt, on the other hand, make far fewer assumptions, provide very little in the way of out-of-the-box "just works", and are far more easy to tweak. In my own experience, my issue was getting certain cat/minify/sort processes to work in broccoli (to deal with angular module declaration ordering) was annoyingly complex enough that I just moved to gulp where it was easier (and someone else had already written a gulp plugin).
This may be true for a codebase of trivial size. With a sizable codebase and many build steps (defeaturefy, babel, es6 modules, es3recast, jshint, jscs) you quickly see grunt and gulp fall flat.
Gulp and Grunt absolutely have a simpler API for blindly chaining tasks. And they have the ability (as task runners) to define multiple tasks and compose them.
Broccoli is tricky to learn. In Ember-CLI we go out of our way to make it invisible to devs who shouldn't need to care what tool is running the internals. For the internals however, it is definitely the correct tool.
I'd say: I ended up building all the features I wanted in broccoli as part of a gulp build system. It did not "fall flat", rather, at the time (about eight months ago), I found broccoli had fallen flat- it didn't handle what I wanted, and even when it did it was impossible to do incremental rebuilds (say) of files - change one thing and the whole system rebuilt itself leading to a livereload on * rather than a single changed file. On top of everything else, it was dog-slow on medium-to-large codebases. I understand that this has changed since, but the frustration I had originally getting it to do what I want coupled with the length of time it took to run rebuilds (nobody wants 10k msec builds when the same process elsewhere takes 300msec) made me transition to gulp. I'm sure broccoli is just fine nowadays, and my read of the emails (I still am watching the repo) seems to indicate that Stefan ironed out a lot of the performance issues around watching and rebuilding (symlinks on OSX, IIRC, were a dog).
As I said the first time around: you can do just about anything with gulp or grunt, you just have to DIY. If you happen to enjoy spending some time really getting to know your toolchain, they all end up doing about the same thing, and with grunt and gulp it's marginally easier to configure certain aspects of the process.
Sounds like they're doing exactly that!
Was there something wrong with the yeoman & grunt/gulp combo? The yeoman tool is great for the scaffolding and skeleton story, and even for setting up your build, test, deployment environments using whatever combination of grunt & gulp you want to build into your generator.
I'm starting to get weary of this constant need to reinvent the incredible tools that we have already instead of iterating and improving them.