News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by tsally on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:11PM (#920760)
To: The profit mongering companies with lobbyists and idiotic politicians who cause legislation like this to be created.

We'd like our internet back now.

Sincerely,

The Compter Scientists, the group of people who invented the internet.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by pg on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:48PM (#920806)
The problem is not companies that are "profit mongering" (whatever that means). It's companies with obsolete business models that are willing to destroy the more dynamic parts of the economy in their fall.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by tsally on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:47PM (#920921)
I was attempting to get at the destructive themes associated with the phrase "war monger". To be more precise, I was trying to describe companies that don't mind destroying innovation in order to make profit. My language was too loose, but I think we're both coming from the same place.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by amichail on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:11PM (#920850)
But won't much stronger copyright enforcement allow these companies to survive?
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by pg on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @11:01PM (#920954)
History doesn't offer much encouragement. New technology is often opposed by existing interests that are threatened by it, but I can't think of a lot of examples where they've succeeded in holding it back for a significant time.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by billswift on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @04:24AM (#921368)
Japan retreated from the gun (and the outside world) for several centuries. Without an outside world to break in, they might still be there.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by johnaspden on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @05:37AM (#921445)
And China put the brakes on all innovation.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by eru on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @12:25PM (#922083)
Much of Europe shies away from a lot of genetic manipulation.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by tumult on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:24PM (#920874)
Temporarily, it will allow certain parts of these established corporations to continue with their current model and still have some sort of revenue. Eventually, they will die. Whether or not something like ACTA will prolong or hasten their death (due to backlash) I'm unsure.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by netcan on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:30AM (#921193)
In some cases, the shift to digital content has shaken business models in a way that is not recoverable and has nothing to do with the enforcement of copyright. Newspapers are mostly examples of this.

The old world of media had a price for each viewer/reader of various mediums. The new world of media also has a price too and the old price doesn't apply. Readers are now usually worth substantially less then they were. An online news impression is worth less than a print one. In parallel, the democratisation of the web has created additional competition that has taken away some eyeballs, especially in the juicy parts of the business (eg classifieds). The effect of aggregators as competitors is an example of the type of effect that hurts them and is related to copyright somehow. This last is a very small & insignificant part of why they are failing.

In some cases, copyright enforcement might theoretically recover some or all of their revenues. Music is an example of this. If people couldn't pirate music, they would probably buy more of it. The move to digital probably affects sales somehow, but it is not necessarily negative. Film, TV, Books etc. are also examples of these cases.

The first type of company has business models made obsolete by technological & cultural changes. The second kind have business models that fail because the lost the ability to enforce copyright. Companies of the first kind usually think that they are of the second. Both types of companies would be happy if the Internet just went away.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by regularfry on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @05:05AM (#921416)
At what cost? Of course you can dictate that anything MUST survive by fiat if you want, but when does it stop being worth it? They're imposing quite a heavy inefficiency on an expanding portion of the economy, for what is, in absolute terms, not that great a benefit. The old-school media companies just don't have that large a turnover, all told. They just have glamour on their side.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by blhack on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:49PM (#920808)
To: The profit mongering companies

I believe the preferred nomenclature is "profiteering gluttons".

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by derwiki on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:51PM (#920809)
someone's been watching 'Hackers'
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by blhack on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:57PM (#920816)
Haha

I did "The Hacker's Manifesto" for a speech contest in high school...it was just funny and a bit painful when that movie came out.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by blintson on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:37PM (#920793)
Bitching about it accomplishes nothing. I doubt there's anybody here who thinks this is a good thing, and even if there were, that sort of language persuades nobody. The smart thing to do is to write your congressman, and get people together to protest. Anybody here have any experience with politics and know what we could do to stop this?
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by aohtsab on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:26PM (#920881)
You are right: bitching does nothing, yet writing our representatives is almost as bad. I interned for a certain senator a while back—all the letters that people sent in were recorded as tallies in a system, and the responses were typed up by office staff. By the way: most of the letters which were sent in were spam—the same letter with different signatures.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by dkokelley on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:50AM (#921219)
I think calling might be considered more effective. It shows that you are willing to invest enough time and actually make your concerns heard. I think they might weight calls like TV networks. Your 1 call counts as 1,000 people who wouldn't care to call. Of course the most effective thing to do would be to befriend your congressman personally.

On a larger scale, organizing a sort of free internet seal of approval for all representatives could be even more powerful. If representatives know that voters would be more likely to vote for candidates with the seal of approval, then they might be persuaded to earn that seal.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by ascuttlefish on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @09:30AM (#921704)
Sometimes others find the words better than I can, so I sign a generic form letter to my member of Parliament. It's not really spam. It's heartfelt.

Edit: I just wanted to add that while generally I agree that writing letters has little to no effect, I think it's important for people to start DOING something. If it starts with writing letters, maybe the upshot will be that people are embolded to participate in bigger future actions, like taking part in demonstrations and more when the time comes. Cynicism and defeatism aren't the right starting attitudes for a fight. Just my two cents.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by tumult on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:31PM (#920897)
I don't actually see anything wrong with that. The problem is that they don't seem to do anything with the numbers they gather.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by aohtsab on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:52PM (#920940)
Very true. From what I understood, the data was nothing more than something for the senator to chew on.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @08:24AM (#921599)
Spam? My signature is valuable, even if attached to a petition. Shame on you.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by danek on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:47PM (#920924)
so there's no point in ever crafting a nice letter? good to know.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by tumult on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:39PM (#920796)
Protesting does nothing.

edit: I'm specifically talking about in-the-streets-marches kind of thing.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by blintson on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:42PM (#920801)
Then what? It's better than complaining on a website where everybody agrees with you. I'm going to do something. We've got to do something. The situation's bad enough as it is.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by pg on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:57PM (#920820)
I agree with you. If the entire tech community was up in arms about this (assuming the treaty is really as bad as this article says), I think politicians would notice. They are not all in the pay of the movie business. The more neutral ones might wake up if it appeared the treaty was going to do net damage to the US economy.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by hackerblues on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:10PM (#920845)
From the wikipedia page ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protests_against_the_Iraq_War )

"According to the French academic Dominique Reynié, between January 3 and April 12, 2003, 36 million people across the globe took part in almost 3,000 protests against the Iraq war.[3]"

Protests don't seem to have a very good track record.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by pg on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:57PM (#920948)
I'm not just (or even) talking about people taking to the streets. If this report is accurate, the treaty would hurt VCs, and VCs aren't powerless.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by tdonia on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:10PM (#920843)
should this prove to be true, this is an excellent opportunity for [google | yahoo | microsoft | apple | facebook | any other major tech company that relies on people making things with computers] to petition against this with their ad dollars in a very vocal manner. being the first to rally people against this seems like it'd be far more culturally relevant in the long term than spending the money on a superbowl ad and billboard campaign saying "my brand is good".
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by danek on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @11:10PM (#920966)
does the EFF lobby?

if not, maybe what we need an organization to lobby on our behalf.

maybe a new startup could somehow do this? i don't know how it would get the money to do so...

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by InclinedPlane on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:15PM (#920860)
Destroy them, fund the competition. Boycott any company that encourages the use of DRM. Pirate their products and distribute them via encrypted, untraceable networks like TOR, or plain old sneaker-net. Support individuals and companies who avoid DRM, who treat their users with respect, and who distribute their works directly, etc.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by tumult on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:47PM (#920804)
I don't know. We're probably fucked.

If you believe you can stop this by writing to your congressperson or protesting: why do you think this is being done in secrecy? Obviously, they are fully aware nobody is going to like it. It will be enacted regardless.

That being said, I would still like to do as much as I can to prevent it, or in the case that it's enacted, circumvent it or corrupt it to the point of uselessness. At this stage, I don't think there's much we can do just yet. We also can't be sure this report is accurate.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by daeken on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:48PM (#920805)
We find a silly case under this law that would've been legal previously, then get a few hundred thousand (or more) people to download it, willingly putting the content up in violation all at once. Civil disobedience isn't the best choice necessarily, but it can work quite well in situations like this.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by tumult on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:27PM (#920885)
Why hasn't this worked for the DMCA?
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by daeken on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @10:49PM (#920931)
Little organization. There haven't been any well organized attacks on the DMCA, which is necessary for it to work.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by Quarrelsome on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:29PM (#922239)
You could always create a worm that installs utorrent and starts downloading any popular file going.

Once the worm is in the field then how will they tell who are real pirates or hapless victims?

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by roc on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @05:35PM (#922767)
I think the more conscionable peaceful protest would be to wardrive around your town and download various torrents through any and all wifi APs that you can access.

This wouldn't require violating anyone else's machines, but would have much the same effect. (presenting the ISP with the prospect of cutting off a huge percentage of their customers, i.e. revenue)

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by Quarrelsome on Thursday November 05, 2009 @05:32AM (#923624)
Yes but that requires serious logistics to do on a massive scale, furthermore peaceful was never a caveat. People are saying "what can we do? what power do we have?". As programmers we could do that. I'm not saying that is the right choice.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by roc on Thursday November 05, 2009 @12:47PM (#924272)
It only took a handful of lunch counters and a handful of busses.

With today's media, it certainly wouldn't take more than a handful of towns. Most of us probably have enough people in our personal social graph to pull it off.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by stse on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:49AM (#921218)
Protesting might be a first step, but what really counts is organizing. The Pirate Party started in 2006 and now has a man (and maybe soon a woman) in the European Parliament and active parties in a dozen countries. I know some people are skeptical to the whole phenomenon, but that's mostly because they don't understand where it came from. I'm not saying that starting a political party is the right thing to do in the US, but organizing and getting heard probably is.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by cpach on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @06:03AM (#921479)
Yes, due the Lisbon treaty the Pirate Party will have a second chair in the European Parliament.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by Create on Thursday November 05, 2009 @03:45AM (#923547)
...but the EP is a puppet compared to the ECs (Council and Commission)
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by cpach on Thursday November 05, 2009 @04:28AM (#923577)
I'm afraid you might be right about that :-/
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by rms on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @01:25AM (#921182)
Most protests do nothing, but at a certain point protests can bring down governments. That's why the Tienanmen square massacre happened and why the more recent Iranian election protests were violently stopped.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by amichail on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:36PM (#920790)
What effect would this have on the US economy?
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by stse on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @02:12AM (#921243)
To: The Compter Scientists, the group of people who invented the internet.

Hey, maybe you could invent some technology which actually provides some privacy and security instead of all this 80's tech?

Sincerely,

The Users, the group of people who use the Internet on a daily basis.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by tsally on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @02:41AM (#921273)
Everything needed to achieve a high level of security and privacy on the internet has already been invented. If you're looking for a reason why reality doesn't reflect this, you'll have to look at some other force besides the researchers.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by stse on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @03:43AM (#921328)
I'm glad to hear all solutions has been found. Still, last time I checked researchers actually had a lot of influence on the evolution of the Internet.

Edit: What I'm really saying is that if there would have been an implemented, 'universal', solution that takes civil liberties into the digital world, then it would be much harder to take these liberties away. I really don't think most politicians understand neither technology nor the fact that they are in effect infringing civil liberties like anonymity protection, freedom of expression and secrecy of letters. Who's to blame for this? Probably no one and everyone, still sad to see though.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by tsally on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @04:54AM (#921403)
Still, last time I checked researchers actually had a lot of influence on the evolution of the Internet.

The last time you checked must have been in the 80s then. If researchers still controlled the development of the internet, would we be having a debate about net neutrality?

Politically I agree with you, but you vastly overestimate the power of researchers.

Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by stse on Thursday November 05, 2009 @02:05AM (#923481)
Maybe I should put my location (Sweden) in my profile and hopefully it's just the cultural differences that make you come across as arrogant. I do think there are some organization (ISOC, "IETF", IAB) who might not share your opinion and I guess the last time I checked was back in 2005 when DNSSEC was first implemented for the .se TLD.
Re:Secret copyright treaty leaks. It's bad. Very bad. by tsally on Friday November 06, 2009 @07:54PM (#927314)
No, it's not a cultural difference, I can be a bit abrasive. It's not anything directed at you, just frustration that researchers don't have a more direct pipeline for getting things done. I definitely wasn't going for arrogant though, so sorry about that.

Sweden rocks as far as a lot of privacy issues go. Sweden (along with a couple other countries) were early adopters for DNSSEC. I wish we could be more like Sweden; the US is not so quick. Verisign (a for profit company) wont deploy DNSSEC on .com and .net until 2011. By contrast domains administered by the US government and a non profit (.gov and .org) are supposed to have it done by the end of this year. I think these differences illustrate nicely the point I was trying to make. Security can sometimes take a back seat on the priorities list, and even the US government and a non profit are far behind countries that choose that make it a priority.