Even when migration is allowed, people don't just move to better off-areas en masse. We see this with US states and countries in the Schengen Area. Somehow even Greenfield, CA ($9,226 per capita per year) manages to exist less than two hours from Palo Alto ($56,257 per capita per year).
I think the Schengen treaty approach of slowly adding new countries is a good long-term strategy, and I think US should join it. The population of the Schengen area is already 100M higher than the population of US, and there are several cities there that have higher living standards than anywhere in the US.
Turkey population ~75 million has accepted 1.5 million of them with ~200,000 more looking to enter the country.
For scale there are around 10 million illigal immigrants from Mexico. Picture another 5 million showing up next year with zero notice.
Don't get me wrong I think most countries could accept far more immigrants, but the much of the world is a long way from what most HN are used to. Consider, ethnic cleansing' is not just something that happened in WWII, it far more common than people want to admit. Poverty, language, ethnicity, and culture are real issues and complex issues.
PS: I think most people should read though every item on this list at least once. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_cleansings And then realize a lot of things did not make the cut.
Okay, so you accept 5% of population, it doesn't help much the rest 95% of it. And then you struggle to assimilate them and may become a warzone yourself.
The commenter was talking about "slowly" adjusting rules and a very thought-out plan. Not "next year" and "zero notice".
Of course, some people stay. But some people always stay - "Greenfield, CA" is a place that would still exist be there 15 thousand residends or ten times less.
By the way, maybe you can consider it insignificant already.
I actually didn't think of it from that angle. I guess it could be argued that poor countries shouldn't enter reciprocal open border agreements with rich countries, out of their own self-interest. I'm guessing the movement of these Baltic people mostly benefited their new host nations, though?
Poor countries often only have bad choices. Either you leak population but get money from abroad workers, soften tension and enjoy capital movement - or you try to restrain population, get even poorer (less eager capital, same amount of export-able work for less people), face grief and political instability.
In that respect you can compare Baltics with Ukraine.
The difference to Ukraine is that the Baltic nations grew strong enough already during the final decades of Soviet Union, and they still remembered their pre-war independence.
In 1959, the population of Estonia was roughly the same as in 1939. The difference was that almost a third had been replaced by Russians.
Ethnic Estonians had been first purged by USSR in 1939-1941, then killed by war going back and forth over the country in 1941-1944, and then purged again by Stalin's further repressions until 1950's, by moving people to camps all over the Gulag and killing them there. After that, there was a bit of dual existence, and "Druzhby narodov nadozhnyy oplot!" was rather a less reliable bulwark of friendship than the song was saying.
Then, in 1991, came the singing revolution. After that, many Estonians have migrated to Finland, Sweden, Germany, and other countries, but they send money back home. In exchange, Estonians get guest workers from Russia or Belarus in the same way. Still, it's not that easy for Estonians, as for instance trained doctors and nurses often leave the country after their training.
Ukraine, in contrast, was run by various Russian cronies - the Orange revolution could not build nation -and has had endemic corruption all the time.
What you say about poor nations having bad choices is right as you either leak population or you build a police state that tries to restrain population. Education and eradication of corruption will help, but it's very slow work. I think the Baltic states are showing the way there.
Of course that doesn't hold true for all occupations. Doctors being a sore point, for one - they can't make what they would abroad mostly because most of the people are still paid miserable wages and won't be able to afford healthcare which would pay really high salaries to doctors.
This is an interesting thread about people being surprised about it: https://www.reddit.com/r/Eesti/comments/2xqd01/can_someone_e...
Quality of life is just worse in those regions. It's not very much, but still noticeable. One of the reasons why this is the case is just income being lower for equivalent work. Richer countries just tend to have the better companies with more reach.
It's real. People move different state to live and to do business for various reasons but most are really the benefits that other states offer.
There is a difference between nationalism (being loyal and passionate about one's nationality) and identity. This is particularly obvious when it comes to ethnicity and nationality. Do I identify myself as Chinese or Chinese American? As a Chinese do I identify myself as a Chinese-speaking HK person or a Chinese? Does one identifying oneself as American because of natural birth is the same as being a nationalist? When two New Yorkers ask each other "where are you from" is it significant to hear "I am from Queens", "I am from Bronx"? You don't hear two people say "I am human, an earthly being" because obviously they are human and it would be redundant to even say to each other as introduction. Context, audience matters.
Having a nationality is one form of identity. Yet, some don't have that nationality tag like many here do.
In China there is census register system (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hukou_system). Basically you can live anywhere you want, but you will be treated as second-class resident outside of your birth/registered city/town. If you are wealthy, fine, if not, you are just as nobody as homeless. This including your education and social welfare. One of the key reasons for this is to manage population distribution and welfare distribution.
I doubt the issue is as simple as I believe you intend - I don't think there are many examples of draconian cities eliminating homelessness via exports. I also don't think overly generous cities are swamped as much as you believe - size of city & climate are larger factors in homeless population size than generosity.
http://www.kgw.com/story/news/2014/07/26/12578644/
http://thinkprogress.org/health/2013/09/11/2602391/san-franc...
Is there any evidence that this has ever actually happened? I have a feeling it is one of those lies that get passed around by people trying to score political points.
A little over half of the homeless population stay put, but from the populaion that starts migrating.
http://web.utk.edu/~edegeorg/TECH521/LaTeX/Migration.pdf
surveys identified the four most common reasons for mobility.
(1) No jobs available
(2) Eviction from housing
(3) No affordable housing available
*(4) No services available
Additionally, those surveyed revealed strong common reasons for choosing the move destination. *(1) The presence of relatives or friends in the new community
*(2) Shelters or missions were present in the new community
(3) Jobs were available in the new community
*(4) Good services and programs for the homeless were available in the new community
Note, 1 is part of the feed back loop as a homeless person will often have other homeless friends.
Consider a basic US example. City's deal with their homeless populations in different ways, but if any city is overly generous it quickly gets swamped. Further, cities can export their homeless by being overly draconian. Net result, it’s basically impossible to deal with the homeless problem at the local level.
Now, scale that up to 2 Billion poor people around the world.
PS: The tragedy of the commons applies to far more than just land. Closed national borders allow for significant social progress which is otherwise impossible as it would otherwise need to scale beyond what any country could possibly support.