Re:Excoin exchange's Bitcoins stolen, will be shutting down
by mlvljr on Sunday February 15, 2015 @03:57PM
(#9054086)
So what was stolen, exactly?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Excoin exchange's Bitcoins stolen, will be shutting down
by vertex-four on Sunday February 15, 2015 @04:42PM
(#9054243)
Somebody managed to trick the exchange into signing a message saying "move this amount of money from this address to this other address" (signed by the private key associated with the first address, with the second address being owned by the attacker) and submitting it to be added to the blockchain by a miner.
The blockchain is the only record of who owns what money, and transactions on it can't be reverted. Therefore, the attacker stole money by causing a transaction that shouldn't have happened.
Re:Excoin exchange's Bitcoins stolen, will be shutting down
by baddox on Monday February 16, 2015 @02:15PM
(#9058618)
Bitcoins were stolen, not a sequence of bits. It's not much different than if you steal USD from my electronic bank account. Bits are obviously involved in the process, but the USD in a bank account is not "just a sequence of bits." No physical property was stolen, but most of us can agree that this qualifies as theft.
Re:Excoin exchange's Bitcoins stolen, will be shutting down
by sp332 on Sunday February 15, 2015 @05:02PM
(#9054333)
This is more a case of fraud than burglary. The attackers tricked the exchange into sending then tons of money.
Re:Excoin exchange's Bitcoins stolen, will be shutting down
by baddox on Sunday February 15, 2015 @05:30PM
(#9054417)
Burglary traditional implies physical entry of a perpetrator into physical building or space. I assume it would not apply to "breaking into" a computer or network in most modern legal systems. Regardless, this would almost certainly be considered larceny, as well as computer fraud.