News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by quaunaut on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:24AM (#8960276)
I still find the supposition that Facebook was supposed to defy a court order hilarious. Yes, I understand it's a court order from Turkey, not America, but you can't just flagrantly break the law in other countries simply because yours believes differently.

Or put another way: As much as Americans like to act like it, we can't enforce our ideals around the world without significant investment that I don't think anyone wants us making after the last couple of times.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by panarky on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:00AM (#8960535)
In the worst case, Turkey could ban Facebook. Would they really do that? It's nowhere near certain.

Google left China rather than submit to their censorship regime, and the Chinese market is like 18 Turkeys.

And if you do remove content, you can make that action transparent on Chilling Effects[1]. Facebook doesn't do that, either.

There are alternatives.

And if you decide to build censorship tools to stay in the good graces of the regime, then don't say "I am Charlie" while you're doing it.

[1] https://www.chillingeffects.org/

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by maged on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:10AM (#8960623)
> censorship

China wanted to censor inconvenient history. Turkey wants to censor offensive (to them) religious images. I think that's the important comparison, not the size of the market.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by mercurial on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:33AM (#8960796)
The Turkish legal code has a clause against "insulting Turkishness", which has been used to censor mentions of the Armenian genocide, so they're clearly not against history-related censorship.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by sp332 on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:29AM (#8960780)
I doubt that's really the worst case, although it is pretty bad since Facebook is very popular in Turkey. I think being fined heavily would be worse. For example, Yahoo was threatened by the US government with $250,000 fine per day if it did not comply with demands to turn over data.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by panarky on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:36AM (#8960825)
> Facebook is very popular in Turkey

This means Facebook has a lot of power to resist censorship.

Make repression costly for the regime in terms of widespread public outrage and international pariah status.

Maybe Erdoğan will pay those costs, maybe he won't.

But if you make censorship free then you're certain to get a lot more of it.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by quaunaut on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:45AM (#8960887)
I'd be a fan of them doing more for sure(especially the Chilling Effects site addition). But many here are ignoring any possibility of compliance while filing objection, which this is exactly.

If this were used instead as an opportunity to get Facebook to make censorship moves like this more transparent, I'd be in full support.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by isaacremuant on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:10AM (#8960622)
Most countries, including USA, have "censhorship regimes". They just vary in scope and targeting.

Many companies could decide not to operate in USA due to the snooping, gagged court orders, civil rights attacks, selective and repressive law enforcement, etc.

I get this is a hard issue to speak in "western" sites because many see it as "us vs them" but let me tell you, I could easily subdivide "us" many times and make your portion "them".

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by vixen99 on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:16AM (#8960675)
Which characters' images from history are censored in the West?
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by isaacremuant on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @06:03PM (#8963121)
I don't know.

You're ignoring all my other examples of censorship, though.

I knew it was going to be a hard issue so the downvotes are not unexpected.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by innguest on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @12:22PM (#8961129)
It happens all the time with a lot of characters. Most recently, criticism of Chris Kyle (the real life sniper/camper/coward) has been censored on Youtube for offending the sensibilities of pro-war, pro-violence folks.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by panarky on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @12:32PM (#8961198)
Citation please.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by innguest on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @12:42PM (#8961252)
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by panarky on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @01:17PM (#8961492)
This guy's video titled "Chris Kyle was a pussy" is not censored on YouTube.

Maybe it got flagged off temporarily by his adversaries, but it's fully available now.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Iypq11_n2I

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by hnnewguy on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:34AM (#8960351)
>I still find the supposition that Facebook was supposed to defy a court order hilarious.

For me at least: it's the idea of making a public pronouncement that you support some political view (because that's easy). Then you do something that, at least on the face of it, goes against that position when there could be business repercussions (because that's hard).

Why not just keep your mouth shut?

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by quaunaut on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:34AM (#8960811)
Because this is the real world, and no matter what the internet tells you, nuance matters. I don't like Mark Zuckerberg. I think his business practices regularly register as complete bullshit, and furthermore I can't quite tell what the hell they spend their time doing because since about 2009 Facebook has consistently become more and more of something I don't want anything to do with.

But there is not one bit of me that doesn't believe Mark really does support free speech everywhere. He didn't have to say that, but he did. He made that effort, even though he knew it opened his flank. And of course he knew that, because he's not a complete idiot.

This is the real world. Where while complying with the law, you protest it, because that's how you act in a civilized society.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by hnnewguy on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @12:54PM (#8961335)
>Where while complying with the law, you protest it, because that's how you act in a civilized society.

Lots of talk in your comment about the "real world", without a hint of irony that our "civilized society" only exists in its current form thanks to revolutions and wars.

The idea that protests should only occur within the confines of the law tells me you have a bit to learn about the "real world".

>He made that effort

I know the Facebook crowd might think so, but saying "Je Suis Charlie" takes effort?

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by cryoshon on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:43AM (#8960871)
Compliance with protest equals compliance and a certainty that you will keep complying and eventually grow tired of protesting.

"How you act in a civilized society" leads to normalization and eventual acceptance of problems caused by compliance.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by quaunaut on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:49AM (#8960914)
I just don't see how in the face of 2014's continuation of the Civil Rights movement you can say something like that with a straight face.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by LLWM on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:59AM (#8960972)
They're only "problems" to you because you disagree with the legitimate democratically elected government of another country.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by blueskin_ on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:06AM (#8960580)
> I still find the supposition that Facebook was supposed to defy a court order hilarious. Yes, I understand it's a court order from Turkey, not America, but you can't just flagrantly break the law in other countries simply because yours believes differently.

Does Facebook have any offices, servers or employees in Turkey? If not, they aren't required to do a thing. Even if they did, they just don't store that content on those servers (and maybe compartmentalise dealing with such data away from any employees based there) and they're fine. If that wasn't the case, then any random tinpot dictatorship (such as turkey) could make arbitrary things illegal for anyone in the world, and expect compliance from every single person in the world.

I'm sure turkey would want anyone in the world they could force to be to be brought under sharia law too, not just facebook. Does that mean we should even if we don't live there and don't visit? I for one, don't think so.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by user_0001 on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:29AM (#8960778)
>I'm sure turkey would want anyone in the world they could force to be to be brought under sharia law too, not just facebook

lol, what are you talking about? I suggest you remove your head from your arse and read a bit more about Turkey

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by blueskin_ on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:31AM (#8960784)
Majority muslim nation, cult of personality, widespread corruption, oppressive government, evidence of rigged elections, suppression of free speech. Seems clear-cut to me.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by LLWM on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @12:02PM (#8960988)
None of that is sharia. In fact, there's a huge contraindication which you conveniently left out - a constitutionally mandated secular government.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by blueskin_ on Thursday January 29, 2015 @03:05AM (#8964903)
That's as much of a token gesture/joke as Pol Pot's Cambodia calling itself 'Democratic', or the first amendment in the US.

Argentina's constitution says they own the Falkland Islands, yet they don't either. The US constitution guarantees freedom of speech, protection from unlawful searches and surveillance, probable cause for any search, and separation of church and state, yet the actual reality is almost the direct opposite of all of those.

As such, Turkey going "hey, look, we're secular" is worthless when they act like a psychotic dictatorship.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by LLWM on Thursday January 29, 2015 @08:15AM (#8965872)
If your claims about the US are any clue, I don't think there's any reason to trust the accuracy of your knowledge of Turkey either.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by user_0001 on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:55AM (#8960951)
<rolleyes>
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by chc on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:17AM (#8960683)
Really? I would imagine that just serving the content to Turkish visitors would be enough for Turkey to see it as violating the law and put any servers or employees there at risk.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by FroshKiller on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:41AM (#8960390)
That is a silly comment. Of course you can and often should break laws you don't agree with, even when you're an individual versus a nation. Or would you be fine complying with sharia because some backwater on the other side of the globe said so?
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by g8oz on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:01AM (#8960539)
They are only complying within Turkey right? The consequence of not complying with local laws you disagree with is being shut out of many countries and not being a global brand.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by panarky on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:41AM (#8960851)
Maybe standing up for universal values would strengthen a global brand that's built on communication.

YouTube and Twitter refused to take down material in Turkey, and they were both banned for two months.

If anything, their principles enhanced their brands in Turkey and around the world.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by ivraatiems on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:50AM (#8960457)
Would you be fine with being imprisoned/executed for refusing to comply while residing in said backwater?

It's not that complying with the law would be noble or right, but it's not really reasonable to expect everyone in a country to be a martyr.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by FroshKiller on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:55AM (#8960493)
Yes? I feel like you are missing the point. The Friendship Nine broke a law they disagreed with where they lived, they were in the right, and their convictions are finally about to be overturned more than 50 years later. Do you think they shouldn't have broken a stupid law?
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by ivraatiems on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @12:33PM (#8961207)
That's apples to oranges to sharia law.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by FroshKiller on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @12:50PM (#8961309)
I disagree, and I'm obviously not going to change your mind, so I'd prefer not to argue any further if that's all right with you.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by isaacremuant on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:13AM (#8960647)
It all comes down to jurisdiction. If jurisdiction can be enforced then you can't really break a law without facing the consequences.

If I disagree with the TSA and decide to go through without caring about their scans they're going to detain me. It doesn't matter if I "shouldn't do it".

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by jessaustin on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:37AM (#8960362)
...without significant investment that I don't think anyone wants us making after the last couple of times.

A service choosing not to censor, and then potentially being censored in turn by ISPs in another nation, could be costly, sure. It wouldn't seem to be in the same ballpark as a military invasion of another nation? (Honestly though, when has a USA military invasion ever actually been about enforcing ideals?)

When this issue was discussed yesterday, I pointed out that it's not Zuck's actions that surprise us, because money. Rather, we're surprised by what he says while taking those actions. It's incongruous to appropriate the rhetoric of freedom while happily making money undermining freedom.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by roc on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:49AM (#8960450)
Once you've accepted the conceit that Facebook will say and do whatever has the best return, it's hardly incongruous for Facebook to hitch a ride on a free, positive PR train.

The only incongruity is on the part of people who believed Zuck when they have plenty of data that they shouldn't.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by davorb on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:12AM (#8960640)
Zuck: Yeah so if you ever need info about anyone at Harvard

Zuck: Just ask

Zuck: I have over 4,000 emails, pictures, addresses, SNS

[Redacted Friend's Name]: What? How'd you manage that one?

Zuck: People just submitted it.

Zuck: I don't know why.

Zuck: They "trust me"

Zuck: Dumb fucks

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by dreamweapon on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @01:13PM (#8961470)
I still find the supposition that Facebook was supposed to defy a court order hilarious. Yes, I understand it's a court order from Turkey, not America, but you can't just flagrantly break the law in other countries simply because yours believes differently.

I think you're missing a major point: unless FB has something like a CDN physically located inside of Turkey -- or has some other corporate presence there -- then it is under no legal obligation to comply with its laws (or court orders) whatsoever. The reality is that FB is complying with the Turkish government's requests for no other reason than that it chooses to, because it considers the (perceived) business advantages to be more important than the social and human costs of doing so.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by kyllo on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:07AM (#8960590)
It's not so crazy; imagine you're running a business that operates in both the US and an Arab League nation such as Lebanon.

The laws of Lebanon require you to observe a boycott of any products and services that originate in or transit through Israel. Meanwhile the laws of the US forbid you from observing the Arab Boycott of Israel. What do you do?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_League_boycott_of_Israel

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by richardwhiuk on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:29AM (#8960774)
Detect where the traffic comes from and apply the law thusly?
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by kyllo on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @08:59PM (#8963893)
Unfortunately in this case, that won't work if you're a US corporation because the law applies to US corporations globally, regardless of what country the actual operations take place in. So the US law requires that you disobey the foreign law even in the foreign country.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by jsprogrammer on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:28AM (#8960299)
Does Facebook have a physical presence in Turkey?
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by gtirloni on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:27AM (#8960757)
They have a .tr domain but I doubt they incorporated there.

   Facebook Inc.
   Buyukdere Cad. Maya Akar Center No:100-102
   B Blok K:18 Esentepe
   Istanbul, Turkey
   [email protected]
   +90-212-2726364
   +90-212-2726365
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by 100timesthis on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:40AM (#8960387)
it seems they don't have offices in Turkey[1]

[1] https://www.facebook.com/careers#locations

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by JoshTriplett on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @12:53PM (#8961327)
> Yes, I understand it's a court order from Turkey, not America, but you can't just flagrantly break the law in other countries simply because yours believes differently.

Yes, you absolutely can. Jurisdiction: As long as you're following the laws of your own country, and you don't plan to live in, visit, or do business in some other country, you have no obligation whatsoever to respect that country's laws.

In this case, it sounds like Facebook cares about doing business in Turkey (specifically, continuing to reach the citizens of Turkey).

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by uptown on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:28AM (#8960767)
"you can't just flagrantly break the law in other countries simply because yours believes differently."

Isn't that Uber's basic approach?

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by quaunaut on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:36AM (#8960819)
I personally don't have very much faith in Uber's long term business prospects, but that's all for its own discussion. But this is just one of many reasons I do think that way.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by Zigurd on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:53AM (#8960481)
That depends on whether Facebook has significant operations in Turkey. It's not Facebook's job to deny residents of Turkey access to Facebook, or parts of Facebook. It's the Turkish government's job to balkanize the Internet, with all the bad side effects on the tech industry in Turkey, if that is their desire.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by wahsd on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @10:57AM (#8960518)
What are you talking about, we love forcing our ideals down other's throats, because it's always easier to criticize and tear down others than to look at the pile of shit behind us.
Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by santacluster on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:21AM (#8960707)
I find this argument hilarious, especially in this context.

> you can't just flagrantly break the law in other countries simply because yours believes differently

Facebook, and many American tech companies like it, have no problem breaking the law in other countries when it suits their bottom line. Primary battlefield: privacy rights.

> As much as Americans like to act like it, we can't enforce our ideals around the world

Facebook, and many American tech companies like it, enforce their puritan values around the world by fanatically censoring all kinds of harmless content (mostly, "boobies") on their services.

These companies are clearly willing and able to make both commercial and ideological choices with complete disregard for local laws and values.

Re:Facebook begins censoring images of prophet Muhammad by quaunaut on Wednesday January 28, 2015 @11:41AM (#8960855)
What country's privacy laws are being broken again? Because I've not heard of it.

And your argument about enforcing their values around the world is enforcing THEIR values, not American ones. Yes, their values are influenced by their being American no doubt, but it's facetiously cynical to imply the two are related in any way, shape, or form.