If so, then the work of anesthesiologists is quackery. :)
> Why point to things like "consciousness" when our brains being biological automatons is a perfect explanation already?
Because reductionism doesn't provide a satisfying explanation for higher level emergent phenomena.
For example, x86 disassembly isn't particularly informative about what is happening in a theorem-prover written in Lisp.
> I think most people would agree if a human is conscious a dog is. Is a squirrel? I think most people would agree. Is a lizard? Maybe. Is a spider? eh... Is a worm?
Probably, there is a continuum. A squirrel is conscious in a less "rich" way than a dog, and so on.
This whole question is so hard because we find it impossible to define the terms. It could be that by default, we cannot define consciousness. Perhaps that implies that the universe is made of consciousness, rather than the other way around.
Consider humans as biological automatons. Our brains are some sort of neural networked computer and the architecture of the neurons makes for, from a programmers point of view, some very advanced sort of "artificial" intelligence. From here there seems to be two possibilities: 1) That is it. Nothing else and their is no "being" experiencing what the brain processes or 2) something else, I think this idea is what we call...
Consciousness would be the idea that their is some sort of unifying sort of connectedness that allows the soul, ghost, being, etc to experience what is happening and in some people's viewpoints have an affect on what is happening (freewill in other words).
To me this definition seems terribly biased towards my point of view but I don't really know of any other way to define this.
We humans are similar, we have our eyes (camera), this sensory data goes to our brain (cpu) and then it goes to our display (... consciousness?).
That's how I see it anyway
This might not correspond 100% to what philosophers mean, but it has the immense advantage of making consciousness a well defined concept, and even measurable.
So from this perspective, reflective awareness is what you define as consciousness, and it can be present to massively varying degrees, alongside direct awareness down to the neuron.
But, you are right that it is possible to write quite simple self modifying programs that would be conscious with this definition. However, having consciousness without intelligence can't be very useful.
Either All sensory endpoints and the viewer are one, the viewer IS the cumulative sensory endpoint, we'll name this consciousness.
OR the viewer is a separate "something", the viewer is separate from the sensory endpoint. And we'll name the sensory endpoint "consciousness" and the viewer the "soul".
Any other ideas?
On the other hand, I find it surprising that science does not deal with "experience of awareness", for clearly it is part of reality (since we are talking about it) and hence of physics (there is only one way out of this, which is to say that we are all zombies just making up that our awareness is influencing reality).
By the way, anyone know of a more concise term for "experience of awareness"? I have been looking for it, and I'm sure it must exist, but no luck so far. How do philosophers address this concept?
Another approach is to consider consciousness and material to be 'dual aspects' of the same intractable underlying reality. This was the approach taken by Spinoza and later by Schopenhauer, but also, independently and millennia earlier, by Hindu and Buddhist philosophy.
The fact that consciousness, as a word, has fuzzy edges, does not imply that it does not exist. Most of our words have fuzzy edges.
> The concept of a threshold for consciousness doesn't seem to hold any weight to it. So then consciousness must be a sliding scale? I would agree.
> Is the universe conscious? I would say this is likely. If neurons and the rest of our physiology can give rise to consciousness, then I think it's likely that there are objects at larger scales than us that are conscious (at least partly) due to our behaviors.
Knowledge of self, aknowledging one's physical and mental limitations and one's ability to relate and interact with others and the environment in such a way that transcends on's initial limits if one is so inclined(ie, desire for growth and the choice not to do it).
Just responding to stimuli is not enough, because humans can accept that the stimuli and chose not to respond to it or can decide to act despite said inputs.
If we want to describe that other idea with a word, then perhaps self-aware is closer.
The problem with your tentative definition above is that defining consciousness simply as response to stimuli does not distinguish between a conscious response, and a mechanical response. These are at least notionally distinct, and it is very hard to regard then as being the same thing.
It gets even sillier when you consider that the criteria for what things are considered conscious seems to be quite arbitrary. They say a human is conscious. Is a dog? I think most people would agree if a human is conscious a dog is. Is a squirrel? I think most people would agree. Is a lizard? Maybe. Is a spider? eh... Is a worm? well some might only have ~300 neurons... Is a plant? Well, no neurons, but they technically do react to stimuli...
How about a rock? Well it certainly doesn't have any neurons and doesn't react to stimuli but what is so special about neurons and reacting to stimuli anyway? The concept of a threshold for consciousness doesn't seem to hold any weight to it. It has nothing backing it up.
When two particles interact with each other is a barrier of consciousness formed? Are all systems conscious? Is the universe conscious? Are all possible systems made up of all the connections of all the constituent parts of the universe conscious?