News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by eranation on Friday March 13, 2015 @01:41PM (#9198473)
Great idea. my 2 cents:

1 - you HAVE to say something on whether this is a bot or a human. when I was single I would have happily paid for unbiased professional advice from a real person of the opposite sex on what to say / behave in a date. Once married, I think the notion of my wife finding me texting a woman named Alexis is going to have the opposite effect ;)

2 - no validation on the form. I just pressed the button and saw a yellow banner saying "Finding Alexis...". It still does that. (no timeout handling either)

3 - no about, no FAQ, no address, no phone number, no company name, no support email. I'm not going to give you my phone number, sorry

Again, this is a great idea, but a little too Minimal to be a Viable Product in my humble opinion... (fast forward 3 months, this is a YC company with a valuation of 1 billion and I look like an idiot... but I think the above 3 will help it get there sooner...)

EDIT: favicon - this is silly, but everyone has it...

Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by minimaxir on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:34AM (#9197282)
I'm not entirely sure why this is explicitly gender-specific, given the unisex example questions.
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by gk1 on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:59AM (#9197459)
I think it's based on columns from men's magazines where readers send questions to a relationship, sex, or dating expert, and get them answered in the next issue. The premise is this: "Hey, you're a clueless _guy_ and I'm a _girl_. You have questions about girls, and I am obviously qualified to answer them because I am also a girl and I have a modern + sexy + feminine name like Alexis."
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by bch on Friday March 13, 2015 @03:01PM (#9199208)
I upvoted the GP. I had the same puzzlement.

> "Hey, you're a clueless _guy_ and I'm a _girl_. You have questions about girls, and I am obviously qualified to answer them because I am also a girl..."

That doesn't follow (that you need a girl to answer, or that any girl is qualified), and in fact is insulting.

Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by stephenboyd on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:07AM (#9197505)
I suppose AskAlexis is a catchier name than AskAdamKochanowicz.
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by minimaxir on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:01AM (#9197473)
This is an interesting comment because Alexis is historically a gender-neutral name: http://www.behindthename.com/name/alexis
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by gk1 on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:03AM (#9197484)
You're right. But can we still agree that it's modern and sexy? /s

Main point is that it's all based off the "takes one to know one" idea, in which one woman answers questions from men about all other women.

Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by msellout on Friday March 13, 2015 @01:37PM (#9198446)
In the thread below she quickly introduces herself as Lexi, which is not only a more feminine name, but also perhaps an allusion to a lex-er, as in lex and yacc?
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by proveanegative on Friday March 13, 2015 @01:28PM (#9198384)
It may be a deliberate move to allow one later to expand into advice about men for women without charging the brand name.
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by chinathrow on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:41AM (#9197333)
No imprint, no privacy policy, nothing. But I should submit my cell number? Seriously?
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by minimaxir on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:49AM (#9197377)
Magic had a barebones page with no privacy policy too (and still does, surprisingly), yet thousands of people gave them their cell number.

That's not a good thing, but still.

Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by eranation on Friday March 13, 2015 @01:47PM (#9198517)
Sorry for being so outdated, but what is this "Magic"?
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by xoqem on Friday March 13, 2015 @01:58PM (#9198633)
It is a text message service that purports to handle just about any request you make (food delivery, whatever), they just tack on a fee to the price. They had to limit to a wait list, as the demand exploded.

Site: http://getmagicnow.com

HN Dicussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9087819

Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by chinathrow on Saturday March 14, 2015 @12:54PM (#9203240)
How do you now, that thousands of people provided their cell number? Did they make those figures public?
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by rikkus on Friday March 13, 2015 @12:40PM (#9198088)
I had a go.

  Alexis: Hey, I’m Alexis. I’m here with the answers you need to level up your lifestyle.
    Send me questions anytime about dating, style, food/wine, entertainment… all of it.
    I’m your secret weapon! 08:42
  Me: I'm stuck in the cockpit of the fighter jet I was flying. I've crashed on the border
    between Hungary and Slovakia. I only speak English. How should I proceed? 08:46
  Alexis: Okay, this is a new one. 08:46
  Alexis: Give me a couple minutes to think about that. By the way, you can call me Lexi,
    what can I call you? 08:46
  Me: You can call me James. 08:56
  Me: I would ask you to send for help, but my mission is secret. I have rations for a
    couple of days, but it's hard to drink while hanging upside down by straps. 09:00
  Alexis: Bummer. 09:01
  Alexis: Undo the straps. 09:02
  Me: Also I don't want to ruin my tuxedo. 09:02
  Me: The mechanism seems to have jammed. 09:03
  Alexis: Sweet, you have a tux too? Your life is exciting. 09:05
  Alexis: Er, was up until now. 09:05
  Alexis: Have you tried your pen? It's also a scaffolding hook and ultra high powered
    laser. 09:06
  Me: I've tried using the laser in my watch to cut the straps, but it seems to have
    been broken in the crash. 09:08
  Alexis: James how did you get this far with such bad luck? 09:08
  Me: Ah, the pen... Great, the straps are cut. I can hear footsteps. I'll have to be
    quiet for a minute. 09:09
  Alexis: Should I stop texting you? It might ding. 09:09
  Alexis: Oops 09:09
  Alexis: Are you dead? 09:10
  Me: They must have heard me tumbling out of the straps onto the cockpit roof.
    I've been apprehended and am in the back of a van. 09:10
  Alexis: It's weird that they didn't take your phone away. 09:11
  Me: I distracted them with my bonhomie. 09:11
  Alexis: Use one of your gadgets. 09:12
  Me: It sounds like Hungarian they're speaking. I think they said they're taking me
    to 'the palace'. Is there a palace near here? 09:12
  Alexis: Idk. Where are you? 09:13
  Me: Somewhere on the border between Hungary and Slovakia. 09:13
  Alexis: You're in luck! They're taking you to the Four Seasons
    https://www.google.com/maps/place/Four+Seasons+Hotel+Gresham+Palace+Budapest
  Me: Will I be in time for dinner, and if so, what wine should I order? 09:17
  Alexis: How much are you looking to spend? Red? 09:20
  Me: Red, of course, I'm sure they're not savages! I'm sure cost won't be an issue. 09:25
  Alexis: Chateau Haut-Bailly Pessac-Leognan 2004 09:27
  Alexis: classic aromas of scorched earth, sweet black currants, cherries, and a hint
    of pain grille. Light on its feet, but substantially flavored 09:27
  Me: Thank you, I knocked on the cab and (in my best Hungarian) asked the driver to
    telephone ahead and check it's in the cellar. You've been a great help! 09:30
  Alexis: You got it. Don't forget to explode something and walk away from it slowly
    without looking back. 09:31
  Me: Yippee ki yay, good sir, as I believe you say over the pond. 09:39
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by Silfen on Friday March 13, 2015 @02:14PM (#9198786)
This exchange, if legitimate, seems to strongly indicate that this service is not automated. Either that or huge strides forward have been made in chatterbots...
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by rikkus on Friday March 13, 2015 @05:37PM (#9200254)
The exchange is legitimate, but I'm not actually James Bond.
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by hiharryhere on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:21AM (#9197578)
Is it free? No hint of pricing
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by jonlucc on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:35AM (#9197296)
I don't see an about page, is this entirely automated on the Alexis end? Could I send a picture of two outfits and ask which looks better? Does it have location-aware suggestions?
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by minimaxir on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:37AM (#9197307)
This appears to be a copy of Magic (apparently "Magic for X" is now a market category?), so it is likely unautomated.

There's also a reason you haven't heard about Magic in weeks.

Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by stephenboyd on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:13AM (#9197538)
Magic is supposed to do stuff for you, acquiring goods and services. This just sends SMS responses, so it's more like ChaCha. Though ChaCha has a broader focus than clueless men who need generic date plans from a stranger.
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by jonlucc on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:38AM (#9197315)
Thanks. I'm not really in the loop; why haven't we heard about Magic in weeks?
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by minimaxir on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:44AM (#9197346)
From what I've heard, people gave up at the waitlist. The unit economics do not make sense either: the CEO said that they break even overall, which is unsustainable when you consider cost of human capital/oppertunity cost. http://techcrunch.com/2015/02/27/catch-a-tiger-by-the-toe/

However, from their Twitter account, Magic is apparently not dead. https://twitter.com/tweetmagicnow

Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by mooreds on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:53AM (#9197783)
Following that link, I found an ad for customer service reps for $20/hour in Mountain View. http://www.higherme.com/jobs/135

Is that a livable wage?

Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by CleanCoder on Friday March 13, 2015 @12:10PM (#9197896)
From their site: "Initial hires start at $15/hour, with the opportunity to move up to $20/hour quickly!"
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by petercooper on Friday March 13, 2015 @03:42PM (#9199505)
The median income in Mountain View is around $55K - $20 an hour salaried is roughly $42240.. but customer service tends to be below average salary in any area. Many earn less.
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by captn3m0 on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:30AM (#9197633)
Wasn't the Amazon Echo service also voiced as "Ask Alexis" (the phrase used to activate it, like "OK Google", or "Siri")
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by morley on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:33AM (#9197654)
Echo used "Alexa" as the activation word.
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by neilellis on Friday March 13, 2015 @01:37PM (#9198445)
For middlebrow comments, please see below:
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by sleepyhead on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:31AM (#9197640)
Cool story bro.
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by RIMR on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:32AM (#9197651)
Oh, an automated SMS chat number? How very original... If it were the early 2000's.
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by petercooper on Friday March 13, 2015 @03:43PM (#9199515)
Y'know, I heard this sort of comment when I got into email newsletters back in 2010. Now every damn site seems to have email newsletter signup boxes, lol.
Re:Show HN: AskAlexis, an SMS advice service for guys by upofadown on Friday March 13, 2015 @12:46PM (#9198122)
Well this makes sense because women are strange alien creatures that are impossible to understand.

But how can I know that I will have my question answered by an actual woman? If a guy responds to my question it might seem reasonable to me but I would risk causing the woman to become angry or confused...