News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by dyscrete on Sunday March 01, 2015 @08:48PM (#9129847)
Of course take everything with a grain of salt.

The Hacker News community's comments are actually more intellectual than the writer's click-bait propaganda, and leaves room for debate on the author's one-sided views.

Edit: grammar

Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by rodgerd on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:00PM (#9129887)
HN is as much an echo chamber as any other moderated community; the fact you find it a more agreeable echo chamber doesn't mean much.
Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by AnkhMorporkian on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:02PM (#9129899)
Absolutely. Hell, it's much more of an echo chamber than most communities as it's so tightly moderated. Moderation begets echoes.
Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by rtpg on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:09PM (#9129920)
My gut feeling is that community voting is more than enough to make HN an echo chamber.

Think about it, if you see a slightly greyed-out comment, that becomes a data-point in interpreting the comment.

Though compared to other places with such strong voting mechanisms, the echo chamber seems to be less in effect. Only topic I can think about where it really comes out is articles on Uber, bizarrely.

Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by arrrg on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:31PM (#9130018)
I really don’t think it’s that simple. Plenty of anarchic places are also aggressively homogenous in the views expressed there and their overall culture (e.g. 4chan and sites like that).

I think in those places aggression simply serves to push people who would think differently out.

Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by AnkhMorporkian on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:17PM (#9129957)
I'm not sure if that's true. While voting does definitely encourage an echo chamber, it requires moderation so that the true majority doesn't gain a foothold. If it weren't for the moderation on this site, it would be much like reddit.
Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by SquareWheel on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:27PM (#9129996)
Which means nothing, because nearly every reddit community is different.

Moderation plays a small role in the HN community. Any "community bubble" is due to shared interests and a core set of guidelines. This seems like an excuse for making a libertarian rant and nothing more.

Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by AnkhMorporkian on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:39PM (#9130043)
I'm far from a libertarian. I think moderation is a good thing, I just think we need to recognize that it creates bubbles in and of itself. If you want a more concrete reddit example, /r/lgbt and /r/ainbow would provide a concrete example. Moderation provides the tone for a community unless it remains totally unmoderated.
Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by SquareWheel on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:53PM (#9130080)
I don't disagree that moderation can set the tone for a community. I'm just arguing that's not the case on Hacker News. This site has a very strong focus on technology and startups. Any specific niche will create a bubble.

It's also worth keeping in mind that /r/ainbow was created as an alternative after the mess that /r/lgbt became. /r/games from /r/gaming is a similar example. As much as a change in moderation was a focus, it was also a different audience that moved over to the new subs.

Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by AnkhMorporkian on Monday March 02, 2015 @01:01AM (#9130516)
I think HN is less bubbly than most enclosed communities, but it's definitely a bubble whenever it comes to feminism or social justice issues. Check out any post on those issues, check the comments, and refresh. It's intense how many comments are removed.
Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by maxerickson on Monday March 02, 2015 @05:55AM (#9131272)
Turn on "showdead" in your profile. Those comments are removed by user actions (and there is a small difference from removed, they are still available to logged in users that know about that setting).
Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by jerf on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:25PM (#9129988)
I would submit there's a significant difference between comment sites on the original site, and secondary comment sites like Slashdot, Reddit, and HN. The article is clearly about the former. I am not personally aware of a site that at scale (i.e., not a blog with a couple hundred commenters, tops) is worth reading the comments.

Sure, you can write complaints about Slashdot, Reddit, and HN (see siblings of this post competing to see who can slag on them the hardest), but at least there's a chance of some semblance of discussion. That is not a chance that big sites have.

Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by ZanyProgrammer on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:02PM (#9129895)
The Guardian is Fox News for Anglo-American progressives (or at least a certain set of them).
Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by parfe on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:04PM (#9129909)
Users are not permitted to comment freely on HN. Step too far out of line and your comment becomes invisible and you risk a shadow ban. This site offers the most vanilla, white bread, predictable discussion of any forum I frequent. No real surprise about what this user base wants.
Re:Comment sections are poison: handle with care or remove t... by defineclean on Sunday March 01, 2015 @09:12PM (#9129939)
Your spot-on comment is already getting grayed out. Oh the irony.

If the truth hurts... downvote it so it can be hidden! Yeah, that'll show you!