This is definitely not the site I'd have in my signature when talking about the emerging trend of single-page apps and proposing a new standard. It's such a non-standard site, and feels clunky and clumsy.
On the other hand "+1" and "I agree" and "Well said!" clutter the forum.
How do we solve this?
In either case, both are accepted uses. PG has said as much:
However to me it feels a bit like discouraging alternative opinions, when they are hidden/greyed out.
Is this commonly accepted then?
I do believe we have the a similar kind of understanding for when to up-vote. What is a 'nice contribution to the conversation' other than arguments or facts that 'I do agree with' in them being a nice contribution to the conversation.
I fear we would have to have a meta-discussion on the concepts of good and bad and how they are flawed in that there are no montains without valleys^^
The community is in many ways already an echo-chamber; that battle was lost a few years ago. Don't let it bug you.
It makes sense, then, that the upvote button be used for agreement.
But the main thing is that this doesn't solve any problem that exists. We can already do everything his proposal would enable; all this does is make it more inflexible.