News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by davidw on Friday March 13, 2015 @06:52AM (#9196488)
If you're from the US, you have to file a US tax return, wherever you live, even if you pay taxes locally.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_taxation

It's the only country in the world that forces its citizens to do so (besides Eritrea), which is why record numbers of people who don't live in the US are giving up their US citizenship.

If you actually have residency in some country, then you probably need to pay taxes there. But if you're actually being a 'nomad', are you going to be anywhere that long?

> If I had an accountant I wouldn't be searching for this info!

Find one, then; ask your friends for recommendations. If you are a US citizen, then there is likely a tax treaty between the country you are a resident in and the US. You need an accountant that knows about this. I'd be happy to recommend one for Italy.

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by sitkack on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:21AM (#9196565)
From my understanding, please correct me, is that America(tm) requires that you never _save_ money by leaving the country and working somewhere else.

Say your US tax rate is 27%, you are working in Canada and your tax rate is 32%, you pay Canadian taxes first, then file with the US which charges you nothing.

If you are working in a place with a 5% tax rate, you will owe the US the difference. When you are a US citizen, your global minimum tax rate is your US tax rate. You can never save money on taxes by leaving the country, only by giving up citizenship.

You can save money on taxes by living somewhere with a lower cost of living, make less, spend less.

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by bcg1 on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:10AM (#9196720)
This is pretty much my understanding as well.

OP, everyone hates taxes, but I would not recommend having a flippant attitude about not needing professional assistance with your situation. Especially with FATCA in effect.

YOU NEED PROFESSIONAL HELP, DON'T FSCK AROUND UNLESS YOU WANT TO GO TO JAIL. That said, if you want to do your own research, I doubt this information is made up:

http://www.irs.gov/Individuals/International-Taxpayers/U.S.-...

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by tallanvor on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:50AM (#9196665)
Sort of. There's the Foreign Earned Income exclusion that allows you to deduct $100,800.00. There are also deductions for housing costs if you live overseas. If your income exceeds that (and other deductions), then you may have have to pay taxes on the excess income. This depends on whether or not the US has a tax treaty with the foreign country and which country has higher tax rates.

In the end, it means you have to earn quite a bit to have to pay any US taxes when living overseas, but it can happen. The big hassle is having to file returns no matter what. It can end up being pretty complex.

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by kalleboo on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:49AM (#9197042)
> The big hassle is having to file returns no matter what

There's also the problem of the USA imposing FATCA reporting requirements on foreign banks who have American customers. This can make it a lot more work for an American to sign up for a foreign bank account, and reportedly some banks are outright refusing any customer who walks in with an American passport because they don't want to open their books to a foreign entity.

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by briandear on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:47AM (#9196830)
I would beg to differ on the saving money on taxes. I live in France, I have the $96,000 foreign exclusion, so the first $96,000 I make is US-tax free. I have to pay taxes everything above that no matter where I live.

The following is just for informational and entertainment purposes only.

So, if I were to hypothetically make $200,000 per year, I would pay US taxes on roughly $104,000 per year, instead of $200,000, plus I get to take deductions. So If I have $20,000 in deductions, I pay taxes on $84,000.

When I file my French taxes, my income justification is based on my Adjusted Gross Income on my US tax return since I don't make any money from French-EU companies. If I make $200K, have $96K excluded because of the foreign income exclusion, then $20K deductions, my AGI is roughly $84,000. So the $84,000 is my income in terms of France. Now, I get to then take whatever French deductions we are eligible for and pay taxes on whatever the reminder happens to be. Let's say that remainder is $80K. I now pay French tax on that $80K, which would be taxed at an effective rate of 22% (the French system is similar to the US in that each "band" of income it taxed at a higher rate with the top marginal rate being 45%.) So that's roughly $17K in taxes, which are then dollar-for-dollar deductible from US taxes owed. (That dollar for dollar deduction is based on the US-France tax treaty, so that might not apply to other places.)

Let's say the approximate effective tax rate of $84K is roughly 22%. That means I'd owe $17K to the US, but I paid $17K to France, so I pay zero US taxes under this scenario and overall I paid $17K in taxes on $200K in income, which works out to an 8.5% tax rate. This of course would not apply if you earned income from within Europe.

If you want to live in the Bahamas and you have an adjusted gross income of $96K or less per year, you'll pay zero total taxes. Same for Bahrain, Brunei, Kuwait, British Virgin Islands. But you also have countries that don't tax your worldwide income, only income earned within that country. So if you're clever and do your research, you will absolutely save money on taxes living outside the United States. You also get the bonus of not paying any state income taxes either. Given the EUR/USD weakness at the moment, there really hasn't been a better time to live in the EU if you're making US dollars. However, the tax regimes of each country are often very different, so do your homework.

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by patio11 on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:05AM (#9196895)
When I file my French taxes, my income justification is based on my Adjusted Gross Income on my US tax return since I don't make any money from French-EU companies.

This step is, and I am choosing my words carefully here, criminally fraudulent. If this is your actual tax strategy, speak to an accountant. They will say "NON!"

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by briandear on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:56AM (#9197077)
AGI is what the French social security, the CAF (Caisses d'Allocations Familiales) office and every other public office uses to determine our income. That wasn't our choice, it's what they use.
Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by maxerickson on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:34AM (#9197280)
There's a big chance that When I file my French taxes, my income justification is based on my Adjusted Gross Income on my US tax return since I don't make any money from French-EU companies. isn't the right way to interpret the source of your income.

(I'm not offering that as advice, I'm pointing out that those offices are relying on a characterization that you and whoever is paying you are making. A US corp with all of its operations in France probably doesn't qualify as a non EU entity...)

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by Jolijn on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:23AM (#9196959)
I'm sorry to say this, but this is extremely fishy and I hope it is all hypothetical. If it's not hypothetical you've just confessed to tax fraud.

Either way, it's bad advice.

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by codecamper on Friday March 13, 2015 @05:04PM (#9200026)
Can you describe an actual problem with his outline? I think it is very good to get this sort of first hand advice. In my experience it is very hard to find an accountant that understands this stuff well.
Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by maxerickson on Friday March 13, 2015 @05:20PM (#9200137)
I'm not a tax lawyer, but since I don't make any money from French-EU companies probably isn't relevant to French income tax rules.

If you live and work in a place, the rule of thumb is that your earned income will be taxable there, regardless of who is paying you.

(my brief understanding is that France does have an exception for income that is sourced from the US. But this means things like investment income. Work for hire performed in France for US companies would not be attributable to the US under such a rule)

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by codecamper on Friday March 13, 2015 @05:46PM (#9200298)
OK, yes that makes sense.

I'm more interested in the FEIE myself. I'm traveling Europe, UK, and Morocco in a motorhome, earning income from an app along the way.

I think this means that as I'm < 3 months in any one country I do not need to pay taxes in any of them. And for the US I can claim the foreign earned income exclusion as I'm out of the country > 330 days of the year.

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by davidw on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:25AM (#9196575)
It's complicated, but under a certain amount of money, what you write is generally true. It's still a complete load of bullshit, as it requires you to spend time and energy and money dealing with something you shouldn't have to.
Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by rayiner on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:29AM (#9196978)
When my dad was working in Yemen in the early 1990's, the civil war broke out. C130s lifted him and a bunch of other American citizens out of the country at the first opportunity.

Outside the U.S., waving around an American passport still carries weight, and if you live in a tax-treaty country, all you pay for that is some additional paperwork.

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by briandear on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:15AM (#9197177)
When the US Marines come rescue me from my house in the south of France, I'll write them a check for the evacuation. Until then they can f'off. My American passport doesn't give me any advantages overseas, in fact, it gives me far less advantages than a Swiss passport would.

I pay more for visas (thanks to visa reciprocity agreements,) I have more difficulty opening bank accounts (assuming I can even open one at all,) AND I have to file taxes based on citizenship and not residency. The US is one of the few countries in the world that have citizenship-based taxation. FATCA is also an egregious breach of privacy. The US strong-arming countries into reporting on ALL bank accounts held by Americans. The person only has to declare them if the balance exceeds $10,000 at any point during the year, however the banks are still obligated to report them. My little boy who was born in France, but he's an American citizen by birth, has never been to the US and yet even his little bank account (opened by the bank with 40 Euro as a gift,) gets reported to the US government. He's six months old and already in an IRS database. If he made phone calls or used Facebook, he'd likely be in an NSA database as well.

To get slightly political here, if ISIS were to kidnap me, I'd be dead. Four French journalists -- Nicolas Henin, Pierre Torres, Edouard Elias and Didier François, who were kidnapped in Syria last year by ISIS -- were released in April.

One of those hostages, Henin, had been held by ISIS alongside James Foley. Henin is free, and Foley is dead. The only difference between the two: their passports.

Don't get me wrong, the US is my country. I fought for the US as an army officer (2003-2007). However, patriotism is more than waving the flag, it's calling out the nonsense when necessary.

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by davidw on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:21AM (#9197210)
> To get slightly political here, if ISIS were to kidnap me, I'd be dead. Four French journalists -- Nicolas Henin, Pierre Torres, Edouard Elias and Didier François, who were kidnapped in Syria last year by ISIS -- were released in April.

I wasn't going to mention that, but yeah, it seems like countries like Italy and France pay up to get their people released. Let's please, please not have the discussion over whether that's in general a good thing or not, but if it were my own neck on the line...

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by davidw on Friday March 13, 2015 @04:44PM (#9199929)
Point out what's not true, downvoters. The press here in Italy widely reported rumors of payments being made for hostage releases.
Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by davidw on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:40AM (#9197012)
I don't live in a country where I'm likely to need an airlift out. That kind of thing is extremely rare, and in any case other countries also manage it without taxing their citizens living abroad.

> if you live in a tax-treaty country, all you pay for that is some additional paperwork.

If you start adding stuff up, between an accountant, time off work to meet him, and so on, it adds up to several hundred dollars, which is not chump change to me.

And all that after I've already done my Italian taxes, which are not fun at all, either. But I live here, get free health care here, and so on, so fair's fair.

It's still worth it to keep the citizenship for me, for the option value and because I have family there, but I do feel ripped off.

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by kalleboo on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:53AM (#9197064)
And when Anthony Bourdain filmed No Reservations in Beirut when the 2006 Lebanon War broke out the Americans were some of the last to be lifted out and they got to pay for the privilege.

I don't really think US passports are worth that much more than f.ex. any EU country. I don't think the people resigning their US citizenships are swapping them for Nigerian ones.

Re:Ask HN: Digital nomad taxes – which country to pay in? by maxerickson on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:26AM (#9196576)