News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by rayiner on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:06AM (#9127542)
The article title is misleading. This measure isn't about state imposed Internet monopolies, but overturning state bans on municipal broadband. On the substance: this is an excellent decision, but needs to go further. The FCC should act to ban anti-competition municipal measures like build-out requirements.

Right now, if you're an ISP startup and you identify some neighborhoods where it would make sense to build fiber, most cities won't let you. Instead, to build anywhere, you have to build everywhere. This is a huge missed opportunity, because competition in even a limited service area could cause change in incumbent behavior if that area is full of lucrative accounts.

Google is leading the way on this as part of it's Fiber deployment, but the FCC has the opportunity to make it national.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by chimeracoder on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:30AM (#9127660)
> The FCC should act to ban anti-competition municipal measures like build-out requirements.

I'm not sure it would be a good idea for the FCC to ban buildout requirements across the board. That seems really heavy-handed.

Buildout requirements can be bad, in that they hold back an entire region to the least common denominator, but they can also be used as a bargaining chip to force service to regions that otherwise would never receive service at all.

Remember that local politicians are much more beholden to the needs of their constituents than the FCC is[0], so if an entire neighborhood is being technologically blighted, it may make sense for the city council or town to use build-out requirements to ensure that those neighbourhoods don't get remain stuck in the 20th century.

I think it makes far more sense to let cities and states negotiate these requirements than to disallow them across the board. Over time, it'll be clear that cities that don't impose all-or-nothing build requirements get much better service in wealthier and denser neighbourhoods (like Google Fiber), and other cities will either follow suit or not.

[0] and this is a good thing; they should be attuned to what their constituents need

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by rayiner on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:37AM (#9127696)
> so if an entire neighborhood is being technologically blighted, it may make sense for the city council or town to use build-out requirements to ensure that those neighbourhoods don't get remain stuck in the 20th century.

But that's not what happens. In all but the wealthiest cities, this just becomes a focus point for class warfare, where municipal representatives for poor neighborhoods torpedo fiber build-out across the whole city.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by chimeracoder on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:43AM (#9127718)
> where municipal representatives for poor neighborhoods torpedo fiber build-out across the whole city.

But that's an issue for the city government to address internally, perhaps by means of negotiating a deal involving some other issue that those representatives also care about. That's how city government works.

This isn't exactly the only case in which neighbourhoods within a city or town have conflicting interests in local government[0]. I don't see yet why this one in particular should be special-cased (by allowing the FCC to bypass city/town governance).

[0] Arguably, that describes all of local government.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by rayiner on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:51AM (#9127755)
What deal could representatives make that fixes the problem? Someone has to pay to service those poor neighborhoods, and it'll be the ISP's shareholders only if they can make outrageous amounts of money on the remaining subscribers. Otherwise, the options are public money, or no fiber. Most cities are broke, so the former option is off the table, so in practice the result is no fiber for anyone.
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by nitrogen on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:46PM (#9128037)
If Internet access is an essential utility, and the city can't reach an agreement with ISPs, then the city itself should pay. This is what many cities are already doing, and the state laws prohibiting municipal networks are the issue addressed by the FCC.
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by tptacek on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:34AM (#9132253)
How are they supposed to pay for Internet buildout when they're running 8-9 figure deficits servicing 9-10 figure debt loads, watching their municipal bonds downgraded, and scrambling to figure out how to pay down defined-benefit pension plans to firefighters, police officers, and teachers?
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by nitrogen on Monday March 02, 2015 @11:42AM (#9132715)
Not all cities are in such a position. Fixing crushing debt is not an Internet problem, it's a governance problem.
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by tptacek on Monday March 02, 2015 @11:47AM (#9132763)
Name a major US city in a strong position to build out fiber Internet at their own expense and we can drill into the numbers.

Before I wrote, I pulled up the general fund numbers (debt load and deficit) for the 5 biggest US cities, and a couple random cities down around #15. I was going to write up a little table, but got pulled into a meeting.

This is one of those discussions where we have the benefit of actual numbers to work from. They're just a Google search away. If you're right, this should be an easy debate for you to win.

Slightly later

Figuring that the top 10 cities might put your argument at a disadvantage (it's harder to run a giant city than a smaller one and obviously more expensive to roll fiber out in one), I checked the next 10 cities on the list (by population). Quick observations:

* San Jose - huge deficits, pension crisis, closing police stations.

* Austin - like all the cities in Texas they seem to be doing OK.

* Indianapolis - 8 figure deficit, funding the city from reserves.

* Jacksonville - small deficit, service and pay cuts to keep the budget balanced.

* San Francisco - mid-high 8 figure deficits.

* Columbus - hard to find figures, probably doing OK.

* Charlotte - seems to be doing OK

* Fort Worth - Texas, seem to be doing OK

* Detroit - Heh

* El Paso - Texas, seems to be doing OK

* Memphis - 8 figure deficit, service cuts.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by nitrogen on Monday March 02, 2015 @10:24PM (#9135930)
It's interesting that the major cities in Texas are doing OK. Even for those that aren't doing OK, I'd propose that adding fiber rollout to the city's utility maintenance budget is the right thing to do in the absence of a better alternative.
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by extra88 on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:26PM (#9127946)
Now that there's Title II categorization, maybe it'll be addressed the way telephone roll-out was, was a "universal access" tax added to broadband bills to fund extending the infrastructure to less profitable areas.
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by woah on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:48PM (#9128048)
It's an extremely clumsy, circuitous political solution to a technical problem.
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by emmab on Monday March 02, 2015 @04:23AM (#9131040)
Why not just subsidize internet service to areas which are not receiving service?
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by tptacek on Monday March 02, 2015 @11:46AM (#9132747)
Because: expensive, no money to spend on it, and a suboptimal use of funds. It might be hard for high-income message board nerds like us to see this, but cities are straining to provide basic city services: making sure roads are drivable, clearing alleys and policing vacant lots and condemned apartment buildings, getting kids to school safely, keeping the heat on at those schools.

There is probably not in fact a huge demand for fiber Internet in North Lawndale or Fountain Park or Joyland.

That's actually part of Rayiner's argument. Build-out requirements are seized on by activists and politicians as chits, not because residents want fiber Internet (they won't get it regardless!), but as a political weapon to wield against rich neighborhoods whose residents want to pay premium rates for fiber Internet.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by vertex-four on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:28AM (#9127652)
> Right now, if you're an ISP startup and you identify some neighborhoods where it would make sense to build fiber, most cities won't let you. Instead, to build anywhere, you have to build everywhere.

Which is a good thing, because otherwise you wind up with communities which are further disadvantaged in access to information, education and work.

The solution is for the Government (federal, state, or municipal) to provide funding to build out into poor/remote areas (but still require it), not to throw your hands up and suggest that it is OK to exclude entire communities from what is quite possibly the most important technical development of the past couple of decades.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by rayiner on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:35AM (#9127687)
There is no free lunch. People in more expensive neighborhoods aren't willing to pay more just because the city requires build-out to poor neighborhoods. All build-out requirements do is make the economic case for building fiber even worse, and the end result is that nobody gets fiber.

The digital divide issue is much more cheaply solved by subsidizing wireless service for poor people. You don't need fiber to access Wikipedia, submit job applications, etc.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by vertex-four on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:50AM (#9127754)
> You don't need fiber to access Wikipedia, submit job applications, etc.

You do need a decent, reliable connection to access video-based educational materials (which form the bulk of many MOOCs), and more so to watch livestreamed conferences and tutorials. Do you plan to force mobile phone networks to provide virtually-unlimited bandwidth on top of supporting tethering when they're already struggling with physical bandwidth issues as it stands?

The rest of the developed world manages to provide high-speed (>50Mbps) Internet to at least almost the full population of their major cities (ignoring rural areas for now), with plenty of competition, so I don't really see why the US can't.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by rayiner on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:07PM (#9127836)
The bandwidth used by a whiteboard + audio stream is minimal. The government could easily pay market rates for the requisite wireless bandwidth.
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by vertex-four on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:19PM (#9127902)
> The bandwidth used by a whiteboard + audio stream is minimal.

Might be the case in theory, but I've yet to get a WebEx or Youtube live stream working reliably over 3G from my own home.

Paying market rates doesn't help when the infrastructure is already struggling to deal with current, unsubsidised load. 3G/4G based Internet is a dead end in reality, barring huge technical leaps.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by rayiner on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:48PM (#9128051)
Existing 4G networks are plenty fast for educational streaming, and the additional load from a few subsidized users watching MOOCs isn't going to break the bank. Take a place like downtown Wilmington, DE, the kind of city that would be a key target for such a program. On T-Mobile, I'd regularly get 8-15 mbps.

Your argument ignores a key demographic statistic: 80% of people below the poverty level already have cell phones, while under 60% have computers.[1] Given trends in PC-use, that disparity is going to increase, not decrease. Subsidizing cell phones is a much better fit for the social trends in poor communities.

[1] http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/terence-p-jeffrey/census....

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by chimeracoder on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:38AM (#9127701)
> People in more expensive neighborhoods aren't willing to pay more just because the city requires build-out to poor neighborhoods.

They may very well be in some cities/towns; this isn't fundamentally different from them paying more in taxes to subsidize other services that are used equally by all residents.

There's so much regional variability on this that it makes more sense for the FCC to allow cities and towns the right to determine this for themselves. If constituents are unhappy with the results, they can raise the issue at a town hall or with the city council, which is a far lower bar than trying to change FCC policy.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by rhino369 on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:06PM (#9127831)
The problem is they already have cable internet incumbents who can price below the new fiber with you make the fiber more expensive.

And the fiber companies know this and do the math.

This sort of subsidy for poor areas worked when there as a telephone monopoly. Well there isn't a monopoly anymore so you can't just make customer eat your price no matter what.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:32PM (#9127974)
It seems like a duopoly is about the worst possible market you can have. Monopolies basically have to be regulated (or government operated, or broken up), but at least monopolies have economics of scale and can justify research spending like Bell Labs. A duopoly doesn't give you any kind of vigorous competition but it still doubles all the fixed costs by requiring two networks to be built and maintained and then gives each provider a disincentive to invest in anything its competitor could benefit from.
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by leereeves on Sunday March 01, 2015 @11:37AM (#9127692)
> People in more expensive neighborhoods aren't willing to pay more

The government specializes in making people do things they "aren't willing to do".

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by venomsnake on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:30PM (#9127962)
> The digital divide issue is much more cheaply solved by subsidizing wireless service for poor people.

That is completely wrong. Wireless is completely useless in its current form. I burn through 4-5 TB of traffic per month. Nothing beats wire to the home.

Municipal owned last miles funded with property taxes is very nice way to redistribute some income, create work and provide ISPs with incentive to do their stuff. And ISPs just hook to them. I think that last miles connections should not be owned by other than the connected property's owner or society.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by rayiner on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:54PM (#9128072)
> Wireless is completely useless in its current form.

We're talking about subsidies to the poor to access the informational content of the internet. The vast majority of that is text or low-resolution video. I don't think it's a good use of public money to subsidize high-bandwidth games and entertainment.

> Municipal owned last miles funded with property taxes is very nice way to redistribute some income

Municipalities are already facing the prospect of having to hike property taxes to pay for existing obligations. Shit, e.g. Chicago won't even pay to replace all the lead pipes it put in decades ago which are leaching poison into peoples' drinking water! There's so many higher priorities that are underfunded before "multiple Netflix streams for everyone."

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by venomsnake on Sunday March 01, 2015 @01:38PM (#9128300)
> We're talking about subsidies to the poor to access the informational content of the internet. I don't think it's a good use of public money to subsidize high-bandwidth games and entertainment.

Have you seen the size of Visual Studio lately. Or photo shop. Or Linux installs. Or their ability to have a normal cloud backup.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by EpicEng on Sunday March 01, 2015 @04:32PM (#9128979)
So...it takes longer to download? Who is in such a rush to download an IDE that they will be significantly disadvantaged of they can't do it in under 15 minutes?
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by rayiner on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:00PM (#9128381)
Poor people can afford Visual Studio or Photoshop? Cloud backup for what, so they can access their data from home or work?
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by venomsnake on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:17PM (#9128459)
Both VS and Creative Suite have free/trial version. Cloud backup for not losing accumulated photos/videos and memories.

Of course a poor guy would have great use of all those online courses he will access trough wifi, if he cannot obtain the needed software.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by rayiner on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:38PM (#9128537)
VS Express 2010 is a 800 meg download. So 15-20 minute download on LTE, for something you'll use for months or years. Even 2013 is only a one-to-two hour download over LTE. It'd be far cheaper for the government to just pay for the LTE bandwidth for the small number of people who will avail themselves of these things than to build fiber out to everyone hoping a few will do so.
Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by vxNsr on Sunday March 01, 2015 @02:46PM (#9128559)
You're an edge case, even in my home which has 7+ users who stream and torrent we rarely hit 1tb.

(What I'm about to say is gonna be unpopular, but:)

Most importantly, there is no reason why the rich should subsidize the poor's porn and movie addiction. If you want those types of amenities make more money and make it lucrative for a company to bring you the services that they require.

Re:As Big as Net Neutrality? FCC Votes to Kill State Imposed... by guelo on Sunday March 01, 2015 @12:25PM (#9127939)
The title is accurate since the practical effect of the state laws is to preserve the existing ISP monopolies.