News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by larrys on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:10PM (#9317760)
I strongly disagree with the eff. Safety trumps all and there simply isn't a compelling need (that I can think of) that requires the need to tinker with the auto software. All of the "arguably restricts vehicle inspection, repair, and modification" is just a red herring.

"The reach of copyright law has expanded so far that it now threatens people's ability to repair their own cars and protect them against malware. Yesterday, EFF launched a legal campaign to fend off that threat."

Can't even think that I have read any stories (so far) about malware having an impact on auto operation. Hard to believe that opening up the software won't result in something bad happening either.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by ploxiln on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:23PM (#9317841)
"Safety trumps all" - I really do kinda hate you people.

Anyway, you can already mess with modern cars tire pressure sensors, when driving near them. http://www.winlab.rutgers.edu/~gruteser/papers/xu_tpms10.pdf

Closed source and un-modifiable car firmware is like closed-source crypto and other systems - it's not the best. Because it doesn't really have to be better, so why bother. Open source / custom can be as bad or worse, or it can be much better.

I prefer a world where we have the freedom to have good stuff.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by larrys on Friday April 03, 2015 @04:01PM (#9318077)
" I really do kinda hate you people."

Seems you have broken this rule:

http://blog.ycombinator.com/new-hacker-news-guideline

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by nickysielicki on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:17PM (#9317797)
Safety doesn't trump all. But that logic still doesn't hold up. If you care about safety you should want as many eyes on your cars code as possible.

See the following computer bugs that caused safety problems:

* http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-07-10/honda-reca...

* http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/toyota-pay-12b-hiding-deadly-u...

there are dozens of other stories.

If safety trumps all, we might as well ban people from changing their tires. If you don't use a torque wrench, you might find your wheel coming off on the freeway.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by skj on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:17PM (#9317802)
My manufacturer wants to charge me $400/year to keep the built-in map system updated. It was a $3500 add-on when we bought the car originally.

It sure would be nice if I could go in and put Google maps in there.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by Zikes on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:18PM (#9317807)
In the short term, they could easily use this to lock people out of being able to perform certain routine maintenance operations on their vehicles, forcing them to go to authorized dealers and paying exorbitant markups.

In the long term, tires, filters, and brake pads could become proprietary in the same way as Keurig's K-Cups are now, though I imagine with more complex DRM.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by crististm on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:26PM (#9317857)
This already happens with other machines (washing ones). Only the dealers get access to a proprietary DRM software that updates a 4KB firmware. I bet that not for too long.

http://www.scc-service.com

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by thinkling on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:17PM (#9317800)
I think the key issue is whether tinkering with the software is materially different from tinkering with physical parts of the car like (say) installing new brake pads yourself.
Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by mikeash on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:59PM (#9318066)
How is repair and modification a red herring? It's commonplace to repair or augment vehicles with third-party aftermarket parts. Do you think we should live in a world where you must buy spare parts from the original manufacturer? Because that's where this ends up if they get to exercise this level of control.
Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by bougiefever on Friday April 03, 2015 @05:40PM (#9318741)
You must be a PR person for the auto makers. I personally want to know when my driving information is being sent to a third party and be able to modify this behavior so I can control how my information is shared.
Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by joshstrange on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:32PM (#9317888)
> Can't even think that I have read any stories (so far) about malware having an impact on auto operation. Hard to believe that opening up the software won't result in something bad happening either.

First of all it would be EXTREMELY hard to nail down a car crash to malware currently because we have no tools/insight to do so. For all we know (put's on tinfoil hat) car hacking has been employed multiple times by state actors to kill off people who they disagree with. It's way too easy to write it off a the driver made a mistake and never have an investigation into the root cause.

However we HAVE seen that it's possible to hack into a car, there are multiple news articles showing people taking over control of cars remotely and killing the breaks, shutting off the engine, pushing down the accelerator, etc.

Also I don't buy the "Safety" argument it's way to easy to scream "Think of the children" to kill off an argument. Hobbyist hackers who want to hack their own cars have to still abide by the laws set out by the government just like a mechanic can't put a car on the road without breaks. I don't see the difference, yes maybe it will make it easier for bad hackers to disable your breaks but they could just cut the break line which would probably be easier (or should be if the automakers take security seriously at all which I would bet they don't).

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by ams6110 on Friday April 03, 2015 @04:03PM (#9318092)
Key safety systems have passive modes that work regardless of the software. Steering and brakes are among these. You might lose the power assist, but you can still steer and stop.

Killing the brakes on a car would require mechanical interference/sabotage, not just software hacking.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by snuxoll on Friday April 03, 2015 @04:20PM (#9318222)
This all depends on the vehicle. For example, Toyota's Hybrid Synergy Drive (formerly Toyota Hybrid System) in their hybrids is entirely drive-by-wire, meaning there is no direct attachment between the steering column and pedals and the mechanics they control.

I see no reason why the ability to brake in my Prius couldn't be disabled by sabotaging the ECU, same with steering and acceleration. There's not a traditional transmission either, so I can't just force it into neutral and roll up a hill to stop. There's technically a mechanical linkage in the break pedal to the disc brakes should the ECU fail, but ECU failure and ECU tampering are two separate concerns.

With that said, I'm not overly concerned about electronic attacks on my vehicle at the moment, someone would still need to forcibly enter the cabin, connect to the OBDII port and make modifications to the ECU firmware, not something some jerk could do while we are going down the freeway. I would certainly feel a lot safer if the code running on the ECU was available for the community at large to dissect and inspect, though.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by xg15 on Friday April 03, 2015 @04:37PM (#9318349)
I bet then you will be excited to know that the newest ECUs come with built-in GSM modules and OTA update functionality: http://news.softpedia.com/news/Connected-Drive-Glitch-Allows...
Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by Zak on Friday April 03, 2015 @05:23PM (#9318647)
Killing the brakes on a car would require mechanical interference/sabotage, not just software hacking.

Aside from the exceptions snuxoll mentioned, I can think of two ways the brakes could be hijacked on a car with traditional hydraulic brakes in order to cause a crash.

The first is abusing the antilock brake system to render the brakes less effective. Instead of reducing braking power when the wheels lock, it could be programmed to reduce braking power as much as possible in the event of panic braking at high speed.

The second is to abuse the stability control system now mandated by law to be included on new cars in the US and many other jurisdictions to induce, rather than prevent/correct a skid. Stability control works by selectively applying the brakes on different wheels. Applying one front brake at a moderate level (not enough to lock the wheel and leave rubber on the road as evidence) would look just like an erroneous steering input to anyone investigating a crash as long as the tampering couldn't be detected electronically. For extra evil, use GPS or have an observer trigger it manually when the car reaches a location in which a sudden turn would result in an especially bad crash.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by dcotton on Friday April 03, 2015 @05:22PM (#9318635)
That's not true any more. The brakes can be killed remotely with software.

http://www.cbsnews.com/news/car-hacked-on-60-minutes/

More info on Security Now episode 497 if you are interested in hearing the security devs being interviewed.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by crististm on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:22PM (#9317837)
First of all safety does not exist in a vacuum. And second, software is just a technology. If you have the tools you will be able to hack the device.

What will happen instead is, the car's software will be signed and even if you somehow get the sources, you won't be able to run a different version. Just like in tivo.

Getting back to technology, 20 years ago you were able to hack the car with a wrench. Now it's just plain impossible to know what's going on. Hopefully not for too long.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by genericuser on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:25PM (#9317854)
Personally I bought an OBDII cable and disabled my passenger seat belt chime. I got so sick of putting heavy objects in the passenger seat where they would be convenient to grab when I got out of the car, and having to strap them in to stop that horrible chime.
Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by gambiting on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:55PM (#9318027)
Just a word on safety - if you hit something, that heavy object in your passenger seat might actually kill you flying unrestricted around the cabin. All items in the car should be positioned in such a way that they don't turn into flying bricks upon collision.
Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by genericuser on Friday April 03, 2015 @05:28PM (#9318676)
Its usually a large duffel which sits on the seat jammed between the seat back and the glove box, but point taken.
Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by jasonlotito on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:25PM (#9317852)
> Can't even think that I have read any stories (so far) about malware having an impact on auto operation.

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/14/science/14hack.html?_r=1

The study referenced [PDF] http://www.autosec.org/pubs/cars-oakland2010.pdf

This was a simple search: "malware car software." Pretty sure disabling the brakes or selectively braking individual wheels on demand could have a deadly impact on auto operation.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by cmdrfred on Friday April 03, 2015 @03:41PM (#9317945)
In response I simply defer to Ben Franklin: "They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."
Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by _cipher_ on Sunday April 05, 2015 @06:35AM (#9323657)
> Safety trumps all and there simply isn't a compelling need (that I can think of) that requires the need to tinker with the auto software.

So you won't have any problem in <x> years if all PCs are coming with default configuration 'cause "safety trumps all' and "you don't need to tinker with the auto software". You don't need to change your shell. You don't even _need_ a shell anymore. The _company_ will provide you with everything you need. And of course, no choice for what OS you're going to install.

I imagine an answer would be "but my PC isn't going to run over a child". No, but an insecure OS can cause you to lose all your credit balance and many more (which I imagine you can guess being an hn member). All that just because "you don't need to tinker with the auto software".

I'm sorry, but people with views like yours keep the world behind.

Re:Automakers Say You Don’t Really Own Your Car by amorphid on Friday April 03, 2015 @05:11PM (#9318568)
Having recently worked on a proprietary enterprise software app, I have no confidence that you should assume the software in your car is safe. What's unsafe is hiding essentially software in a black box without the ability to review the code.