The challenge with F# is controlling memory usage. Even one extra allocation per packet can make a measureable difference in performance. I ended up doing a ton of unsafe code and manually managing most of the heap. Rust allows me to write fairly high-level code (not as expressive as F# yet but whatever) while getting "best" performance. Inline asm is a bonus, as there's some algorithms for integer compression that can use SIMD for big wins (I can do that in .NET, but it's ugly, and doing it safely means a ~30 instruction thunk). And sometimes in tight loops, I've found it difficult to get .NET to do acceptable codegen, causing double-digit% impacts.
There's also the safety issues writing unsafe code for network-exposed traffic. So Rust is actually more safe than .NET, because I have to toss .NET's safety to gain performance.
The backend management code I can continue to write in F#, and Rust's C-compatibility means it's trivial to interop the code. So I can do "orchestration" of indexing daemons and management APIs and such things in a higher-level language, then for actual indexing and whatnot, just jump over to Rust, seamlessly.
Finally the static compilation means a smoother installation experience for customers. And if I ever ship a closed-source module that executes on the client, I don't need to license Mono for static linking. So that's nice. And the safety guarantees are good, because similar, existing, software in C has put customers at risk before. (I'm not sure if I can effectively market that last part, but hey.)
Rust would appear to have a unique value proposition and I'm very pleased to see it progressing so damn well.
The alternatives you listed aren't known for being able to write top-performance idiomatic code (I've got something _working_ in F#, but it's ugly non-idiotmatic code). The overhead of a GC is just too much to pay when doing linerate networking. Rust allows me to keep nice, high-level, idiomatic style, without paying any overhead. I can account for almost every byte.
I've been building a 3d game with Rust and OpenGL, ported from a C++ codebase. So far, my experience has been very positive. Despite Rust's supposed immaturity, it feels more polished than C++ in many ways. Forward progress has been much faster than it was with C++.
Does anyone else have a story (positive or negative) about using Rust in real projects?