Re:This Uncanny Valley of Voice Recognition
by modeless on Monday February 09, 2015 @04:05PM
(#9023723)
Of course nobody prefers less accurate transcription, but we're talking about more than transcription here. It's entirely reasonable to prefer a "command line" style interface like the XBox over a "conversational" style interface like Siri for the reason that the "conversational" style interface is less reliable even though it's in some sense more "real".
Re:This Uncanny Valley of Voice Recognition
by amelius on Monday February 09, 2015 @03:55PM
(#9023646)
> The uncanny valley is a hypothesis in the field of aesthetics which holds that when features look and move almost, but not exactly, like natural beings, it causes a response of revulsion among some observers. The "valley" refers to the dip in a graph of the comfort level of beings as subjects move toward a healthy, natural likeness described in a function of a subject's aesthetic acceptability.
Wording by wikipedia. So apparently, there might be points on the graph where a slight increase in recognition performance actually freaks out some users.
Re:This Uncanny Valley of Voice Recognition
by matthew-wegner on Monday February 09, 2015 @05:54PM
(#9024377)
I think there is a real danger that people are modifying/learning how to speak to computer voice recognition software. If voice recognition can't quickly become able to parse natural language, it will inevitably have to parse "I'm talking a dumb computer" cadence and inflection instead.
Incremental improvements are very bad in this regard.
These things are hard to reverse, too (people still speak with a very distinct "I'm speaking on a telephone" cadence today).
Re:This Uncanny Valley of Voice Recognition
by woodson on Monday February 09, 2015 @06:44PM
(#9024558)
IMHO, people (and hence language) will always adapt in certain ways to get the message across. People already learned how to "google" and expect the same style of search queries to be effective elsewhere. When speaking on the telephone, people tend to slightly change their voice to counteract the channel noise (with acoustic consequences such as increased fundamental frequency ["pitch"], etc.).
I would be surprised if a similar adaptation didn't happen for human-computer voice interaction, which would ultimately help making it work well enough to be useful. (Of course, using speech recognition to transcribe human-to-human interaction will still be barely usable..)
Re:This Uncanny Valley of Voice Recognition
by jimmaswell on Monday February 09, 2015 @11:21PM
(#9025360)
In text adventures there was a limited grammar that the parser understood that was English-like, which you had to express your actions in: get lamp, put lamp on table, eat fish, look sword. This is easier than if the parser tried to let you use fancy English sentences that it'd probably get wrong often and that you would make more mistakes in because the line is blurred between what you're allowed to say or not. That would be a point between the simplistic text adventure grammar and perfect natural language parsing, with the simpler grammar being preferable. I can see the same being true for voice commands.
Re:This Uncanny Valley of Voice Recognition
by lsaferite on Tuesday February 10, 2015 @09:13AM
(#9027153)
As a side note, it might be funny to hook one of these voice command systems up to a z-machine VM. The command set is very limited as you pointed out, so it should easily be able to handle the input side. And the voices, while still robotic, seem pretty good as well. With games like Zork being fully text based you could easily turn it into a conversational game.
Right now, every incremental improvement to voice recognition improves its usefulness. It might appear that we're in an uncanny valley because voice recognition is barely usable right now versus completely unusable in the past, but there is no one that prefers worst voice recognition over better voice recognition.