News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The TSA's FAST Personality Screening Program Violates the... by dragonwriter on Friday March 06, 2015 @05:13PM (#9159932)
> The Constitution is a domestic instrument.

The Constitution is the basis of all US government authority, it is not merely a "domestic instrument".

> It does not limit what the United States can do abroad,

Several provisions of the Constitution directly and explicitly concern what the United States can do abroad, and which institutions of the United States government are entitled to do those things, so that seems an implausible interpretation.

> and the founders were clear that it wasn't meant to do any such thing.

The founders were quite of different minds on many points, and you can often find founders on multiple sides of any issue (including matters of Constitutional interpretation.) Where's the evidence that the founders, collectively, were "clear" on this point?

> As for "international law"--there is no such thing.

The Constitutions grant of power to Congress to "To define and punish [...] offenses against the law of nations;" certainly seems to suggest that they thought that the "law of nations" was not a phrase that referred to something nonexistent.

> The U.N. is not a sovereign entity

No, its a product of treaty, ratified by the US Senate under the provisions laid out for such in the Constitution.

Re:The TSA's FAST Personality Screening Program Violates the... by rayiner on Friday March 06, 2015 @05:33PM (#9160048)
"It results that the investment of the federal government with the powers of external sovereignty did not depend upon the affirmative grants of the Constitution. The powers to declare and wage war, to conclude peace, to make treaties, to maintain diplomatic relations with other sovereignties, if they had never been mentioned in the Constitution, would have vested in the federal government as necessary concomitants of nationality. Neither the Constitution nor the laws passed in pursuance of it have any force in foreign territory unless in respect of our own citizens." United States v. Curtiss-Wright Export Corp., 299 U.S. 304, 318 (1936).

The U.S. cannot engage in war because the Constitution says so. It can engage in war because it's a sovereign country, and waging war is a characteristic capacity of sovereign countries. Admittedly, the U.S. has entered into certain treaties limiting itself in the conduct of war.[1] But in that case, the U.S. is bound not because of "international law" but because those treaties translate international law into domestic law. And it is bound only to the extent it has agreed to be by those treaties.

[1] E.g., the Geneva Conventions: http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2013/04/drone-strik....

Re:The TSA's FAST Personality Screening Program Violates the... by jimktrains2 on Saturday March 07, 2015 @07:32AM (#9161692)
> "The powers to declare and wage war, to conclude peace, to make treaties, to maintain diplomatic relations with other sovereignties, if they had never been mentioned in the Constitution, would have vested in the federal government as necessary concomitants of nationality"

And the Constitution only mentions these to prevent member-states from partaking in these actions of their own accord. A 1936 ruling is a generation after the Civil War, so there is a predominate interpretation of who was actually a sovereign at the time, right?

I'm not arguing with you, I just find the topic interesting to say (basically) "we can do this because we're a country" when that hasn't always been the end-all-be-all of it.

Re:The TSA's FAST Personality Screening Program Violates the... by dragonwriter on Saturday March 07, 2015 @12:35PM (#9162403)
> And the Constitution only mentions these to prevent member-states from partaking in these actions of their own accord.

No, the Constitution mentions them to assign what agents of the government have the power to do them, and the conditions on the exercise and the interrelations between those powers and other powers.

Note that, pieces of the powers related to war, peace, and foreign relations are assigned to different entities in the Constitution (some to the Congress, some to the President, and some to the Judiciary.)

Re:The TSA's FAST Personality Screening Program Violates the... by dredmorbius on Saturday March 07, 2015 @01:51PM (#9162647)
Your war argument boils down to "who gives authorization and to whom".

International law is both a fairly novel and fluid concept, and as with product guarantees, grants of legitimacy or otherwise vary greatly in there effects. Much of the UN's power lies in the Secretary General's authority to give a stern talking to of those chuffing the General Assembly, subject to approval by the Security Council or veto by any of the Permanent Members.

There are numerous countries which have acted either in opposition to UN measures, or which have succeeded in blocking actions to sanction them within the UN.

There are also other international legal arbiters though their authority is not universally recognized, e.g., the International Court, or more complex arrangements under various international criminal law constructions.

All are routinely flouted.

A country could allow for itself no military or violent action -- I imagine that the hypothetical Constitution of the Jainist State might do just that. In which case the country would, by its own laws, have no legal right to offensive or defensive action causing harm.

I'm finding dragonwriter's arguments far more persuasive here.

Re:The TSA's FAST Personality Screening Program Violates the... by rayiner on Saturday March 07, 2015 @04:11PM (#9163145)
Why do cats have the capacity to kill mice? Because they're cats. Nobody gives them the right to kill mice. It's silly to even ask the question. They may choose to do it or not. But having the capacity to do so is characteristic of their very existence.

That's basically the premise of Curtiss-Wright. It rejects the idea that the federal government requires an affirmative grant of power to exercise sovereign powers abroad, because those powers "would have vested in the federal government as necessary concomitants of nationality." The Constitution might impose a certain allocation internally about how that power is exercised, but it doesn't really purport to limit the scope of those powers in any significant way.

Re:The TSA's FAST Personality Screening Program Violates the... by dredmorbius on Sunday March 08, 2015 @01:49AM (#9164845)
Put a cat in a context in which it's subject to the authority of another entity and that specific cat might well find that it is expected to behave in a specific way toward mice -- either to kill them or not. And that the cat might be rewarded and/or sanctioned based on that activity. I'm not arguing that this is a legal context, but that rights and obligations exist within a power and control context, which might or might not exist.

Regards C-W, your quoted passage states specifically "unless in respect of our own citizens". Which is to say that U.S. law, under C-W, can specifically govern the actions of the US and/or its citizens.

The recent record also seems clouded. There have been individuals whose extradition to the US has been sought (or secured) for actions occurring principally or totally outside the U.S. The case of Manuel Noriega comes to mind:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manuel_Noriega#Criminal_prosecu...

"In April 1992 a trial was held in Miami, Florida, at the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida in which Noriega was tried and convicted on eight counts of drug trafficking, racketeering, and money laundering."

There's also Executive Order 12333 2.11:

"No person employed by or acting on behalf of the United States Government shall engage in, or conspire to engage in, assassination."

http://www.archives.gov/federal-register/codification/execut...

http://www.cnn.com/2002/LAW/11/04/us.assassination.policy/in...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_12333

Further, your use of C-W doesn't support your previous statement: "[The Constitution] does not limit what the United States can do abroad". It simply states that there do exist powers which, even if not explicitly listed in the Constitution, would exist. Not that the Constitution could not specify, define, and/or limit such powers.

Which in fact it does -- the United States cannot engage willy-nilly in international agreements with other nations, or engage in acts of war. Both of these require specific actions of affirmation vested in the Legislature: Declaration of War by the full Congress, treaty approval by the Senate.