Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by curun1r on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:37PM
(#9209210)
> Couldn't the owner just ask the person who is renting the unit to move out in a reasonable amount of time?
California has a provision for doing this. It's called the Ellis Act and San Francisco's regulations for Ellis Act evictions require payment of $5k-$15k + $3k per senior/disabled tenant. This remodel + rent increase seems a transparent attempt to circumvent that law. Whether legal or not would require a lawyer to weigh in.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by alistairSH on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:58PM
(#9209025)
> Couldn't the owner just ask the person who is renting the unit to move out in a reasonable amount of time?
Assuming the original $2145 is below market, the answer would be no, wouldn't it? Or, rather, they could ask, but the tenant would never willingly leave, as they are paying below market.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by DrStalker on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:05PM
(#9209061)
Why can't they tell the tennet to move out? In Australia residential leases have a fixed term (usually 12 months) and after that become month-to-month, and the owner can ask you to leave with 90 days notice when you're not under a contract.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by refurb on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:23PM
(#9209151)
In SF the only real way to kick someone out of a rent controlled unit is via an Ellis Act eviction. The allows the owner to take the building off the market. Issue is, you need to pay a substantial fee to the tenant (many thousands if they've been there a long time) AND you cannot rent the unit out again for 5 years.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by zobzu on Monday March 16, 2015 @12:00AM
(#9209762)
it actually sounds fair, doesn't it?
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by charlesdm on Monday March 16, 2015 @07:58AM
(#9210944)
Sarcasm? How does that sound fair for the owner. Not being able to rent out your apartment for 5(!) years is ridiculous.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by zobzu on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @03:29PM
(#9220635)
then dont stop renting it...
sounds like the buyer should have guaranteed cash cows.. well, bad luck, guaranteed cash cows are NOT fair.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by dredmorbius on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:33PM
(#9209196)
s/can rent/cannot rent/
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by PebblesHD on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:04PM
(#9209315)
I believe there are also provisions in Australian law that allow a landlord to evict in a much shorter time period, at least where a detached house is concerned. I was asked to vacate my previous place within 14 days due to difficulties experienced by the landlord, complete with legal documents and such.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by charlesdm on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:09PM
(#9209083)
They did, in a hostile way. Then again, maybe the tenant refused to move out.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by forrestthewoods on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:29PM
(#9209181)
Someone paying significantly below market rate is almost certainly going to refuse to move out.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by IgorPartola on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:51PM
(#9208993)
I can't imagine someone going through this trouble instead of just asking. It is a dick move, for sure. I just don't see GGP's point about making this specific action illegal as the solution. Seems to me that it would the just complicate things and in the end negatively affect everyone.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by clarky07 on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:24PM
(#9209153)
We only see one side here. perhaps they did ask nicely, and the renter said no.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
by tizzdogg on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:25AM
(#9210142)
It is fairly standard practice in San Francisco for landlords to offer high tens of thousands of dollars to renters for them to move. I have a friend who paid a tenant $60k to move out. This allows them to avoid the complications and restrictions of the Ellis act or owner move-in (notably restrictions on condo conversion).
But, that doesn't make it a fun process to go through for a renter. It sucks. Couldn't the owner just ask the person who is renting the unit to move out in a reasonable amount of time? That seems like the ethical thing to do.