The ten patents in suit relate to technologies fundamental to making devices which are compatible with one or more of the GSM, UMTS (3G WCDMA) and wireless LAN standards. The patents cover wireless data, speech coding, security and encryption and are infringed by all Apple iPhone models shipped since the iPhone was introduced in 2007.
--
So these are likely to be more hardware related. That doesn't make the claims any more valid, but I don't think that these will have many (any?) software claims.
It is, pardon the pun, patent nonsense.
Software patents are just a tool to extort, not an incentive to innovate.
This is not like Nokia went and patented something that was already existing in the market and is trolling. They poured their own money into it, so why would they let a competitor, esp. a very succesful competitor use their tech for free???
The patents listed all contain stuff that seems to be pretty obvious when it comes to mobile communications.
Yes, you need encryption, thousands of manyears of work not done at Nokia preceded that. Yes, you will need GSM, which is unfortunately patent encumbered, but since there is no other option that makes any patents on that tech a simple matter of extortion.
WiFi ? How else will you connect to a lan from a mobile phone ?
Etc. If this is Nokias best shot at showing how they're going to 'compete' with Apple then they've just told us they don't think they can. What a total waste of a reputation.
It reminds me of the GIF patent.
I spent 40B euros figuring out how to and and digging a well to get water to my parched village. I add a bucket, but the water is still kind of muddy. I'm the only well, though, so I do well enough.
Then someone comes along and digs a well a couple hundred feet away, adds a pumping system (so they can sell more water) and a filtration system (so the water is cleaner). Nobody wants my water anymore. So I'm about to go broke.
So of course, instead of making a better pumping and filtration system, I sue the guy making the better well. At least, that's Nokia's position.
In your analogy, you seem to be skipping the issue of patents entirely. Note that Apple did not go out and "dig it's own well" by developing something completely unrelated to GSM, UTMS, Wi-Fi, etc. Whether Nokia's claim turns out to be valid aside, it's undeniable that Apple is using the technology that Nokia is making the claim on. That is to say, they aren't suing over Apple developing "the better well", they're suing Apple for using their well without compensation.
The point is that they could not have because that would be inoperable.
I'm sure my one-man-boycott isn't going to impress anybody but that's the sweep your own street argument working for you.
It's a variation on the 'if one percent fallacy', 'if everybody does it then it will make a difference'. And I'm sure that not everybody - or even a small percentage - will do this, after all the only time when it will make Nokia recant is if the loss in sales outweighs their potential gain in this suit.
But that doesn't matter to me. Point of principle. You do software patents, I might buy your stuff. You sue using software patents (and there seems to be some confusion about that, the non-software issues are dead obvious, the software issues should never have been granted or should have become common property the second Nokia started pushing for those things to be accepted as standards).
Nokia was one of the parties pushing hardest to allow software patents in the EU:
Have you seen some facts that this would be about software patents? I would guess it is a mixture of hardware and software, from the press release:
"The ten patents in suit relate to technologies fundamental to making devices which are compatible with one or more of the GSM, UMTS (3G WCDMA) and wireless LAN standards. The patents cover wireless data, speech coding, security and encryption..."
And do you really think that 40 BILLION (not million) is required to implement GSM, UMTS and wireless lan ?
That's just handwaving to convince the gullible that this is a case where nokia has the moral highground.
All of this stuff is about interoperability in the first place, patents really should have no role to play there.
Did some Standard-Bearing Moses come down from the mountain carrying three stone tablets on which the fully-formed GSM, UMTS and WLAN specifications were inscribed?
Of course not. These standards were derived from inventions by Nokia, Ericsson, Qualcomm and many others; inventions that indeed did cost billions to develop.
Sure, inventing stuff costs money, but handset manufacturers all benefit from those inventions by being able to charge for them.
As for the history of GSM:
"In 1982, the European Conference of Postal and Telecommunications Administrations (CEPT) created the Groupe Spécial Mobile (GSM) to develop a standard for a mobile telephone system that could be used across Europe.[6] In 1987, a memorandum of understanding was signed by 13 countries to develop a common cellular telephone system across Europe.[7][8] Finally the system created by SINTEF lead by Torleiv Maseng was selected.[9]"
The rest of that stuff: communications methods and associated bits & pieces should simply not be patentable, especially not if they consist of pieces of software.
By your reasoning every TCP protocol stack component should have been patented because it cost 'billions to develop'.
Unless you don't but Apple either, which makes sense.
So personally, I don't blame companies for patenting. I do blame companies that sue.
But the system needs fixing.
With the rules setup how they currently are, it'd be irresponsible for a company such as Apple not to patent things incase they get sued.
I'd rather see that changed so that no one can get silly all-encompassing general patents, and certainly not software or UI patents.
Dear Nokia,
For more than a decade I've been a loyal user of your products, pretty much every year or so I would upgrade my phone to your latest model.
Today that comes to an end.
My reason is that I think that companies should compete on quality and price, not to use software patents as a means of stifling competition.
Software Patents were a mistake when they were granted to begin with, to see the proud company that Nokia once was stoop to the use of the dirtiest weapons in business is really sad.
I realize that my voice hardly counts in issues like this, but I figured that by letting you know, you are aware that there is another price attached to this lawsuit.
best regards,