Formal training means a way to structure your thoughts and assess risks. Don't dismiss it out of hand.
Most college new grads are not exactly CEO material from the get-go.
Sure, many of those things could come in handy in the future - but there are far more difficult things which you also have to learn "as you go".
Lots of people just want to be their own boss and run a viable business.
Interestingly, I see several tech startups of this nature started by folks having a deep understanding of a specific business problem due to their prior work experience tend to create such startups.
As a service provider for small businesses, I see many amazing bootstrapped services & products come up around the world, that serves a very specific need for a small subset of customers. These viable businesses tend to make enough for the needs of 2-3 folks for a long time. I have a strong inclination towards finding many of them as a service provider because they just tend to be some of the best customers with great ROI.
(This radar often goes off when I hear someone refer to YCombinator as 'the Harvard of Incubators.')
I think to be a great founder you have to not only know how to handle failure, but to also be OK with everyone dismissing your venture as a failure, as something even laughable.
Wouldn't it be cheaper and more educational to just launch a side-business and keep it running for a year?
Correct me if I'm wrong but I actually thought that was the obvious reason to most applicants.
A $120k investment from YC doesn't provide that much runway. That kind of money doesn't give much wiggle room for founders to splurge on luxuries like Aeron chairs and fancy cappuccino machines. That amount is to allow a small team to live in near-poverty in the SF Bay area for ~6 months and maybe also buy some tech necessities like AWS EC2 time. Basically, provide some breathing room for founders to not worry about rent and put the focus on building their idea. What other reason to work 60+ hours a week in modest conditions unless it was the networking and interaction?