Outside the U.S., waving around an American passport still carries weight, and if you live in a tax-treaty country, all you pay for that is some additional paperwork.
I pay more for visas (thanks to visa reciprocity agreements,) I have more difficulty opening bank accounts (assuming I can even open one at all,) AND I have to file taxes based on citizenship and not residency. The US is one of the few countries in the world that have citizenship-based taxation. FATCA is also an egregious breach of privacy. The US strong-arming countries into reporting on ALL bank accounts held by Americans. The person only has to declare them if the balance exceeds $10,000 at any point during the year, however the banks are still obligated to report them. My little boy who was born in France, but he's an American citizen by birth, has never been to the US and yet even his little bank account (opened by the bank with 40 Euro as a gift,) gets reported to the US government. He's six months old and already in an IRS database. If he made phone calls or used Facebook, he'd likely be in an NSA database as well.
To get slightly political here, if ISIS were to kidnap me, I'd be dead. Four French journalists -- Nicolas Henin, Pierre Torres, Edouard Elias and Didier François, who were kidnapped in Syria last year by ISIS -- were released in April.
One of those hostages, Henin, had been held by ISIS alongside James Foley. Henin is free, and Foley is dead. The only difference between the two: their passports.
Don't get me wrong, the US is my country. I fought for the US as an army officer (2003-2007). However, patriotism is more than waving the flag, it's calling out the nonsense when necessary.
I wasn't going to mention that, but yeah, it seems like countries like Italy and France pay up to get their people released. Let's please, please not have the discussion over whether that's in general a good thing or not, but if it were my own neck on the line...
> if you live in a tax-treaty country, all you pay for that is some additional paperwork.
If you start adding stuff up, between an accountant, time off work to meet him, and so on, it adds up to several hundred dollars, which is not chump change to me.
And all that after I've already done my Italian taxes, which are not fun at all, either. But I live here, get free health care here, and so on, so fair's fair.
It's still worth it to keep the citizenship for me, for the option value and because I have family there, but I do feel ripped off.
I don't really think US passports are worth that much more than f.ex. any EU country. I don't think the people resigning their US citizenships are swapping them for Nigerian ones.