News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by jwise0 on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @12:56AM (#9332091)
The article title on HN seems particularly misleading. It seems that the submitter is trying to imply that Ms. Pao is hiring in a way that is discriminatory (i.e., that would make it harder for people of some gender or race to join the company). The full context of the quote is:

> Ms. Pao, who said she wants to stay long-term as Reddit’s CEO when a one-year interim period ends, said she has removed salary negotiations from the hiring process because studies show women don’t fare as well as men. She has brought in well-known Silicon Valley diversity consultant Freada Kapor Klein to advise the company. And she has passed on hiring candidates who don’t embrace her priority of building a gender-balanced and multiracial team. “We ask people what they think about diversity, and we did weed people out because of that,” she said.

It's eminently clear from the rest of the quote that she is not doing anything untoward or illegal, or even particularly unethical; a headline that paints her actions in that way seems misleading.

I'd suggest instead: "Reddit CEO Ellen Pao: “We ask people what they think about diversity, and we did weed people out because of that,”"

Or, to use the original quote, and simply replace the rephrasing with the original content: "Reddit CEO Ellen Pao "passed on hiring candidates who don’t embrace her priority of building a gender-balanced and multiracial team"".

Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by Bahamut on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @12:59AM (#9332102)
Agreed, the current title is definitely a demonstration of bias.

The title should just be the title of the article, and the link should just be to the regular article. This attempt to deceive/slant the conversation is dishonest.

Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by Zikes on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @12:58AM (#9332099)
The irony and newsworthiness of this I think is that "hiring for cultural fit" has historically been a tactic used to discriminate against women in the workplace.
Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by tomlock on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @12:59AM (#9332101)
If this selection is trying to paint Ellen Pao as a hypocrite, shame on the poster! I don't think its particularly surprising that an asian woman would want to work in a company with employees that support building diversity. I think that's in fact aligned with everything we know about her.
Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by zaroth on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @12:35AM (#9332036)
The hash tag text highlighting was a neat trick! The code is not obfuscated, at the bottom of the page (Line 1920) when you view source. There's no copyright notice, not sure if that means it's free to copy.
Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by muglug on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @01:02AM (#9332110)
How is this different from interview questions that assess culture fit? Sure, it's one specific point, but hundreds of tech companies weed out programmers based on criteria that don't speak directly to their coding prowess.
Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by notsony on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @12:32AM (#9332029)
> "We ask people what they think about diversity, and we did weed people out because of that"

Is that kind of questioning even legal during an interview?

Or is it done after hours, at a drink to get to know the candidate better? Does the interviewer pretend to be a bigot just to see what the candidate's reaction is?

What happened to just hiring the best people for a job rather than trying to create a corporate utopia?

Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by zaroth on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @12:37AM (#9332041)
Yes, it is legal. Your opinions on workplace diversity are not a protected class. If it's not a protected class, it is legal to discriminate based on it.

Hiring standards cannot create an "artificial, arbitrary, or unnecessary barrier to employment" ... "which adversely affects equal employment opportunity for a protected class of persons." So e.g. weightlifting requirement, if not central to the job at hand (as in the case I quoted) would not be allowed because it's an artificial barrier which excludes women.

This standard is arguably artificial and unnecessary, but it would be hard to show it adversely affects employment opportunity of a protected class.

Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by smt88 on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @12:47AM (#9332071)
> What happened to just hiring the best people for a job rather than trying to create a corporate utopia?

What makes you think someone's level of bigotry does not have an effect on whether they're the best person for a job?

Diversity, meaning racial and gender diversity, has been repeatedly shown to be an advantage for a company. So has some degree of cultural fit, meaning having similar values. When M&As fail (and they often do), it's almost always because of cultural mismatch.

So I, and the research, would argue that asking people if they believe in and value diversity is an important indicator of their success at a company like Reddit, or any other company striving to be a diverse and equal workplace.

Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by A_COMPUTER on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @01:06AM (#9332120)
Well, what's bigotry? If it's true, can it still be bigoted? Where's the line? I agree with you 100%, racial and gender diversity is a good thing to some extent empirically so, and also that too much diversity is a bad thing, also with empirical evidence (Putnam.) The second half of that sentence won't fly with a diversity consultant. I just lost a job at Reddit. Good thing I know enough to lie on trap interview questions and use a fake name on Hacker News. And it is a trap question to filter for ideological purity.
Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by na85 on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @12:47AM (#9332070)
>What happened to just hiring the best people for a job rather than trying to create a corporate utopia?

Perhaps Ms. Pao feels that pro-diversity attitudes make the best hires, even if it means a small compromise on coding quality.

It's Reddit after all: users are already tolerant and accepting of horrid site performance ;)

Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by bjones22 on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @01:00AM (#9332107)
I'll get the ice. Personally though I always wonder why their stack stands as it does. Does anyone else get the impression that it is somewhat monolithic? Would be interested to hear from some one whose had the opportunity to comb through more of their code then I have.
Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by jkrems on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @12:59AM (#9332104)
> What happened to just hiring the best people for a job rather than trying to create a corporate utopia?

When hiring one candidate severely restricts hiring others (e.g. because that first candidate would make them feel uncomfortable and/or not welcome), then this has nothing to do with a "corporate utopia" and everything with hiring the best people for a job.

Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by bluthru on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @12:58AM (#9332098)
>she has removed salary negotiations from the hiring process because studies show women don’t fare as well as men

1. I wonder if she negotiated her pay?

2. How can she be a champion of equality if she formalizes a process that prohibits workers from negotiating their market value? It's one step forward and two steps back.

Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by wanderingstan on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @01:04AM (#9332114)
I don't have deep knowledge of this issue, but it seems like this is a legitimate strategy of having a set "price" which the prospective employee is free to take or not.

This reminds me (in reverse) of travels in 3rd world countries, where every item's price becomes negotiable. I had grown up accustomed to shops where everything had a marked price, and was not prepared to haggle over the cost of toothpaste.

It seems totally legit for a company to do the same/similar with salaries. No one is forced to take the job, they're just eliminating the negotiation part.

As long as I knew this policy followed for everyone in a company, I'd actually prefer it.

Re:Reddit CEO Ellen Pao “passed on hiring candidates” by SilasX on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @01:04AM (#9332115)
I thought the same thing. It's hard to imagine what it would even mean to "remove salary negotiations", and it's the kind of thing I would hope a journalist would try to pin down?

Similarly vague is the idea of filtering "anti-diversity" people out: how do you do it, without simply making it a test of "can you tell us what we want to hear?"