News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by jasonfried on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:29PM (#917655)
I don't think it's strange that I don't read fiction. I've met plenty of other "creative" people who don't read fiction either. Nothing against other people reading fiction, I'm just not interested in it.

I watch movies and I'll watch TV shows, but if I'm going to spend dozens and dozens of hours reading, I'd rather read about something that's real. There's plenty of creativity in the real world. More than I'd ever be able to discover in 100 lifetimes.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by caffeine on Monday November 02, 2009 @03:43PM (#917860)
I watch movies and I'll watch TV shows ... There's plenty of creativity in the real world

You realize that movies and TV shows most certainly do not constitute the "real world"?

Nobody says you have to read fiction. But it's really a shame to take the weaker forms of escapism the world has to offer you rather than the deeper, ecstatic ones, just because the latter are in book form.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by run4yourlives on Monday November 02, 2009 @04:05PM (#917918)
I don't think he's taking "weaker" forms of escapism as he's taking shorter ones.

I still find his stance different as a lover of fiction, but I can't argue that a good book isn't also very time consuming, and if you allow that your time is precious, there are probably better uses for it.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by caffeine on Monday November 02, 2009 @05:17PM (#918092)
I think TV shows and movies are weaker. Movies can't do what books can do because you don't create them in your mind as you consume them (or at least not in the same way).

But I can see why for some people, the basic realism of film might take them even further than a book and their own imagination. My original post sounded a bit more judgmental than intended.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by petercooper on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @08:59AM (#921647)
I share your viewpoint. Like Fried, I don't read fiction novels either but.. I do read short stories from time to time. Especially J G Ballard.

It's all about the time issue for me. I read lots of long novels as a teen but it's either do that or actually do some work nowadays.

As an aside, the death of the short story as a significant literary force is worth mourning here too..

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by buugs on Monday November 02, 2009 @08:46PM (#918386)
He is most definitely not speaking like TV and movies are the real world as your quote seems to make out. I also tend to stay away from fiction other than the occasional short story and find that autobiographies and other forms of non-fiction offer a nice creative boost in their writing.
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by ivankirigin on Monday November 02, 2009 @05:16PM (#918091)
Check out this story: "How Nonsense Sharpens the Intellect" http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/06/health/06mind.html?_r=2...
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by antonovka on Monday November 02, 2009 @08:04PM (#918321)
I will come out and say it: categorically dismissing fictional books as "not real" (and therefor uninteresting) is both strange and stupid.

Fiction can be as real as the author wishes to make it, as an endeavor to elucidate their ideas and insights regarding the 'real world' through the telling of a story. I'd never be so audacious as to state "I hate non-fiction, there's very little to learn from boorish, presumptuous, and poorly considered interpretations of the author's reality"

This sort of navel-gazing article is uninteresting and of questionable real-world value, reminiscent of breathless puff pieces on the (soon to be forgotten) luminaries of .com technology that were so popular in the mid to late 1990s.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by fnid on Monday November 02, 2009 @08:24PM (#918354)
It's not real. At best it is anecdotal. It's a story. It's imagination. It's entertainment. It's a very expensive form of entertainment when you value your time.
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by antonovka on Monday November 02, 2009 @08:29PM (#918358)
It's not real. At best it is anecdotal. It's a story. It's imagination. It's entertainment.

Why are ideas presented in the form of non-fiction any more "real" than ideas presented in the form of fiction?

Even the most literal non-fiction remains an expression of the author's opinion and ideas.

It's a very expensive form of entertainment when you value your time.

I find what I learn from well-chosen fiction and non-fiction to be equally valuable, and I value my time quite a bit.

I also would be very surprised that anyone who has time to comment here doesn't have time to read a fiction (or non-fiction) book.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by fnid on Monday November 02, 2009 @08:50PM (#918396)
It's not about having the time or not, it's about what you choose to read when you do have the time.

The difference is that when you read fiction, you are in a world, a physical land that is entirely constructed by the mind of the author. The characters aren't bound by the same laws of physics that you and I are. When characters make decisions, the other characters react in the way the author wants, but real people may not react that way.

With nonfiction, there are rules. With fiction, there are no rules. In fact, you don't know what the rules are when you read fiction.

You know that quote about those who don't read history are doomed to repeat it? Well, there is a lot of history to read.

They're two different universes. One, fiction, is framed in a universe where we don't exist. The other, nonfiction, is in the same universe we all share here. In fiction, what goes up may not come down. If you shape your life or make decisions based on fictional ideas, they don't always apply in the real world. Sometimes they may, but mostly they do not.

Yes, you are right, lots of insights can be gained from fiction. I learned a lot reading slaughterhouse five. It's fiction, but it's also pretty real in a way. I learned a lot from 1984. I learn a lot from science fiction.

But there are is also a lot to learn and a lot of insights to be gained from nonfiction as well. Truth is stranger than fiction.

Think of it this way. If you only read fiction for the rest of your life, could you program a computer? Could you build a house? Could you understand quantum mechanics or any myriad other practical skills? Probably not.

This of course is my opinion, but if I had to choose between a future life of only fiction reading or a future life of only nonfiction reading, I would choose nonfiction. I think nonfiction is a better learning tool and a greater benefit to my life than fiction, because through nonfiction, I can learn facts that I can't learn through fiction. It's actually difficult and confusing sometimes to decipher truth from fiction.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by antonovka on Monday November 02, 2009 @09:11PM (#918418)
Think of it this way. If you only read fiction for the rest of your life, could you program a computer? Could you build a house? Could you understand quantum mechanics or any myriad other practical skills? Probably not.

My practical skills are only useful in their relation to my human condition, both of which warrant exploration.

This of course is my opinion, but if I had to choose between a future life of only fiction reading or a future life of only nonfiction reading, I would choose nonfiction.

Fortunately for all of us, that choice is entirely unnecessary, and I've no problem suggesting that anyone who actually dismisses either fiction or non-fiction is demonstrating a remarkable, frightening lack of insight.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by fnid on Monday November 02, 2009 @10:44PM (#918532)
Do you believe the human condition cannot be explored through nonfiction? Would you entertain the idea that perhaps it may be possible to explore the human condition deeper and more profoundly through nonfiction than through fiction?

I think it's actually quite insightful to understand that.

Find me a fiction book more profoundly descriptive of the human condition than The Divided Self by RD Laing.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by antonovka on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:05PM (#918554)
Do you believe the human condition cannot be explored through nonfiction?

No.

Would you entertain the idea that perhaps it may be possible to explore the human condition deeper and more profoundly through nonfiction than through fiction?

It's not a contest.

Find me a fiction book more profoundly descriptive of the human condition than The Divided Self by RD Laing.

You don't believe his book is an exploration of his own personal perspective on reality and meaning?

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by fnid on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:43PM (#918617)
I believe it is a contest, because we have a limited amount of time on earth. If you could do either A or B and you believe B is better, then why would you do A?

Of course The Divided Self is his exploration of the topic, but it's sold in the nonfiction section.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by antonovka on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:54PM (#918633)
I believe it is a contest, because we have a limited amount of time on earth.

Well, you have enough time to comment here. Is this really a better exploration of the human condition (or whatever it is you want to achieve through reading) than non-fiction books?

If you could do either A or B and you believe B is better, then why would you do A?

In reality, fiction and non-fiction are not mutually exclusive unless you're obtuse enough to make them so. They're not even clearly distinct in their value or purpose.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by fnid on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @12:07AM (#918651)
Using language like "obtuse" isn't really conducive to conversation. They are different. Yes, there can be facts in a fiction book and fiction in a nonfiction book, but they are categorized differently. Humans need groups to put things in and we put books into groups based on fact and based on imagination.

I'm actually doing about 5 things right now. Playing a poker tournament, chatting with my wife, commenting here, watching an animal documentary on tv, and designing a new feature for my web application.

If I was reading, I'd only be doing one thing.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by kingkawn on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @09:50AM (#921752)
I'd be hard pressed to argue that our imagination does not change our reality.
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by abalashov on Monday November 02, 2009 @05:26PM (#918102)
I agree strongly with your stance on fiction, and am of a similar mind. I was surprised to see someone share it, especially a known "creative" personality, given the tight coupledness of fiction to the worldview and mass-cultural constellation of the technical profession.

Movies and TV shows are principally fiction, sure; I think the salient distinction that people who are prejudiced against "fiction" make is as to the realism and real-world viability of what is involved, i.e. the way that "historical fiction" might stand in contradistinction with Harry Potter-style "fantasy."

I, for instance, as an otherwise ardent nonfictionalist, enjoy Star Trek, but don't enjoy Harry Potter or Tolkien novels. Take that for what it's worth.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by axod on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:35PM (#917673)
Do you not read fiction at all ever, or just not regularly?

I don't regularly read fiction, but I have about 3 novels that I've read in my lifetime that were absolutely spell binding, like the best movie * 1000. Never been absolutely tied to a book that you literally can't put it down until you finish it?

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by jasonfried on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:52PM (#917720)
I don't read fiction at all anymore. Used to, but I have limited time for reading these days so I choose to focus on non-fiction. That's what I find the most stimulating and interesting.
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by jrockway on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:57PM (#917736)
You don't really get to see into the author's mind when you are reading non-fiction; it's all about the facts. With fiction, the author's creativity is not restrained by actual happenings. (Books like "1984" are worth reading, even if they are not a factual account of events that took place in 1984.)
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by jshen on Monday November 02, 2009 @03:28PM (#917810)
"You don't really get to see into the author's mind when you are reading non-fiction; it's all about the facts."

This is very wrong.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by jrockway on Monday November 02, 2009 @05:33PM (#918117)
I should have qualified that with "as deeply".
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by jshen on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @03:00PM (#920109)
which is still wrong. If we use your example of Orwell, "homage to catalonia" may be a more deep insight into his mind than 1984.
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by tptacek on Monday November 02, 2009 @03:47PM (#917874)
So you can't tell the difference between how David Foster Wallace, William Langeweische, and Steven Levitt see the world by reading what they write? Or the difference between a conservative-leaning historian and a liberal historian? Come on.
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by Psyonic on Monday November 02, 2009 @04:27PM (#917981)
You realize that DFW was primarily a fiction writer, yes? Sure we all like A Supposedly Fun Thing I'd Never Do Again, but Infinite Jest was his Magnum Opus, and was fiction.
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by tptacek on Monday November 02, 2009 @04:42PM (#918017)
What's your point?

Without getting into the Latrodectus Mactans Productions quiz to prove our geek/hipster DFW cred: I just picked three writers of nonfiction with both very different prose styles and very different worldviews, and I don't think you'd disagree with my point.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by asnyder on Monday November 02, 2009 @07:18PM (#918272)
Sometimes you can get a good piece of non-fiction that's done very well. For instance, I recently read Newton and the Counterfeiter and found it excellent. In this case fact was far more interesting than any fictional account could've been. Furthermore, I was personally more interested in the outcome since the events actually happened. I get an interesting story, and learn history at the same time. Personally I couldn't ask for more.
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by petercooper on Wednesday November 04, 2009 @09:00AM (#921650)
Ditto. Except I do occasionally read some good short stories - particularly J G Ballard's. You can get some really mind-bending stuff in < 20 pages from the right authors. It's a shame the format isn't more popular. You can pick up insights and feelings that non-fiction rarely delivers.
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by tome on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @09:32AM (#919337)
Can you share what they are please?
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by kingkawn on Monday November 02, 2009 @05:46PM (#918143)
Some fiction is realer than reality.
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by bradlane on Monday November 02, 2009 @09:45PM (#918460)
"The difference between fiction and reality?? Fiction has to make sense." --Tom Clancy
Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by gord on Monday November 02, 2009 @09:48PM (#918462)
Thats kind of the definition of good fiction [or good art, even highly abstract art]...

eg. Neal Stephensons Young ladies illustrated primer or Cryptonomicon strike me that way - they make you think even more about what is real.

Re:The Way I Work: Jason Fried of 37Signals by alnayyir on Monday November 02, 2009 @11:46PM (#918620)
I love that on hackerne.ws the poster/creator of the content you're discussing is far more likely to respond to what you're saying.

I've been a programmer (professionally) for 3-4 years now, been coding far longer than that and was wondering what your feelings were regarding CompSci degrees and the necessity (or not) of them.

Also, have you considered separating the "less is less" product and then creating the more "enterprisey" product as a separate entity and allowing your customers to upgrade within your product range instead of having in and out customer numbers?

I mention this as I think of companies that exercise pretty vigorous product differentiation (Microsoft's OEM versus Corporate licensing, Apple-anything) and your comment regarding not wanting to make your flagship product intimidating to new customers.

Just wondering what your thoughts were on those two questions, thanks.