EDIT:an "allow for 10 min" option would resolve this
XPrivacy does have the benefit of making it easy to provide realistic-looking fake data, which I believe the CyanogenMod team is against.
While I'm not exactly certain on how Privacy Guard works (I have yet to examine that code base), if a phone returns [] for a list of contacts and the application crashes...
In contrast, Android apps demand all of their permissions up front.
With Android, you grant an app access to everything it asks for, or you aren't allowed to install it. This seems obviously inferior to me.
Android's permission-granting model does leave much to be desired, though.
I value my privacy and the privacy of those I have information about on my device over some "feature" that "could be cool" but will almost certainly be exploited. http://news.yahoo.com/android-malware-only-pretends-turn-185...
Such as?
Intercepting calls before they go out through the main dialer, and instead using some form of VoIP.
Intercepting an incoming SMS that's used for phone number verification, rather than requiring that the user switch to their SMS app and manually enter a code.
For that matter, replacing the SMS app with something better.
Reasonable app backgrounding support for any purpose you can think of, not just for those that Apple has graciously allowed you to do.
Hell, you couldn't even have custom keyboards on iOS until recently.
Apps can also have access to stuff that iOS never allows: e.g. I have a 3rd-party app that backs up my SMS database to Google Drive every night. It can also do backups to Dropbox and a couple other services. With iOS your one and only cloud backup solution for "system related things" is iCloud, and you can't change that.
None of these things require rooting the device. Yes, all of these things can be abused. But I prefer permissiveness that requires a little vigilance on my part over living in a restricted environment.
I use Android because it let's me have defaults. See? Irrelevant statement.
Everyone has different needs, just drop it.
iOS does not require the user to accept all permissions that an app wishes to use, before installing that app. On iOS, you install an app without giving it permission to much, initially, and then the app, when you start it, starts asking for permissions that it needs, as it needs them. You can deny any permission request, and the app still works.
Eg. you can install the Facebook app, and deny it access to read your contact list.
In Android, about 150.
There is no mapping 1:1. Some things iOS does not allow at all (wifi information, sd card access). Some things iOS allows by default, with no way to deny it (internet access).
The iOS approach would not scale, the user would be burried under confirmation dialogs. And that's just the initial confirmation, there has to be UI, when he changes his mind later.
Those, who claim that iOS approach is superior are showing their ignorance, that they newer thought about the way, how the user would set matrix of this amount of permissions with many apps, without getting lost (hint: many are getting lost just in the current system. Imagine, that they would be able to toggle anything. And imagine, what the developers would say about that).
Then I opened the .apk. It asked me for what has to be every permission available on Android. Why would Amazon need access to me Contacts? It even asked specifically for permission to my microphone! What?
Why cannot the installed apps request the permissions they need individually?
Play gets around this by being bundled as a system app initially. And if you have a rooted device you can potentially promote the amazon store to the same status, and so forgo the "unknown sources" switch.
There's also an issue with "leaky abstractions" on android, where some useful features require extremely invasive permissions.
That said, if you want to create a separate profile for Uber or Line, you can already do so on Android 5.0 and above: https://support.google.com/nexus/answer/2865483?hl=en&ref_to...
I think Facebook Messenger, Line, and the like will still have access to all permissions even if you switch to a different user and install the apps there...
That being said, guest mode is really nice on my nexus 5 so my curious friends on iPhone can log in to their google account on my phone as a guest and test drive android.
Note, I have not looked deeply, so maybe it doesn't work like I said. I would not expect multitasking to be very seamless with this method. Also, I know there are some permissions that have "cross-user" abilities, so maybe there is still a way to accidentally allow an app to access your real data.
For example 2048 game has a lot of permission but being a game I don't allow a single one and it still works flawlessly. I would love to see something like this in android as well. But for now users are at the mercy of app developers.
App Ops: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=droidmate.appo...
Also, if your phone isn't rooted, is it really yours?
And, rooting doesn't help the majority of users. Whereas protection from spying would. But Google, perhaps accidentally, seems intent on making permissions less visible and has no problem with devs requesting every permission. And since so many major apps do this, users have no effective recourse.
MS and Apple got this one so much more right.
Almost every app requests too many permissions. Almost every app starts a background process to receive notifications. which are very bad.
Notifications are globally handled by the OS over a single dedicated optimized connection. And then dispatched to the individual applications.
Oh wow, can this be used to just create a separate profile for every app? That way I can run Uber or Line without giving them every permission to everything? This is the biggest reason I do not install apps. Every "famous" app requests so many permissions it's just stupid.
And not to mention the weirdness of some of them, like "WiFi Device Information". What's that mean? Access to my WiFi AP names? No thanks. Or just local multicast? Who knows.