Before I wrote, I pulled up the general fund numbers (debt load and deficit) for the 5 biggest US cities, and a couple random cities down around #15. I was going to write up a little table, but got pulled into a meeting.
This is one of those discussions where we have the benefit of actual numbers to work from. They're just a Google search away. If you're right, this should be an easy debate for you to win.
Slightly later
Figuring that the top 10 cities might put your argument at a disadvantage (it's harder to run a giant city than a smaller one and obviously more expensive to roll fiber out in one), I checked the next 10 cities on the list (by population). Quick observations:
* San Jose - huge deficits, pension crisis, closing police stations.
* Austin - like all the cities in Texas they seem to be doing OK.
* Indianapolis - 8 figure deficit, funding the city from reserves.
* Jacksonville - small deficit, service and pay cuts to keep the budget balanced.
* San Francisco - mid-high 8 figure deficits.
* Columbus - hard to find figures, probably doing OK.
* Charlotte - seems to be doing OK
* Fort Worth - Texas, seem to be doing OK
* Detroit - Heh
* El Paso - Texas, seems to be doing OK
* Memphis - 8 figure deficit, service cuts.