News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by AceJohnny2 on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @07:57PM (#9266889)
Sigh, yet another nail in the XMPP coffin, at least as far as the general public is concerned.

Remember when we had ICQ, and AIM, and MSN Messenger, and Gadu-Gadu, and we were dreaming of a unified messaging system?

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by hengheng on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @09:37PM (#9267292)
So, I don't do web or software development, let me tell you^W^Wrant about how chat in 2015 feels to use. I'm 27, I grew up on IRC, I know my ICQ UIN by heart. Chat has always replaced SMS for me, and most groupware as well. I was happy when Facebook came along, and suddenly even the non-nerdy friends were compatible with my preferred way of having an endless conversation about random things. Chatting feels natural to me, allowing to keep in touch with good friends but not capturing my attention the way a phone call does. It also interleaves very nicely with menial work.

I don't care much about cloud or private cloud or local app. I've used irssi on a server that everybody connected to via ssh. But I switched over to cloud services as soon as I had more than one device that could send and receive messages. Everything else was way too tedious, as I never knew which device was connected, where messages went, where unread notifications went or whatever. Nothing to do with closed vs open, json vs xml or whatever social pattern. XMPP was lacking features, simple as that! From a user perspective! XMPP didn't work!

Give me persistent group chat, shared chat history with a search function, synchronized unread/read statusses, and I'll be leaving the cloud with flying colors. My current best bet for a text messenger is Skype, but the app is way too clumsy on Android and Windows. Close second is WhatsApp with a few groups, running on a large phone with a well-trained SwiftKey2. Both feel about as great as ICQ6 with its banner ad, and none feel as great as Adium or Trillian did comparatively back in the day.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by phillc73 on Thursday March 26, 2015 @04:08AM (#9268300)
> ... persistent group chat, shared chat history with a search function, synchronized unread/read statuses....

Across all my devices - Web, Linux, Android and FirefoxOS. No advertising.

Telegram - http://telegram.org

I've been using it for several months now and am very happy. Would love integrated voice calling, especially to landlines/mobiles, and hope someone develops a plugin for this soon (perhaps the guys at Jaconda[0] will do it).

I have just one regular contact still using Facebook messenger, and our conversations are now very disjointed, as sometimes I don't login to that service for several days at a time. I don't use Skype as a messenger service, but do still have about four or five contacts who are wedded to it for free voice calls. I use WebCallDirect[1] for cheap calls to landlines/mobiles.

[0] https://jaconda.im [1] http://webcalldirect.com

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by Corrado on Thursday March 26, 2015 @04:39AM (#9268392)
Telegram looks really interesting. It has an open protocol and API so it should be easy to integrate with other systems; there is a libpurple port for it[1]. Maybe Telegram could be a replacement for XMPP?

[1] https://github.com/majn/telegram-purple

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by fencepost on Thursday March 26, 2015 @02:45PM (#9272165)
My biggest concern with things like this is that AFAICT their business model is kind of foggy. Quoting from their FAQ, "Pavel Durov, who shares our vision, supplied Telegram with a generous donation through his Digital Fortress fund, so we have quite enough money for the time being. If Telegram runs out, we'll invite our users to donate and add nonessential paid options to break even. But making profits will never be a goal for Telegram." https://telegram.org/faq#q-how-are-you-going-to-make-money-o...

That's a very nice sentiment, but it's not a sentiment that fills me with confidence that I can rely on the continued existence of the free thing they're giving me.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by dancsi on Thursday March 26, 2015 @09:00AM (#9269184)
Wow, Telegram looks great! Now if I only could convince all of my friends to switch...
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by pjtr on Thursday March 26, 2015 @03:21AM (#9268196)
You are so right. I really wanted XMPP to succeed and I used in happily back in 2002 or so. But it just doesn't seem to have evolved at all. You pretty much nailed it with persistent group chat and shared chat history. Skype can really get on my nerves, but it had this covered since forever, and trying to get people on XMPP without equivalent features is hopeless.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by ozmbie on Thursday March 26, 2015 @03:11AM (#9268182)
I used to use Skype for persistent, cross-platform group chat with my close group of friends. But we recently switched to using Slack, and it's far better.

The only thing that's missing, is end-to-end encryption.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by click170 on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @09:53PM (#9267357)
Can you go into detail about what features were lacking?

For what it's worth, a lot comes down to what features the server admin has activated. I've heard many complaints about XMPP but this is the first I've heard someone mention lack of features as a problem with it.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by christop on Thursday March 26, 2015 @04:15AM (#9268320)
In addition to logging as mentioned, I find that file transfers (encrypted!) that Just Work between users regardless of the network/client/server used seems to be missing.

I really like XMPP, and the extensibility it has is brilliant, but at the same time leads to a crazy level of fragmentation for the instant messaging use case. You're basically guaranteed that you can chat to others and maintain a buddy list, but anything much beyond that is a toss up, depending on the server used, how it's configured, and what client each user has.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by hengheng on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @10:40PM (#9267506)
Server-side chat logfiles that are distributed to all connecting clients? I've never looked into the protocol, but I'm pretty sure that one is lacking.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by rakoo on Saturday March 28, 2015 @01:08PM (#9282031)
If you're talking about Multi-User Chats, then on entering a room the server should send previous messages (http://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0045.html#enter-history), with no requirements set in stone (except when the client specifies a maximum amoun to send).

When a client logs in, it is true that a server doesn't have to send messages back, but that's the goal of XEP-0313.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by synchrone on Thursday March 26, 2015 @03:44AM (#9268231)
There was certain controversy about which protocol to use for sharing history between clients for both private chats and MUC, but now XEP0313 seems to be the future of it.

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/25982426/persistent-xmpp-...

There are implementations for servers, e.g https://code.google.com/p/prosody-modules/wiki/mod_mam_muc, but I have yet to see a client reliably supporting this.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by click170 on Thursday March 26, 2015 @12:55AM (#9267890)
I haven't heard of an extension that does that either, but I'm not sure that would scale well for busy long-running Multi User Chats.

But the benefit of XMPP is that a new extension can be proposed that does this if enough people want such a feature. Personally I would argue that a better approach would be to make Public MUC logs accessible and searchable via a web interface and to have the client log chats going forward from when they join (with offline messaging from the server so you don't have to be online the whole time).

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by pjtr on Thursday March 26, 2015 @03:29AM (#9268209)
The problem with XMPP MUC's is that it's modelled after IRC, as that's what the protocol hackers know and love. But (please forgive the hyperbole) normal people don't use IRC, they use Skype. And the Skype model is so foreign to the IRC / XMPP techies that they'll always dismiss any attempts to add these features, often with spurious technical doubts as you just did. Ignoring that Skype has these features since a decade and has taken over (some parts of) the world because it has them. (Skype alone today has about ten times more daily active users than all IRC networks together!)
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by 1wd on Thursday March 26, 2015 @06:09PM (#9273472)
Not to forget whatsapp. 1000 times more daily active users than IRC. Basically the same model as Skype. (And likewise quite unlike IRC.)
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by patcon on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:30AM (#9270325)
1339782 add me
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by jkarneges on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @08:05PM (#9266917)
Now we have twice as many incompatible services. And still dreaming. :/
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @08:58PM (#9267142)
This is what we get when we embrace closed platforms. Free Software gets you nice, simple, easy to use services and closed platforms will always manipulate you for their needs.

This is why I want to make a Free Hardware cell phone. I have made one wireless product already and wrote the frequency hopping stack myself, but something like a phone needs better data rates and a more advanced protocol.

Still, I dream of a simple cell phone that runs vanilla linux and has apps for IRC, XMPP, and the other functions you would want. The key component would be that the protocol would be designed from the ground up to respect user privacy, including a "broadcast" mode for towers where certain low data rate data channels are streamed without requiring any transmission from the handset. Then you could follow IRC or twitter during a protest without any risk of being probed for your location.

The protocol would also be built with anonymity in mind as much as possible, so phones would route data using rolling anonymous ID numbers and spoofing location could perhaps be trivial for plausible deniability (unless that opens up a vector for DoS).

I met the "Game of Drones" guys last night and they seemed interested in my wireless. I can only do 1km at 20kbps with current boards and 10km at 20kbps with amplified boards, but I think they might be interested in a solution that would work for FPV and that could be a good excuse to develop something that would also work for a cell phone.

I am 100% Free Hardware all the way, so maybe your dreams can come true eventually. :)

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by runn1ng on Thursday March 26, 2015 @04:17AM (#9268326)
> Free Software gets you nice, simple, easy to use services

While there are many upsides to free software, usability and user friendliness were never one of them.

Hackability, sure. But most people don't care, let's be frank. I will use Hacker News because it works despite being proprietary software.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by vitno on Thursday March 26, 2015 @08:48AM (#9269114)
Hacker News is not proprietary software. It's open source under the Perl Foundation Artistic License 2.0 (FSF compatible). It's even written in Arc Lisp, which is nifty.

Some of us do care.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by runn1ng on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:17AM (#9269745)
Nice, I did not know. Really

Where is the source code?

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by julionc on Thursday March 26, 2015 @12:06PM (#9270639)
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by runn1ng on Thursday March 26, 2015 @01:03PM (#9271193)
It seems like the source for Arch discussion, that seems to be similar, but slightly different, to Hacker News.

But it's better than nothing.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by TaylorAlexander on Friday March 27, 2015 @02:54AM (#9275030)
But free software can do things proprietary can't, like maintain trust with the user and provide maximum good. Think about all the good things people could do with facebook but have been blocked because facebook wants to protect their one narrow use case. Social Networks won't reach their full potential until they're totally free software, because facebook has such narrow interests.

So sure, you're happy for now, but billions of people are getting spied on and getting sick of it, and out of work programmers are increasing for number every year. As users get more fed up with proprietary companies jerking them around, I feel like people will start to demand Free Software. However this may be what all engineers who fall for Free Software think... I make Free Hardware so my plan is to prove why Free is better to people. We'll see if I succeed! I just recently realized that was the issue so I am working on that now.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by amyjess on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:30AM (#9269842)
It's worse now.

Back then, we had Pidgin, Trillian, Kopete, etc. that would let us connect to all our messaging services with one client.

But nowadays nobody even tries to reverse-engineer protocols anymore. Where are all the people reverse-engineering Hangouts or Facebook Messenger? I wish we could teleport the people who reverse-engineered AIM, Yahoo!, and MSN to the present day, because they don't seem to exist anymore.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by na85 on Thursday March 26, 2015 @03:39AM (#9268222)
I've been saying for years that an update to the IRC protocol to allow for push notifications without requiring users to have a shell and set up a bnc would be pretty much ideal.

The constant ping-pongs really dissuade me from using IRC on my mobile as it kills my battery life. Being able to set some kind of "mobile" mode and receive push notifications if I get a hilight would be ideal.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by BuildTheRobots on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:13AM (#9269715)
I've ended up using the www.ircCloud.com service as my bouncer. It gives lovely native mobile apps with proper push and has a much nicer/more usable interface than any other solution I was capable of rigging up myself.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by DanTheManPR on Thursday March 26, 2015 @09:56AM (#9269599)
Some of the cloud-based IRC clients do a lot of this (I'm a big fan of IRCCloud). But it would be nice these kinds of features were baked into the protocol. When something like a majority of users want a feature, it should probably be part of the protocol.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by cbhl on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @08:15PM (#9266979)
It's worth noting that XMPP was based on XML. New hotness is JSON, or maybe even compressed binary protocols.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by AceJohnny2 on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @09:04PM (#9267168)
I don't know if you're being ironic about JSON. Note that jkarneges, who comments elsewhere in this thread, is the creator of Psi [1], arguably the best XMPP-focused messaging client.

The value/burden of XML has always been a topic of debate for XMPP. In retrospect, I think it contributed to its lack of appeal, though the extensibility and readbility (ehm, arguably) it provided were unique back then.

I've long wondered about which alternative base protocols could be used in place. JSON is OK, but may be as much a fad as XML. I've wondered if ASN.1 could be used, but ProtoBufs sound like they're a better fit [2] in that they're simpler, more space-efficient, and backwards-and-forwards compatible (and thus extensible, XMPP's main feature) In fact, it's what Google already uses themselves.

[1] http://psi-im.org/ [2] https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/protobuf/eNAZlnPKVW4

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by xorcist on Thursday March 26, 2015 @03:37AM (#9268219)
What is the purpose of layering your chat protocol over another protocol at all?

SMTP has no "base protocol" in this sense. HTTP, nothing (unless you count RFC 822).

It's hard to think there protocols would have had the same life time if they were based on XML, JSON, or protobufs. (Yeah, HTTP over XML, that should be enough to give you nightmares. But welcome to DAV and XMPP.)

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by wtbob on Thursday March 26, 2015 @07:56AM (#9268898)
If you're looking for a happy medium between the readability of JSON and XML and the efficiency of ASN.1 and protobufs, take a look at canonical S-expressions[1].

There's an advanced representation, which looks like this: (message (header (sender "Billy Joe Bob") (sent "2015-03-26T12:02:00Z")) (body "Hey guys! Let's meet up for lunch!")). It's possible to encode any byte string using Base64 or hex. It's also possible to encode types with data: (message (header (sender "Billy Joe Bob") (sent "2015-03-26T12:02:00Z")) (body [text/html]"<p>Hey guys! Let's meet up for lunch!</p>"))

While there are multiple advanced encodings for the same data (e.g. foo or "foo" or |Zm9v| or #666f6f#), there is a _single_ canonical encoding for any datum: the messages above would be (7:message(6:header(6:sender13:Billy Joe Bob)(4:sent20:2015-03-26T12:02:00Z))(4:body35:Hey guys! Let's meet up for lunch!)) and (7:message(6:header(6:sender13:Billy Joe Bob)(4:sent20:2015-03-26T12:02:00Z))(4:body[9:text/html]42:<p>Hey guys! Let's meet up for lunch!</p>)).

A huge advantage of this canonical encoding is that it's amenable to cryptographic hashing and signing; a weakness of JSON is that one has to layer requirements atop JSON itself (e.g. alphabetising object properties) in order for two parties to be able to hash the same datum and get the same value.

Another advantage of canonical S-expressions is that it's straightforward to define a mapping between them and HTML: "<p class='foo'>This is a <em>nifty</em> paragraph.<br /></p>" could be represented as ((p (class foo)) "This is a " (em nifty) paragraph. (br)). There are other possible mappings between S-expressions and HTML, of course, but I like that one. Another might be (p (/ (class foo)) "This is a " (em nifty) paragraph. (br)).

[1] http://people.csail.mit.edu/rivest/Sexp.txt

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by rakoo on Thursday March 26, 2015 @08:29AM (#9269023)
> there is a _single_ canonical encoding for any datum: the messages above would be (7:message(6:header(6:sender13:Billy Joe Bob)(4:sent20:2015-03-26T12:02:00Z))(4:body35:Hey guys! Let's meet up for lunch!))

This reminds me a lot of bencode, with the advantage for bencode that it doesn't need any fiddling for non-printable characters: no more base64, no more hex.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by wtbob on Thursday March 26, 2015 @11:35AM (#9270365)
The base64 & hex stuff is only used for the advanced, human-readable bits; on the wire it's just straight length-encoding and byte strings.

I'd say that bencode's advantage is a built-in standard for integer encoding (with canonical S-expressions one must decide between ASCII decimals or little/big-endian bit strings), and a clearer standard for a dictionary/map/hash (a canonical S-expression would probably use an alist-like structure like (map (foo bar) (baz quux)), but one could also go with (map foo bar baz quux), (map (foo bar baz quux)) or some other encoding.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by benbristow on Thursday March 26, 2015 @05:05AM (#9268469)
XML is horrendous. Especially to parse/scrape. JSON on the over hand is a breeze.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by dawidloubser on Thursday March 26, 2015 @08:23AM (#9268994)
Only if you don't understand XML.

* XML has a formal, class-based description language (XML Schema) with strong typing, polymorphism, and - best of all - self-descriptiveness.

* Languages like Java have a seamless, bidirectional mapping to XML Schema.

* XML has a rediculously powerful and elegant transformation language (XSLT) which makes scraping, selective data extraction and processing trivial.

The problem with XML is that people who require instant satisfaction are not willing to invest the time to understand it, and the mature tooling ecosystem around it.

The XML ecosystem solves problems, and contains solutions to problems, that the JSON / JavaScript ecosystem can only dream of, and is hell-bent on partially re-inventing.

If you need strong-typing and self-descriptiveness, you're out of luck with JSON. Binding JSON to a strong-typed language like Java or Haskell is a total ball-drag compared to XML + Schema.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by hackerboos on Thursday March 26, 2015 @05:40AM (#9268560)
I don't see why I can't use XML, JSON, MsgPack or YAML.

Couldn't the parsing be a pluggable component? Just set a standard on how data is structured and let third-parties figure out how data is parsed.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by darklajid on Thursday March 26, 2015 @08:37AM (#9269059)
And that would improve the XMPP adoption and experience by ... ?

Are you saying mom and dad aren't using XMPP because the message is sent using XML based stanzas? Facebook is ditching XMPP because of the X?

It doesn't matter?

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by rakoo on Saturday March 28, 2015 @01:17PM (#9282059)
As much as I can agree that XML doesn't prevent user adoption, it may very well prevent developer adoption; if developers are not willing to bother with XML or any part of the protocol, they may very well give up and develop for some other platform.

Yes, that may sound futile, but in the end the developers are the people who build everything. It is my strong belief that HTTP, IRC, SMTP and bittorrent (among others) have thrived because of their utter simplicity, to the point we're embarassed today because we've ended up with so much under-specified crap on top of them. Still, they deliver. As always "worse is better".

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by hackerboos on Thursday March 26, 2015 @10:47AM (#9269970)
>And that would improve the XMPP adoption and experience by ... ?

Saving battery on mobile devices for one.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by darklajid on Thursday March 26, 2015 @07:03PM (#9273740)
Wait, wait. We're talking underlying data format here.

Are you saying that serializing something to JSON (or whatever you fancy here) vs. to XML .. saves battery?

I mean, XMPP is certainly not the battery friendliest tech right now (elsewhere people discuss push extensions for example), but .. that's not related to the use of XML.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by hackerboos on Friday March 27, 2015 @02:49PM (#9278303)
I'm saying pushing a verbose format like XML over mobile radio signals consumes more battery.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by cplease on Thursday March 26, 2015 @07:07PM (#9273758)
Having to support a panoply of marshaling standards would suck battery more, not less. I doubt XML vs. JSON vs. YAML per se makes any substantial difference in CPU usage. You might get a little mileage in going to a compact binary format and reducing data transmission, but is that worth it?
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by hackerboos on Friday March 27, 2015 @02:50PM (#9278308)
CPU cycles are cheap compared to bandwidth on mobile.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by jkarneges on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @08:22PM (#9267003)
The funny thing is that XMPP was created when XML was the current hotness.

SMTP survived despite changing fads. If we're ever going to standardize IM (or anything), we have to accept that protocols may use older technology. Someday JSON will be old too. Let's not make these mistakes again.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by olau on Thursday March 26, 2015 @06:37AM (#9268702)
At the time when XMPP was getting standardized and was still mostly known as Jabber, I started implementing a Jabber chat client with a friend.

The problem with XMPP isn't that it was based on XML. No, what made it annoying was that the dudes who made it decided that instead of basing it on exchanging individual messages, i.e. XML documents like everyone else does, everything must instead be put inside a so-called XML stream.

IIRC it basically meant that the exchange started with a start tag that wasn't terminated until the connection was closed. Since nothing at the time was designed to work with unfinished XML documents (remember the end tag doesn't come until you're done), all the convenient standard XML tools/libraries wouldn't work.

So I don't think XMPP is a stellar piece of work. But it's of course much better than some proprietary crap, and it's sad to see it lose support, although I imagine to Google and Facebook who both probably couldn't care less about interoperability, having an open XMPP interface is probably more of a liability (spammers, enables people to skip their ads) than something they get much perceived value out of.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by jkarneges on Thursday March 26, 2015 @04:12PM (#9272739)
Even though it seems like a strange decision, using XML for the stream framing made the protocol nicely pure. It theoretically meant you didn't need to write a parser (this was a rare thing for a network protocol). In practice, though, you're right, most parsers at the time didn't work well with network streams.

Of course, lack of adoption by the big providers was almost certainly political rather than technical.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by drawkbox on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @08:44PM (#9267080)
Maybe we need a new standard JSON protocol, I bet part of it falling out of favor was the XML.

Messaging is one of those areas that is actually pretty simple that corporations that want to own channels have munged up pretty bad into a complex mess. Companies internally even have a couple or few.

Side note: AOL/Timewarner actually owns the IM patent from ICQ (http://edition.cnn.com/2002/TECH/biztech/12/19/internet.aol....)

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @09:38PM (#9267301)
Yeah, I don't think the issue with with the implementation, it's with the fact that it can't be controlled that companies didn't like. We either build systems to use ourselves or let private companies control our communications.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by toomuchtodo on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @08:14PM (#9266972)
> Remember when we had ICQ, and AIM, and MSN Messenger, and Gadu-Gadu, and we were dreaming of a unified messaging system?

We'll always have SMS.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by GauntletWizard on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @08:22PM (#9267002)
SMS? Or SMS, iChat, Hangouts, Whatsapp, and the thousands of others that use your SMS number as username? Some (iChat, Hangouts) even steal your SMSs and place them on proprietary networks; If you switch devices from iPhone to Android or vice-versa, messages get lost.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by toomuchtodo on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @08:27PM (#9267017)
SMS, the network.

> If you switch devices from iPhone to Android or vice-versa, messages get lost.

I moved from an Android phone to an iPhone, back to an Android, and then back to an iPhone again. I never had my messages in limbo, and its easy to fix (at least, on the Apple side) if it occurs: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204270

Note that link also comes up as a search engine provided result by google just by googling "disable imessages". That's stupid simple.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by cplease on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @11:06PM (#9267582)
First of all, I'll wager a supermajority of iPhone users do not understand any distinction between iMessage and SMS. Apple designs away the distinction. Secondly, when an ex-iPhone user ports away their number and is able to send SMS's without issue and receive SMS's from most of the world except for iMessage senders, how are they supposed to 1) discover they have lost messages before they lose something critical, and 2) discern that the cause of their inexplicably lost messages, is that they need to "disable iMessage", when they are not even an Apple user anymore?

I'm not an Apple hater, I use Apple products, but this is a huge fuckup and the OTT fragmentation is a real issue vis-a-vis SMS.

And SMS is not IM so your premise from the start is a nonsequitor. It's telephony, it's wildly and widely overpriced and non-open.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by 72deluxe on Thursday March 26, 2015 @05:53AM (#9268599)
I think you're right about the lack of widespread distinction between SMS and an iMessage. It's sad.

Even sadder are the news articles (like ones you find in the technology section on the BBC website) where they refer to instant messaging as wonderful and then "if you're a bit old fashioned" and still use email...... At least emails can be easily retrieved and archived.

Perhaps people don't care about the transport medium (phone network or Internet) but it is an important distinction. It's even more important for Google users because Hangouts is very flaky for me, unlike SMS.

Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by reustle on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @09:40PM (#9267306)
It doesn't matter if it is stupid simple, it shouldn't be necessary in the first place.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by toomuchtodo on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @09:52PM (#9267348)
So start your own communications network. Market it. Make it open. May the best solution win.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by kedean on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @10:43PM (#9267514)
It's not about the best solution, and everyone needs to stop pretending it is. This sort of thing comes down to which solution has the most corporate backing. The only exceptions are when an open solution happens to hold on for long enough (on the order of years) for a major player to realize that its good and maybe they should give it a chance (example: OpenStack's support by PayPal right now, or when Linux finally started going someplace in the early 2000's with Canonical and RedHat). Give me an example of 'the best solution' winning despite major corporate backing of the proprietary competitor?
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by GauntletWizard on Thursday March 26, 2015 @04:06PM (#9272690)
I don't think it's even as simple as corporate backing, though that certainly plays a part. It's significantly the arbitrary whims of the population; Whatsapp was not corporate backed, and still captured huge marketshare.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by kps on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @09:41PM (#9267314)

  > We'll always have SMS.
Not much good for talking to people on things that aren't phones.
Re:Facebook Messenger XMPP is going away by Yhippa on Thursday March 26, 2015 @03:51PM (#9272575)
I was thinking about this recently. After having some trouble with my iPhone 5 sending SMS's last year and my Nexus 6 sending and receiving MMS's this year I feel that SMS/MMS reliability has gotten really bad. I know it's due to a cocktail of buggy OS's and the cell phone towers themselves but I never thought my old Motorola flip-phone from 10 years ago would be more reliable than this stuff.