News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by lectrick on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:52AM (#9131568)
As a stable store of value... Not for a while. (Then again, gold has been around for awhile, and is IT a stable store of value?)

As a value exchange mechanism... Certainly. Already useful (and troublesome, to certain establishments) for that.

As a secondary ("world"/"international") or even primary currency... Only if your already-legitimized currency is performing worse (hmmm, Argentina, Greece, Iceland, Russia...).

As a third-world currency exchanged via cell phones... Well, now we're talking. Although anything that stores value can be used in the same way, which is exactly how M-Pesa started out as phone credits (the "base" or "backing" value) and is now used for much more than that.

I will say that anyone who travels (still a very underrated undertaking that abysmally few Americans engage in) has been frustrated by currency exchange. If I could default to something like Bitcoin when I travel, it would ease that pain quite a bit.

Governments are concerned about "capital flight". Thing is, it's difficult to destroy (as well as to create) "value," it usually just gets transformed. It therefore stands to reason that if you don't want your country's value to flee, stop debasing your own currency (so that people stop exchanging it for other currencies), and make things of value (so that more representations of value, i.e. cash, flow into your country).

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by vidarh on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:36AM (#9131747)
> As a value exchange mechanism... Certainly.

I'm working on a side project at the moment, and one of the fantastic parts of dealing with crypto coins is that going from nothing to being able to take payments is down to installing bitcoind (or the equivalent for other coins) and issuing jsonrpc commands to it.

Especially in countries where signing up to take payments by cards is cumbersome/slow, that's fantastic.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by pakled_engineer on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:55AM (#9132063)
Even easier if you just generate addresses into a db, or use electrum type seed wallets to safely generate on a remote server without worrying about keys getting stolen.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by pjc50 on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:32AM (#9131724)
Bitcoin gives you two currency exchange transactions to do where previously there was only one. I can't really see it taking off except for transactions that are banned from one of the other payment systems, and given that transactions are entirely public with persistent pseudonyms, that's not great either.

Bitcoin's transaction cost and risk is necessarily greater than any centralised solution, so as soon as it establishes a useful market it can be undercut. (Don't quote the minimum transaction fee in response to this, quote the miner electricity cost per transaction, the exchange bid/offer spread, and the escrow fees if relevant).

It's entirely trivial for value to be destroyed: this is what happened in the leveraged property downturn as recently as 2008.

"Just fix your current account deficit" is about as useful a piece of advice for countries as "just create jobs", ie not very.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by tokenizerrr on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:46AM (#9131781)
> Bitcoin gives you two currency exchange transactions to do where previously there was only one

What? Only if you don't treat bitcoin as a currency. If bitcoin is used as its own currency, and both you and the seller hold bitcoin, there is no exchange, or at most one: When you buy in from your existing currency.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by michaelt on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:59AM (#9131837)
This is why to be a value exchange mechanism, you also need to be a store-of-value mechanism.

If the buyer and seller aren't holding bitcoin, a simple fiat transaction turns into three transactions.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by IkmoIkmo on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:19AM (#9131919)
> Bitcoin gives you two currency exchange transactions to do where previously there was only one.

Not true. Bitcoin in and of itself doesn't work like this. Yes if you have dollars and you need bitcoin then it's an extra conversion. But it's like saying it takes two conversions to use the dollar when you happen to have euros or yen or whatever else. This is a startup phase issue, not a long-term issue. And even if you just begin, you can buy e.g. $1k of bitcoin and buy hundreds of cups of coffee, and only that first transaction was 'double', not the hundreds after. Moot point as far as I'm concerned.

> Bitcoin's transaction cost and risk is necessarily greater than any centralised solution

No it's not. Would you say for example that, putting all the power to vote in elections on 1 person is less risky than democratically letting the country vote? Centralized solutions are more prone to corruption, 'too big to fail', and lack any redundancy. A decentralized solution however is very hard to corrupt, if any of its elements fail it can continue to exist, and thus it's less at risk of individual failure.

Transaction costs of centralized solutions aren't necessarily cheaper. They certainly can be, I agree. But that doesn't mean it will be. The reason for that is that payment networks like Visa operate with billions of plastic cards with passwords written on them and chips that can be scanned by thieves just sitting nearby with a computer, millions of vendors with archaic hardware, with an insurance product built on top of this unsafe 1950s invention known as credit cards. There are huge costs involved here. A network so expensive that there are only a few major credit card players involved. Same with something horrible like SWIFT. If anything, this is a payment system that will be disrupted and undercut, not the other way around. Perhaps after that we'll see a centralized solution that's actually better and cheaper than both, sure, but it's like saying let's not invent the car even when it's better than the horse, cause we may invent flying cars that'd be even better so why bother. It'll just be 'undercut' anyway.

> don't quote the minimum transaction fee in response to this, quote the miner electricity cost per transaction

On the first point: electricity costs of miners is not a marginal cost, thus you can't quote it as a transaction fee. It's a systemic cost. i.e. 25 bitcoins are rewarded every 10 minutes with every block regardless of whether there were 0 or 1 trillion transactions. Just think about that for a moment. It's a systemic cost to run the network even if NO transactions happen at all. It's not tied to the transaction number. Fees are. Block rewards are not. And in the long term, which we're talking about, block rewards are zero. And given that blocks are on a course to go from 1 mb to 1 gigabyte in the next few decades (under the plan of Chief Scientist at TBF Gavin Andresen, we're looking at 1000x more transactions. As such, transactions can replace current block rewards and then some, without increasing the fee per individual transaction (a few pennies). To compare this with roughly 30c + 3% fees on a purchase of a $1k laptop that credit cards or Stripe or Square or Paypal offer you is ridiculous. On the smaller end, microtransactions aren't even possible with most payment systems today, and on the larger end of the spectrum, million dollar transactions still cost pennies with bitcoin.

> the exchange bid/offer spread

Again, treat it as a currency. To use a currency there is no conversion involved. We covered that already. You can already get paid in bitcoin and pay bills in bitcoin, and remember we're talking longer term where paying with bitcoin is like the choice to pay with cash or card: ubiquitous.

But hell, even if you want to include the conversion like any other currency: check the bid/offer spread at your bank for dollar/euro, or at Paypal, it isn't pretty. Meanwhile at Circle the bid/offer spread is 0 and you can instantly buy and sell bitcoin. And at large exchanges the spread is generally much less than what I see at my bank or paypal (when I say generally read always, but I'm saying generally as I'm sure there are exceptions to be found.)

> this is what happened in the leveraged property downturn as recently as 2008.

You're misconstruing his point about capital flight. i.e. that is that if you build a house and create construction jobs, have value in the house, sell said house for money and then leave the country with said money by exchanging it for a foreign currency, the house is still there and the money didn't leave, it was bought by someone with foreign currency who obviously wants to spend that money in your economy. Nothing really left and no value was destroyed. There are certainly some effects but his point is that value isn't destroyed, it's just moved around or transformed.

"Just fix your current account deficit" is about as useful a piece of advice for countries as "just create jobs", ie not very.

Agreed that's a bit too simplistic. But I think the larger point he made holds true, that most governments over the long run shouldn't have to worry about capital flight. It's just one of many forms of protectionism that will fade away with time, and with it, one of the big reasons countries like China don't want bitcoin to become too big.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by rtpg on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:47AM (#9132027)
would just like to point out that bitcoin is fairing much worse than the currencies of Russia, Iceland, Greece, or Argentina, so not necessarily a great primary currency
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by lectrick on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:09PM (#9133302)
> faring much worse

You have to specify a timeframe when you claim this. For example, Bitcoin has been quite stable for the YTD. (Well, at least as far as Bitcoin goes.)

https://bitcoinwisdom.com/markets/coinbase/btcusd

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by chisleu on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:50AM (#9132040)
would just like to point out that this isn't true.

It had a huge spike of worth that was total bubble and it has deflated from it. It is still up dramatically from when I started buying them at $5 each.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by grey-area on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:52AM (#9132366)
That huge spike also makes it terrible as a medium of exchange. A currency which suffers speculative bubbles is not a good one.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by shillster on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:56PM (#9133572)
We live in a world filled with speculative bubbles. You have speculators to thank for their price discovery efforts. This enables you to pay the "true value" of a given commodity at a given moment in time.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by grey-area on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @06:38AM (#9137163)
That's a rather circular definition of 'true value', which assumes that we live in the best of all possible worlds where the market is infinitely efficient.

I disagree that speculators have any role in discovery of true value - on the contrary, they mask true value and ensure our markets are inefficient, panicky, and volatile.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by shillster on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:42PM (#9145909)
I was making a sarcastic remark, echoing the sentiment of all of the "free market" zealots and politicians. Not only are they talking out of both sides of their mouth, their statements are misleading as we see in hindsight.

The only benefit I can see is there is an overall increase in liquidity but the cost of that liquidity is quite high.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by mootothemax on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:37AM (#9131749)
On a day-to-day basis, bitcoin takes ages to confirm that payment has been received, supports somewhere around 3 [three] transactions per second, and shifts risk from sellers to buyers (e.g. compare refund possibilities with credit cards).

There are various hacks that are being proposed to increase the number of transactions per second, and reduce confirmation time. Ultimately, they're just that, though: hacks on a proof-of-concept.

What I'm really interested in is whether it's possible to have a cryptocurrency that doesn't rely on e.g. blockchain technology.

How you'd fix the issue of double-spending ("I can just copy-and-paste my money - yippee!") without a blockchain or equivalent is beyond me.

I'm just really intrigued by the idea of being able to cryptographically sign over a digital $5-equivalent -note to someone else, instantaneously, and without relying on a third party saying "Hmm, yep, that note looks legit to me".

Sadly, a lot of bitcoin's popularity seems to come from people who sincerely hope and believe that it's their lottery ticket to millions in the future. Whilst these people are vocal, it's probably a good idea to be aware of and filter out their voices.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by eblanshey on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:11AM (#9131888)
> What I'm really interested in is whether it's possible to have a cryptocurrency that doesn't rely on e.g. blockchain technology.

Yes, it is possible. MaidSafe is building the solution as we speak, and does not get anywhere near the attention it deserves. Because there is such a general lack of understanding of its underpinnings, it is usually lumped together with other blockchain technologies or altcoins. There is no blockchain, there are no transaction fees, and transactions are irreversible almost immediately (no confirmation time). There is no wasteful mining.

I wrote a pretty comprehensive article[0] on how it works from a technological standpoint if anyone is interested. Perhaps someone will find it useful.

[0] http://blanshey.com/introduction-to-maidsafe-what-it-is-how-...

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by mootothemax on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:44AM (#9132010)
MaidSafe is building the solution as we speak

Doing an admittedly very brief search, it seems there's a lot of scepticism about MaidSafe, ranging from it's "objectively a scam," through to a highly questionable IPO, and doubt over the core technology itself:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8081247

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7641149

http://www.reddit.com/r/crypto/comments/24zext/what_does_rcr...

Clarifying on my original point about not relying on blockchain technology, I think imagining a purely offline system would get closer to the question in my head.

How much can be done without relying on a network / database / blockchain etc?

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by eblanshey on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:03AM (#9132088)
There is a lot of scepticism indeed, mainly because what they're doing is so new. (The IPO was not questionable at all IMO, that's just FUD.)

In any case, the objections and scepticism is healthy and would only serve to improve the project.

I'm not really sure what you're implying though--how can you have a cryptocurrency without communication (e.g. a network)?

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by mootothemax on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:11AM (#9132122)
mainly because what they're doing is so new

I (possibly obviously) haven't done enough research in the area, but it seems like there are potentially showstopper questions about how to stop people gaming the system.

The reddit link also questioned how much of MaidSafe is, in effect, security through obscurity.

One thing that can be said - it's definitely interesting!

How can you have a cryptocurrency without communication?

Exactly - that's kinda what I'm asking! :)

Another rephrasing: is it possible to have some bitcoin-equivalent token sat on your computer which you can exchange for goods and services without consulting anyone else?

As far as I can tell, it's the double-spending problem that's the killer.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by exo762 on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:45AM (#9132016)
>> shifts risk from sellers to buyers (e.g. compare refund possibilities with credit cards).

Dollar couples financial services with money transmission. Bitcoin allows to decouple those. Refunds can be covered by escrow services (with small help of 3-of-2 multisig) which can be provided by multiple parties, not only by your CC/bank. Please provide a single example of service that can be provided by CCs but can not be provided by companies that operate on Bitcoin network.

>> There are various hacks that are being proposed to increase the number of transactions per second, and reduce confirmation time.

Confirmation time is irrelevant, what you really care about in POS situation is TX delivery time - and it's covered by BIP70. BitPay serves BIP70 since Feb 2014.

TPS scales to Visa levels and beyond and there is nothing "hacky" about that. Increased block size are countered by IBLTs.

Want to talk about hacks of all kind? Talk about today's banks tech. Hundreds of millions of dollars being stolen by hackers, hundreds of billions of dollars of drug money being laundered by HSBC and friends, tech out of sixties, broken security model of CC, huge amount of regulation that attempts to fix all this mess. Costs costs costs. This is unfixable mess.

Disclosure - I own small(!) amount of Bitcoin.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by rtpg on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:50AM (#9132039)
>Please provide a single example of service that can be provided by CCs but can not be provided by companies that operate on Bitcoin network.

more or less instant transactions? Like the guy said, transactions take forever with BTC

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by exo762 on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:17AM (#9132157)
Ok, there are two types of transactions.

Ones where you want to be able to spend money that you've just received - those are slow with Bitcoin (ETA 5 minutes). This is a price you pay for your independence of banks. You can transfer money to anyone anytime and this type of transaction is impossible with VISA.

Other - when you pay with BTC at point of sale (POS) and only thing you care about is your counterparty being able to say "thank you for your money". Those are covered by BIP70, which makes transaction as fast and faster then VISA.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by bjelkeman-again on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:53AM (#9131807)
As to your last point, it always surprises me that an argument for Bitcoin often is made in the style "remove the oppression/control by central banks". To be replaced by what? Oppression/control by early Bitcoin speculators [1]? No thanks.

[1] http://www.businessinsider.com/927-people-own-half-of-the-bi...

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by lectrick on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:28PM (#9133404)
> bitcoin takes ages to confirm

Ten minutes, and if you want to assume just a little bit of risk, you can simply wait until the transaction appears on the blockchain, which is pretty instantaneous. In all my bitcoin transactions, I haven't encountered a single double-spend.

> supports somewhere around 3 [three] transactions per second

This is flat-out wrong. Please check your facts before spreading misinformation. It CURRENTLY supports 7 [seven] transactions per second, and this cap was fixed in software, by limiting the block size to 1MB. It can be raised quite a bit (by raising the maximum block size), the devs were simply a little unsure what would happen, so they capped it at 7TPS. Source: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Scalability

> and shifts risk from sellers to buyers (e.g. compare refund possibilities with credit cards)

Yes, let's compare. You can always reverse a credit card charge, or dispute it. There are known scams done by abusing PayPal, for example.

> various hacks that are being proposed to increase the number of transactions per second

There are no "hacks". It would simply be: Increase the maximum block size. In all likelihood, things would still work fine. Please read the Scalability doc I linked above.

> hacks on a proof-of-concept

Do you realize this "proof of concept" has been operating for 6 years now? With only a couple of hiccups which were quickly corrected? And that there are almost (if not more than) 500 (!) other cryptocurrencies out there, based on the same idea or variations thereof?

> whether it's possible to have a cryptocurrency that doesn't rely on e.g. blockchain technology.

Unknown, unless someone thinks of one. Just like it was unknown whether a decentralized transaction ledger could be secured, before Satoshi Nakamoto thought of one. And when someone does, that could simply be applied to any existing cryptocurrency.

> without a blockchain or equivalent is beyond me.

There is something called "Proof of Stake". You can google. It has some possible flaws, though. There are also other hybrid solutions.

> the idea of being able to cryptographically sign over a digital $5-equivalent -note to someone else, instantaneously, and without relying on a third party

That is impossible. You simply can't "rewrite" the dollar monetary system to use a decentralized technology. They use entirely different semantics. Say I wanted to "convert" an actual $5 to a "new, cryptographically secured, decentralized" dollar. What authority (see, you can't have any authorities in a decentralized scheme) would validate the $5, and then what authority (there's that word again) would issue you a credit in this new scheme? The new scheme would inevitably have to be centralized by fallible humans, unless you came up with a robot that would somehow validate a $20 bill, then completely destroy it while issuing you a "crypto dollar credit", which would somehow magically stay pinned to the US dollar... See, it doesn't work that way. Even "real" currencies don't work that way, they can all be speculated on, it's just that their pool of currency is so much deeper and their penetration so much wider (and their value pinned to enough real-world goods) that nobody really notices the ripple effects day-to-day.

> Sadly, a lot of bitcoin's popularity seems to come from people who sincerely hope

Are you seriously trying to disparage early-adopters, here. The same early adopters who adopt almost all new things and push them out into the mainstream...

> it's probably a good idea to be aware of and filter out their voices

Yes. Screw those rotten kids excited about new things! Let's wake them from their dreams and poop in their cereals, and give them a dose of reality!

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by dagw on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:40AM (#9131762)
Even as a Bitcoin skeptic I'm absolutely convinced that in 20-30 years time something that can directly trace its intellectual roots to the Satoshi white paper will play a significant role in several aspects of financial transactions. The underlying mathematics is just too useful to be ignored.

Actual Bitcoin as we know it today will probably be an interesting historical anecdote.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by swalsh on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:18AM (#9131675)
I bought several bitcoins in early 2010, and when the price peaked to $1000, I sold what I had left. To me I was interested in the technology piece, but thought the economics of it was utterly crazy. Having a fixed supply of some arbitrary number with a fixed release seems so "old worldly". It ignores the fact that we have this huge computer network that has built into it access to near perfect information about the economy.

I thought something better would come along, which is why I sold it. However the one thing that really rang with me was this. When I transferred the bitcoins to my account (bitstamp) I didn't even remember the fee. I'm not certain there even was a fee. However when I transferred the dollars, there definitely was a fee, Which seemed like a lot of money.

The cost of using bitcoin is a really big game changer. If it was stable, I think adoption would be bigger.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by Torgo on Monday March 02, 2015 @12:21PM (#9133014)
I personally have seen interest wane because of several high-profile scams and hacks. I originally knew quite a few people really interested, and I'm pretty much the only one left.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by AlexMuir on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:27AM (#9131710)
I used to joke that I had more bitcoins than I could spend in my lifetime. Not because I had a lot, but because there was fuck all to spend them on.

I just paid for my lunch in Bitcoin. Not as some evangelical, cryptanarchistic statement, but because I have bitcoins and I needed lunch. The mechanism for paying is on a par with credit cards, if not slightly above. I've watched the monetary value of my bitcoins plunge in the last year, but I've seen their practical value to me increase massively. A year ago I could buy precisely zero lunches for 1 BTC, now I'd get at least 50.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by mootothemax on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:52AM (#9131805)
The mechanism for paying is on a par with credit cards, if not slightly above.

Was it really easier than taking out your credit/debit card and "beeping" it against the card reader? (i.e. PayPass/payWave).

Whilst I'm all in favour of pushing new technologies, I simply can't imagine that paying by bitcoin was easier than that!

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by AlexMuir on Tuesday March 03, 2015 @04:56AM (#9136931)
I've never once paid by Paywave, even though I think I have it on all my cards. I don't know if it's a European thing but despite all the tech being installed it just hasn't seen much adoption - I know no-one who uses it. We're still firmly chip and pin.

From a business's perspective though, Bitcoin is immeasurably easier. No approval needed, just buy a £100 android tablet and off you go. Funds available immediately. Compare that to going down the bank and grovelling for them to let you take cards. Obviously it's not close to an alternative yet, but it's an easier flow.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by rhizome31 on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:33AM (#9131727)
Where can we buy tangible stuff with bitcoins? Is it only in the USA?
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by AlexMuir on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:40AM (#9131760)
I'm in Budapest and there are now two bars and a restaurant that take Bitcoin.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by cyphunk on Monday March 02, 2015 @11:57PM (#9136184)
more likely to find more places to buy bitcoin outside the US than inside. In Berlin and there are at least 5 resturants and a dozen other stores of various wares one can use them.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by rukittenme on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:56AM (#9131578)
When Bitcoin was high, it was the future. When Bitcoin is low, does it have a future?

I wish we would make decisions about a technology's or company's or economy's viability based on something less fickle than price.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by piker on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:02AM (#9131851)
Perhaps the price reflects a collective decision about the technology's viability.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by rukittenme on Monday March 02, 2015 @11:54AM (#9132818)
Doubtful, the "wisdom of crowds" is useless for something like Bitcoin. It's too new, too revolutionary, too complex for its applications and failures to be apparent to even a select few. Let alone a statistically relevant population.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by lectrick on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:33PM (#9133443)
Yes.

I've also noticed a funny thing. If you actually understand Bitcoin, you tend to like it. If you don't seem to understand it, you tend to not like it. This is unfortunate. People seem to understand "money" (although they don't), but it is enough that they think they do. Not sure if that will work out with Bitcoin.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by rbfuller on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:38AM (#9131754)
Bitcoin is here to stay for at least this one reason: gambling.

I have bought and sold more bitcoin since I started sportsbooking and playing poker with it than I ever had before.

With services like circle and bitcoin-friendly gambling sites, I am able to instantly deposit and withdraw to my gaming site, and then within 2-3 days have my winnings back into my bank account in my native currency.

It is really a better system than I have experienced gambling online with fiat previously.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by xefer on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:44AM (#9131539)
I'm always amused that every bitcoin story seems to include a stock photo of a shiny physical coin with a big "B" on it.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by dagw on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:45AM (#9131780)
Well a vector version of that image (A big B in gold coin) is the first thing you see when you go to bitcoin.org so you can't really blame the media for following their example.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by lectrick on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:50AM (#9131563)
People still have trouble grasping immaterial, purely-informational things.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by arethuza on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:59AM (#9131588)
I'm pretty sure that 99% of the money I have handled in the last decade or so has been "purely-informational".
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by lectrick on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:02AM (#9131605)
Yes, but you can take a physical dollar out of your wallet and look at it. JUST LOOK AT IT! It's a piece of paper with special ink on it that makes it difficult, but not impossible, to counterfeit! BUT IT'S REAL! ;)

The article mentions that 88% of cash in circulation is in $100 bills. (I know that the percentage of ALL transactions that are in cash is low.)

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by lucb1e on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:47AM (#9131553)
People are always looking for a way to visualize it. Since it is a currency, and people associate coins with currency, what better icon to use?
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by maxerickson on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:19AM (#9131677)
How about a stately, classic bank building engulfed in flames.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by icebraining on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:53AM (#9131572)
A spreadsheet would be a closer representation of Bitcoin. You can make it a paper one if you want a proper photo :)
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by lucb1e on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:58AM (#9131584)
But does a spreadsheet icon look like a currency to you?
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by mrkickling on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:52AM (#9131569)
Well, since it's a crypto-currency, maybe something cryptographic? But I see the point, people associate currencies with coins.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by allemagne on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:31AM (#9131722)
How do you visualize cryptography? A padlock? It might be a cool image to have a stack of those "B" coins with holes punched through them attached to a lock. I don't know if that would really help describe what bitcoin is though.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by maxerickson on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:42AM (#9131769)
A police officer peaking around his blindfold at an ostrich with its head buried in the sand?
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by sfk on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:12AM (#9131895)
A tulip?
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by quinndupont on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:37AM (#9131984)
Perhaps given the source (Wall Street Journal), it is no surprise that they asked a couple of economics professors for their opinions on Bitcoin's future... but, they could have thought a little more creatively about the possibilities.

Dr. Harvey (on the "Yes" side), made the typical gesture, at least part right, that the technology is the interesting part. In fact, the subheading says it all: "Valuing Bitcoin as a Technology"---but an edit would improve the matter: "Valuing Technology"; or simply "Technology".

Other than those who have skin in the Bitcoin game, there's no reason for your average person to care about Bitcoin in particular, but the idea and the technological pursuits that it embodies are worth paying attention to. In fact, I think this is the primary reason HN likes Bitcoin---nobody cares about its economic logic or valuation or whether a new block every ten minutes enables liquidity or not. The IDEA behind Bitcoin, and subsequent cryptocurrencies, is what matters. The TECHNOLOGY that permits novel arrangements of power, social interaction, and human-computer interfacing is exciting.

Personally, I'm ambivalent on whether the technology is, on its own terms, good or bad. But, what I don't doubt, is whether the idea is going to stay---we won't call it "Bitcoin" in 10 years, but we may call it "Ethereum" or "Dogecoin" or something not yet invented. In fact, we'll likely just call it by some acronym only the geeks care about (but everyone uses): like HTTP or USB. The technology will recede from its specular, media-driven attention and just become how things are done. Banks will transfer funds on a blockchain (perhaps the government forces them for transparency and verifiability), ATMs will become decentralized, you'll establish a smart contract with your Uber driver... and so on.[1]

[1] For anyone interested, I'll be giving a talk on cryptocurrencies at NYU this Wednesday (March 4, 5PM), along with Bill Maurer and Finn Brunton. Free registration here: http://events.nyu.edu/#event_id/30104/view/event

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by dontdownvote on Monday March 02, 2015 @11:33AM (#9132658)
Ok, so everybody can make a currency, keep some for them (directly or indirectly), convince people to use it, making it scarce and making the value of it grow. Great idea! How couldn't we think about it before! Let's start with a small group (technical people, in case of cryptocurrencies) that are idealists and full of goodwill. Then we'll pack the idea as the world's salvation from stupid governments and fees. Don't be evil!

Meanwhile my (fat) share of myCurrency is getting value exponentially.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by quinndupont on Monday March 02, 2015 @12:34PM (#9133100)
Far from being opposed to the article's articulation of cryptocurrencies, I see your (sarcastic) response as buying into the very logic of it. Thinking that the problem with Bitcoin and its ilk is its lack of economic stability, liquidity, or whatever economic factor floats your boat is tantamount to endorsing a future version that fixes the issue. You see, you've been trapped into the short-sighted vision that the RIGHT cryptocurrency is just a patch or version away.

The issues with cryptocurrencies are much deeper than implementation errors. I may actually agree with your economic assessment of Bitcoin, but I think that's quite beside the point, and we should learn to speak about the deeper issues and debate these.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by dontdownvote on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:37AM (#9131750)
I'm not an expert in this subject but IMHO:

1-Bitcoin is just an huge ponzi scheme.

The early birds to got into the system are the ones that will have HUGE profits. So I want to create my own currency and be able to get an advantage also.

2-Bitcoin is unfair.

Besides everything governments taking care of currency seems the most fair and democratic way of dealing with it. With Bitcoin technical people have advantage over non-technical people. It remembers me Nietzsche when he writes something like:

"There are only 3 types of people: the rich that wants to keep being rich; the poor that wants to be rich; the intelectual, that using his ideals (advantages) wants to be rich."

[1] Due to the strong bias, I created another account to express this unpopular opinion. Shouldn't be like this.

[edited]

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by lectrick on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:39PM (#9133473)
> With Bitcoin technical people have advantage over non-technical people

With all due respect, I think that is true of pretty much everything. Smart people have an advantage over non-smart people. If you want to level the playing field, you can always research the Hutu massacre of the Tutsis...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rwandan_Genocide

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by witty_username on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:44AM (#9131774)
> The early birds to got into the system are the ones that will have HUGE profits. So I want to create my own currency and be able to get an advantage also.

That is in most part due to a bubble caused by people thinking of Bitcoin as an investment vehicle.

> Technical people have advantage over non-technical people. It remembers me Nietzsche when he tells something like:

Explain?

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by Retric on Monday March 02, 2015 @09:41AM (#9131997)
> most part due to a bubble

Not really, Bitcoin's where front loaded. It would have been easy to have the same fixed number of bitcoins, but set things so only 70% of possible bitcoins where released in the first 100 years.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by nly on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:28AM (#9131715)
Of course it has a future... just not a very interesting one. The messiah period is over, and the technical and practical merits (what few there are) have now been digested.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by dmichulke on Monday March 02, 2015 @07:46AM (#9131551)
Are headlines the new way of discouraging investment in cryptocurrencies given Betteridge's law?
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by snowwrestler on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:53AM (#9131809)
The skeptic says that currency is a security because its issuer will pay you face value for it. What will the Federal Reserve pay me for my dollar? This seems like an outmoded view of what a currency is.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by dontdownvote on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:52AM (#9132372)
Ok, so everybody can make a currency, keep some for them (directly or indirectly), convince people to use it, making it scarce and making the value of it grow. Great idea! How couldn't we think about it before! Let's start with a small group (technical people, in case of cryptocurrencies) that are idealists and full of goodwill. Then we'll pack the idea as the world's salvation from stupid governments and fees. Don't be evil!

Meanwhile my (fat) share of myCurrency is getting value exponentially.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by LukeFitzpatrick on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:49AM (#9131796)
A Bitcoin bot has already been created, it predicts 90% accuracy on future tradings.

What I'm concerned with is, if this made public, would it devalue the worth of Bitcoin?

And, how will Bitcoin deal with quantum computing?

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by PuDDin_Face on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:23AM (#9131692)
"they have no basic underlying value" is not true. Bitcoin themselves are value - intrinsic value. The time it took to mine the Bitcoin is what gives it the value. I think this is a much better measure than we have of actual currency where no one, even the reserve really understands where the value of a dollar is.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by icebraining on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:30AM (#9131720)
LTV¹ applied to Bitcoin? I had never seen that :D

I disagree with your reasoning for the same reason I disagree with LTV. That time is just sunk cost - there's no value to it, and certainly no market value.

¹ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_theory_of_value

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by orbifold on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:24AM (#9132196)
I was under the impression LTV applies to human labor, so applied to bitcoin it would imply that they should have close to no value, whereas fiat currencies derive value from the efforts of the tax payers.
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by lectrick on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:40PM (#9133482)
LTV as applied to Bitcoin uses the many many kilowatts of electricity used to verify transactions as the "labor".
Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by pjc50 on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:33AM (#9131731)
The time it took to mine the Bitcoin is what gives it the value

That's a cost, not a value, and it's a purely wasteful activity.

Re:Do Cryptocurrencies Such as Bitcoin Have a Future? by sz4kerto on Monday March 02, 2015 @08:40AM (#9131761)
If I dig a large hole today in my garden and fill up tomorrow, then does this work have value just because of the time I invested in it? Not at all.

(By the way, us tech people are in a lucky situation exactly because you are not right: we don't work very hard compared to many factory workers in the world but still get very high salaries.)