News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do you want to work at Twitter? - Twitter Development Talk by cookiecaper on Thursday October 22, 2009 @07:20AM (#896511)
I don't think it's that Twitter is utterly irredeemable in value; there are a few valuable uses for it, imo. I think it's mostly that the way the public regards and deploys Twitter is incredibly obnoxious.

Twitter is ascribed far more value and relevance than it deserves. Seriously, valuations in the hundreds of millions just because CNN thought they could foresee the "next Facebook" and tout the product incessantly? Twitter has not devised any system of profitability and to do so seems a very difficult task indeed.

To me, Twitter is annoying because it represents a desperate, clinging ignorance on the part of its proponents. The value Twitter actually provides, which is basically broadcasting SMS messages across various formats and aggregating popular discussion topics, is so miniscule compared to its assigned preeminence. This gives off the impression that Twitter's major proponents are impostors.

And I think that's true. I think that Twitter has come so far because the executives at several media companies beheld Facebook, Myspace, and others, and were determined to get ahead of the "next big thing", so that they could exploit the platform as it took off instead of buying up a fad all too late (News Corp buying MySpace). Twitter had cel-shading, big letters, coordinated colors, and a Mac-esque chic about it, there may have been consultants involved, but for whatever reason, these ignorant, angry old media executives ordained Twitter as the instrument-of-choice in their hypercharged desperation to remain relevant and profit off of the internet.

The promoters of old media's franchises have likewise endorsed the platform, and I'm sure the first thing every celebrity agent instructs is a Twitter account. The agents are probably the ones updating it, too.

So, to many of us, it feels "unclean", as it were. The utility obviously doesn't match the praise and promotion that it gets. It's a platform flooded with wannabes and fraudsters.

It's a darling of media pundits, which we find asinine not only because it's so undeserving as a consumer service, but also because it's so undeserving as a business; Twitter generates no profit now and I've not yet met a proposal for profitability that makes sense. Hacker News is filled with businesspeople who work hard on businesses with tangible profit opportunity, and I'm sure many of us are annoyed to see so unworthy a competitor get the glory as we toil away on useful but unrecognized products.

That's my opinion anyway. I really don't like Twitter because of this; perhaps that's unfair in itself because Twitter isn't really responsible for the actions of its external disciples. It's not a jealousy per se, as I don't hold [much] contempt for Twitter's employees or founders directly, but it is an annoyance at the insensibility of the world we live in.

tl;dr Twitter has some utility but mostly it represents old media's desperation to exploit a space that they refuse to understand.

Re:Do you want to work at Twitter? - Twitter Development Talk by marknutter on Thursday October 22, 2009 @08:51AM (#896610)
How did I know that underneath that terse damnation of Twitter was bubbling a stormy and long-winded sea of contempt?

I'll spare you the equally long winded rebuttal with my very simple observation about Twitter: it has brought RSS to the masses; a concept that was very useful to tech-savvy people but very nebulous and confusing to non-tech-savvy people.

That, and you should try http://search.twitter.com sometime. I assume that you haven't because I somehow doubt you'd hate Twitter so much had you.

Re:Do you want to work at Twitter? - Twitter Development Talk by cookiecaper on Thursday October 22, 2009 @09:46AM (#896695)
Facebook is what really brought the concept of aggregation to the masses; it's essentially an aggregator of your friends' lives.
Re:Do you want to work at Twitter? - Twitter Development Talk by marknutter on Thursday October 22, 2009 @09:56AM (#896723)
I'll agree with that, but I would say Twitter is the better example being that it's much more open than Facebook (no friend requests required).
Re:Do you want to work at Twitter? - Twitter Development Talk by elblanco on Thursday October 22, 2009 @03:36PM (#897488)
If only there was some technology....that would....aggregate the blogs and news sites I'm interested in....and display it...perhaps in a reader like format....using some kind of standardized syndication service that's easy peasy to setup....and then, when I see something I like....it has enough content in it to be useful....

sigh

Perhaps Google will figure it out someday.

Re:Do you want to work at Twitter? - Twitter Development Talk by marknutter on Thursday October 22, 2009 @10:25PM (#898151)
Ask your mom if she knows what RSS is. Then ask her if she's heard of Twitter.