http://www.aliexpress.com/item/GH620-Italina-brand-Classic-d...
I actually ordered one to see what it's like: The band looks exactly the same (I'm guessing it's just plated or a alloy though) and the fake diamond looks more shiny and isn't as heavy as it should be.
I guess the raw materials just don't cost that much. :)
So, a top branded (Swarowsky) quality for a 1 ct equivalent CZ will run for $2, unbranded (AAAAA) for $1 and that's when you buy them by the unit.
Good quality (AAA) one bought wholesale will not go over 0.30$. That's still for good quality, if you cut down on quality price can drop much further (try ebay-ing). Note that AAA quality is what I buy for my coloured stones and they are IMO magnificent.
The material of the ring is silver plate, so that is basically worth nothing. Even if it was solid silver you would not have 1$ worth there, so $0.10 is probably generous.
2$ is probably 500% margin -at least- on the raw material (wow!) - I would not be surprised they didn't make 100% with manufacturing and shipping included. Impressive times to be alive.
reference:
* where I buy my CZ, not the cheapest: http://www.diamondcz.co.uk/
* http://www.kitco.com/charts/livesilver.html
* some experience making jewellery
* the reason it is a hobby and not a job: jewellery price on Camden Market
(edit: formatting)
http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1982/02/have-you...
Quote from the middle of the article: Since "young men buy over 90% of all engagement rings" it would be crucial to inculcate in them the idea that diamonds were a gift of love: the larger and finer the diamond, the greater the expression of love. Similarly, young women had to be encouraged to view diamonds as an integral part of any romantic courtship.
EDIT: and this was already linked downthread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9223903
Cultural expectations can be a strong force, even if they were manufactured.
That makes "cultural expectations" just another euphemism for peer pressure.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bzMrxVwl74
It's about African conflict diamonds, but also covers the DeBeers monopoly.
"I'd rather have nothing than a fake".
It doesn't matter how much information I provide her about the scam, it just upsets her. It's so very frustrating, and it's not entirely her fault. The idea is just so firmly implanted by the world.
Just swallow your principles and buy the ring. It's a few thousand dollars amortised over the length of the marrage. Over seven years it's like $40 a month which for a lot of HN is pocket change.
She can point to a bunch of stuff that you buy which has inflated price that you rationalise away as useful spending -- coffee from a coffee shop is a scam yet people don't think twice about it.
Edit: a word
To be honest, so is not being willing to buy a diamond for your partner that wants it, but that's the point, find another person who agrees with your expectations of them.
I couldn't imagine being happy in a relationship without learning to compromise. Only the most important things should be considered "core principles", questions of religion, child-rearing, maybe hot-button political issues, and other moral litmus tests.
Whether or not she gets the ring she wants is a silly gender identity fixation, pretty harmless in comparison. If its a core principal, then so is whether or not he's allowed play video games, or buy a motorcycle, and so on. (Btw, I'm not engaged, married, nor ever bought a ring.)
I agree, compromise is incredibly important and it's all about finding someone whose core principles are the same as yours. For me, the thought of having a partner who would argue and resent me over me not buying an expensive diamond ring would suggest a clash in core principles. But I completely appreciate that that's my own view of it.
I may change my mind to make her happy. She may change her mind because our financial situation has changed (mortgage). We may decide not to get married at all.
I don't consider this a core principle. Our views on the important stuff are very much aligned for the most part.
Coffee from a coffee shop isn't a scam because I'm paying for the accessibility, not the item itself.
Larger high grade colorless man-made diamonds aren't priced all that differently than wholesale natural diamonds and have the significant downside of having almost no resale value. Even if buyers pay 60% of wholesale for stones, it is still better than nothing.
Putting aside "fake" or not, unless you're buying colored diamonds, I don't see much point in buying lab made stones right now even if you're only concern is how pretty it is.
Now I'm betting on time, from time to time just constantly reminding her of whole rings scheme and why we shouldn't be bothered with that and should stick with a simple/traditional wedding rings.
You refuse to compromise; you refuse to budge; you refuse to accommodate her wish. You make her be for this gift, and you still deny her.
You even made her cry, and you post here almost proud of bringing someone to tears because you refuse to see things from her point of view?
I'm happy, not proud. I'm happy, because I'm not alone who's thinking this way. Believe it or not, there isn't a lot of people that agrees with me.
This is where you are mistaken, to her it's not just a ring, or a scam. It's her as a little girl dreaming and looking at the engagement rings of other women, imagining the day she'll be able to 'show off' one of her own. Sad to say, but in our culture, this stuff means a lot.
But there are alternatives:
This guy made a wirelessly powered led illuminated ring: http://www.kokes.net/projectlonghaul/projectlonghaul.htm
This guy forged a ring out of meteorite metal: http://io9.com/5907849/this-guy-hand-forged-his-own-wedding-...
Those are both, I would say, much larger investments than $2000 to $5000 dollars in money.
Tradition is sexist then, don't be sexist
You can still get an awesome engagement ring for, let's say, $500, with no diamond, just a nice blue aquamarine or some other wonderful gemstone. Something that goes well with her eyes.
Lay it on thick. Put in a lot of effort to have it custom made. Involve her in the customizing and decision making.
But stick to your guns on the diamond. It's simply not cool.
Or find one on Craigslist but please don't buy one from a jewelry store if you can help it.
God bless!
Edit: a word
And I didn't really have a good answer. It just seemed like the thing to do at the time. We were both involved in picking out the rings, too; it's not like I went out and bought them for her without her input.
Thankfully I didn't spend a completely insane amount of money on the rings (not compared to what I was earning -- less than a couple weeks' wages -- which is still too much, really but not the crazy amount some people spend). But neither of us were really ready to step that far away from what was "expected" of us, I guess.