News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nokia sues Apple for infringement of multiple patents by warfangle on Thursday October 22, 2009 @01:11PM (#897126)
Your analogy is flawed. It would be more like:

I spent 40B euros figuring out how to and and digging a well to get water to my parched village. I add a bucket, but the water is still kind of muddy. I'm the only well, though, so I do well enough.

Then someone comes along and digs a well a couple hundred feet away, adds a pumping system (so they can sell more water) and a filtration system (so the water is cleaner). Nobody wants my water anymore. So I'm about to go broke.

So of course, instead of making a better pumping and filtration system, I sue the guy making the better well. At least, that's Nokia's position.

Re:Nokia sues Apple for infringement of multiple patents by GHFigs on Thursday October 22, 2009 @06:53PM (#897884)
In the above post, the well represents the patented technology. He creates the technology (digs the well) and patents it (seeks to profit from it by monopolizing it's use).

In your analogy, you seem to be skipping the issue of patents entirely. Note that Apple did not go out and "dig it's own well" by developing something completely unrelated to GSM, UTMS, Wi-Fi, etc. Whether Nokia's claim turns out to be valid aside, it's undeniable that Apple is using the technology that Nokia is making the claim on. That is to say, they aren't suing over Apple developing "the better well", they're suing Apple for using their well without compensation.

Re:Nokia sues Apple for infringement of multiple patents by jacquesm on Thursday October 22, 2009 @08:25PM (#898006)
> developing something completely unrelated to GSM, UTMS, Wi-Fi, etc.

The point is that they could not have because that would be inoperable.

Re:Nokia sues Apple for infringement of multiple patents by GHFigs on Friday October 23, 2009 @12:12PM (#899025)
Interoperability with GSM-based networks is not a God-given right.