News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by CardenB on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @11:52AM (#8923904)
Call me stubborn, but I just can't see going back to windows after switching to os x. People complain about bugs a lot lately, but I haven't experienced any. Windows just feels like an uphill battle to do everything I want to these days. I feel like a start button and multiple workspaces won't really change that.

However, I'm all for new tech so I want there to be room for everyone. I'm excited to see the future of windows.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by sz4kerto on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:11PM (#8924037)
I really wanted to love OSX, but never could. I run Linux + Windows on my Macbook Pro -- Linux is a better and more open *nix, and Windows is just way faster and more stable in general than anything else (at least that's my experience), especially when it comes to anything graphics intensive (graphics drivers are really-really bad on OSX). Obviously web devs see it in a different way, and I can understand that. But if you know Powershell well, then Windows can be quite convenient. For development my choice is either Windows + VS or Linux + whatever. OSX is a nice middle ground though, it's just not for me.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by wvenable on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:25PM (#8924544)
I feel the same way actually, but I realize that my opinion on this isn't mainstream. Using OS X has always been an exercise in frustration for me. Outside of the "real" shell the entire UI doesn't seem to be designed for software professionals.

Ironically, the more that Windows tries to be like OS X the less I like it. Thankfully, it's still possible to turn much of that stuff off.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by moogleii on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:16PM (#8924952)
I don't really feel like Metro is going towards OS X at all, they seem to be strongly going their own way.

>Outside of the "real" shell the entire UI doesn't seem to be designed for software professionals

Interesting, any specific examples? I'm genuinely curious. For me, the more I use OSX, the more I'm frustrated with Windows. The one thing I do miss from Windows is better full screen support. Yosemite kinda helped with that (but it's still kinda clunky).

Other than that, I feel like there's a little more logic behind OSX with common operations, off the top of my head:

Option/alt to modify existing commands. The keyboard kungfu on OSX seems easier on the hands, too, since the combos typically rely on thumb keys vs a Windows pinky reach of Ctrl. Especially noticeable because the thumbs seem pretty underutilized vs pinkies, which already have plenty of keyboard duties.

File renaming: "Enter" to rename a file vs "F2" (something I happily accepted as random dogma, but now it's "??")

Folder/file nav: unified drill down in the file browser (cmd+up/down to navigate levels, with the file level simply opening the file, vs arrow keys, then enter to open)

Window management: being able to close all windows without exiting the app itself (handy when I'm clearing clutter but I don't want to pay a cost for restarting a big application, or if I simply just didn't realize it was the last window when I closed it, and now I have to relaunch the application)

*Scrolling: Being able to scroll any window whether or not it's the active application, so long as the mouse cursor is hovering over content.

Not to say everything is more logical, just common things I do. The screen capture shortcut is totally bizarre to me, I have to google it every time.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by wvenable on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @06:56PM (#8926634)
> don't really feel like Metro is going towards OS X at all, they seem to be strongly going their own way.

I actually meant the desktop parts, no metro. For example, the taskbar is becoming more dock-like in every release.

> Interesting, any specific examples? I'm genuinely curious.

It's somewhat hard to nail down. I find it much more mouse heavy. I find the window management to be annoying; I prefer full-screen apps with dockable panels to the mess of random windows normally found in OS X apps. I definitely feel having one menu bar WAY at the top of a single screen to be insane. I'm sitting in front of 2 24" monitors kinda makes OS X seem a bit underwhelming. On Windows, I have two task bars showing different tasks for each window. Two start menus (thanks Classicshell) and my apps have their own menus.

It seems like the apps have a lot of style-over-substance going on. Code editors with pop-out drawers which are both stupid and a waste of pixels.

> File renaming: "Enter" to rename a file vs "F2" (something I happily accepted as random dogma, but now it's "??")

F2 works but I never use it. I always just click twice to rename.

> Window management: being able to close all windows without exiting the app itself (handy when I'm clearing clutter but I don't want to pay a cost for restarting a big application, or if I simply just didn't realize it was the last window when I closed it, and now I have to relaunch the application)

Most Windows applications are MDI or tabbed so this seems like less of issue. Even a lot of OS X apps are tabbed. I actually hate what you like: nothing but the menu bar open indicating that the app is in focus and running. I've been confused by that a few times.

> Scrolling: Being able to scroll any window whether or not it's the active application, so long as the mouse cursor is hovering over content.

Yeah, you got me there. For the longest time, OS X was missing some really obvious stuff though. Like resizing windows from any corner! I found nothing more annoying than having to move a window around to then resize it.

> Not to say everything is more logical, just common things I do. The screen capture shortcut is totally bizarre to me, I have to google it every time.

SHIFT-PRNTSCN? It's got a labeled key on the keyboard!

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by moogleii on Thursday January 22, 2015 @11:04AM (#8929830)
Ha, looks like my opinions hurt someone's feelings and got downvoted. Meh.

>SHIFT-PRNTSCN? It's got a labeled key on the keyboard!

Right. I meant it was less logical on OSX. Cmd-shift-3? Bizarre. And yeah, I had to google it again. http://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201361

>I actually hate what you like: nothing but the menu bar open indicating that the app is in focus and running. I've been confused by that a few times.

Haha, I'm glad we can civilly hate each other's preferences. To me, repeating the menu strip for each window is a waste of real-estate, but i'm a huge desktop space whore. I don't need "File, Edit, etc" on every program window. I know it's there, so I prefer it to be in a common area. Actually, I find myself getting confused the other way around. In Windows, if I step away from my desk, and come back, it's not clear to me which program is currently active because they're all showing their menu bars just like all the other programs (now that we discuss it, I feel like the root of our different workflows has as lot to do with the fact that I prefer to autohide my taskbars). This combined with the unified window/program closing has lead to gnashing of teeth more than once.

>Most Windows applications are MDI or tabbed so this seems like less of issue.Even a lot of OS X apps are tabbed.

I appreciate the shift with some programs, but it doesn't seem as prevalent as I feel it should be, or we're not talking about the same thing. IE and Office are definitely guilty of this. Ctrl+w your tabs enough, and it'll simply close out the program. Or if you choose to X out your windows via mouse, if it's the last window, it will exit out the program. "Window" and "program" seem to be synonymous, so this requires I do a time-wasting check whether it's the last instance or not. Whereas in OSX, exiting the program is a discrete cmd+q vs closing a window (cmd+w). As long as those two remain intertwined concepts in Windows, it's going to feel less logical to me (in my opinion of course).

So far, I feel pretty keyboard-warrior-y just as much as I was on Windows. Which probably comes back to workflows. As you pointed out, you use the mouse to rename files, whereas I don't. I figure if I'm renaming a file, I need to type a new name, so my hands can be in the classic "home" position instead of moving around to the mouse or F2.

I can see your point about the taskbar, but after a month of use (which admittedly was painful), I honestly stopped missing it. The OS X dock does show what apps are open as well with a lit up effect. Though in both OSes, I end up autohiding them. And worst case scenario, the OS X version of aero tab/Winkey+tab groups together all your active windows by program (though the feature kind of chugged when it first released, but I'd argue aero tab was pretty clunky on older machines when it first came out as well).

>For the longest time, OS X was missing some really obvious stuff though. Like resizing windows from any corner!

So true. And they finally ditched the bizarre "green" button behavior.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by wvenable on Thursday January 22, 2015 @02:22PM (#8931128)
> Ha, looks like my opinions hurt someone's feelings and got downvoted. Meh.

Yeah, stupid, have an upvote!

> Haha, I'm glad we can civilly hate each other's preferences. To me, repeating the menu strip for each window is a waste of real-estate, but i'm a huge desktop space whore. I don't need "File, Edit, etc" on every program window.

Well a lot of programs are ditching having a menu bar at all. This Firefox window I'm typing this into is really minimal -- no menu at all. If you're a desktop space whore than this is better than both options. I feel like the Mac way makes sense when desktop space is at a premium (like with the original Mac) but I have more desktop space than I know what to do with!

> Actually, I find myself getting confused the other way around. In Windows, if I step away from my desk, and come back, it's not clear to me which program is currently active

That's a valid point. After getting distracted, I've typed into the wrong window in my multi-monitor desktop because the wrong app has focus. But I don't think I'd be any more likely to look in the very top left corner of one monitor to see which one is active either. In a single monitor situation, this is almost a non-issue.

> I feel like the root of our different workflows has as lot to do with the fact that I prefer to autohide my taskbars

Yeah, I don't autohide but I do make them smaller than the current Windows default.

> As long as those two remain intertwined concepts in Windows, it's going to feel less logical to me (in my opinion of course).

This is a totally valid point and I don't have a good argument against it. But I think it comes with the baggage of having that single top menu bar which I think is much less logical. But I'm not sure if it's possible to reconcile these things. I will say that Office has probably the worst window management of any application on Windows but thankfully I usually only have one document open at a time. Ironically, NextStep has menus in each app and this was removed when it became OS X to make the transition easier for users.

> So far, I feel pretty keyboard-warrior-y just as much as I was on Windows.

I'm actually more of a mouse person or perhaps more accurately a combo mouse/keyboard. But strangely enough, my file management workflow is weirdly hampered on OS X. I found a few apps that just wouldn't let me CTRL-C CTRL-V a file into them, for example. I'm willing to concede if I used nothing but the keyboard, the Finder might be better but in my usage I just find it frustrating.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by WorldWideWayne on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @11:19PM (#8927505)
Here are some more examples of OS X UI deficiencies compared to Windows:

- Keyboard acceleration for application menus is more consistent and robust under Windows. Press Alt + the underlined letter of any menu to activate it and then hunt around using the arrow keys. Press underlined letter of menu item to activate it. No memorizing arcane shortcuts.

- Windows' Taskbar is much, much more flexible than OS X's Dock because it does everything the Dock does in it's default mode and it's got other modes that the Dock does not such as having one "entry per window" instead of one "entry per application that displays a list of windows when clicked". I like entry per window mode. The Taskbar is also highly customizable via something like 7+ taskbar tweaker where you can make "taskbar entries" act like browser tabs (middle click to close). Apple never gives anyone access to the proper APIs to customize the Dock. Developers can't even change NSScreen.visibleFrame so even if you wanted to replace the Dock you couldn't do it properly and windows end up behind your replacement (a bug all dock replacement software shares).

- Apple seems to prefer buttons that have icons with no labels everywhere. Also, they seem to like little tiny buttons for things like Add/Delete an item in a list, where a Windows app would have a nice big button with an icon and a label. Windows is just more utilitarian over all and Microsoft generally seems to value function over style, which matches my own preferences.

- The Windows Explorer is much more flexible and extensible than the OS X Finder. Extending the Explorer context menu is a matter of course on Windows. There's a very robust API for it. Overall, the Finder is vastly inferior to Explorer which is also easier to navigate with a keyboard.

- Save/Open dialogs in OS X are limited. One example: I go to save a file and create a folder. Ooops, I want to delete that folder but I can't do it from the dialog, I have to go and open a Finder instance. Windows generally lets you do anything in an Open/Save dialog that you can do from a Windows Explorer instance. There's a plugin for OS X that attempts to fix some of these issues called "Default Folder X".

- Display management: OS X doesn't have handy features to quickly turn off external displays like Windows where I just hit Win+P. If I want to get rid of a monitor in OS X I have to turn it off or unplug the video cable. Maybe in Yosemite they added the ability to disable a monitor via control panel. OS X also wants to go to sleep if I close a Macbook/Pro lid, even if an external monitor is plugged in.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by ANTSANTS on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @11:34PM (#8927548)
>Save/Open dialogs in OS X are limited. One example: I go to save a file and create a folder. Ooops, I want to delete that folder but I can't do it from the dialog, I have to go and open a Finder instance. Windows generally lets you do anything in an Open/Save dialog that you can do from a Windows Explorer instance. There's a plugin for OS X that attempts to fix some of these issues called "Default Folder X".

This was also a great annoyance for me on Linux (or more specifically, with the GTK file save/open dialog).

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by moogleii on Thursday January 22, 2015 @12:01PM (#8930208)
The delete thing is actually not true https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8930181
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by ANTSANTS on Thursday January 22, 2015 @01:11PM (#8930646)
I wasn't talking about OSX though.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by moogleii on Thursday January 22, 2015 @01:49PM (#8930888)
Sure, and I wasn't attempting to correct you. Merely pointing out the original premise is not true.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by WorldWideWayne on Thursday January 22, 2015 @07:14PM (#8932658)
Thanks for taking the time to check my assertions and for replying. I think that one feature changed in Mavericks.

I'm honestly not ecstatic about any of the desktop OS choices today, but I have hope that will change one day!

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by moogleii on Thursday January 22, 2015 @11:56AM (#8930181)
> - Keyboard acceleration for application menus is more consistent and robust under Windows. Press Alt + the underlined letter of any menu...

Definitely true. Although, the "common core" keyboard shortcuts are represented enough for me. I don't care to remember each individual program's hot letters. But it definitely is a lifesaver when you don't have access to a mouse.

> Apple seems to prefer buttons that have icons with no labels...Also, they seem to like...

That's beyond debatable subjectivity and well into the realm of "I just don't like it", so I'll just leave it at that (though I will say Chrome for windows is pretty icon heavy, and Visual Studio is moving that way as well). And to be fair, I think API and extensions are beyond the scope of what we were talking about.

> Ooops, I want to delete that folder but I can't do it from the dialog,

That's definitely not true. I just walked over to an OSX machine and verified it wasn't my imagination. Perhaps it was a recent addition, I'll give you that, but I don't recall it being an issue for quite some time.

Sometimes I do miss the full power of a file explorer in my Save/Open dialog, but it's not all heaven on earth. If I'm working in directories in active instances of Explorer, and then I decide I want to save a file from a program to one of those directories, the dialog will use a default (typically My Documents) or the last used path that the application remembers you using. This means I have to drill down or seek out the aforementioned directories either through mouse or typing in the path manually. I find that to be an annoying waste of time, especially if I was deep in a directory tree in a totally different "forest" if you will.

With OSX, I can drag over the folder from Finder to the Save dialog, and it knows that, since the context is "you want to save something", that it should switch to that directory. The Windows save dialog will act like a special Explorer instance, as you said, and copy the dragged directory instead. Sure, there are a few times where that's handy, but I prefer the more logical contextual use.

- Display management

I agree with that, OS X is definitely lagging on multi-monitor features (although I personally rarely need to shut off or unplug my second monitor).

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by jjoonathan on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:31PM (#8925067)
> Outside of the "real" shell the entire UI doesn't seem to be designed for software professionals.

Funny, because one of my big peeves with Windows and Linux is that certain developer-handy UI/UX features are missing and/or a pain in the ass to set up (even aside from the terminal).

* Emacs editing and movement shortcuts are built into OSX system-wide. (Ctrl+A and Ctrl+P collide on Win, Linux and keyboard management in ubuntu is messy and unreliable)

* Modifier-remapping is easy and solid on OSX (Need to run the download.com gauntlet on Windows, Linux is again an unreliable mess)

* Opening a document's parent folder(s) is easy and universal on OSX (command click on document icon in title bar), good luck finding this outside an IDE anywhere else.

* Turning off a laptop's screen on demand is easy and reliable on OSX. It's frustrating on windows (I need 2 apps and a couple lines of code, wtf) and a nightmare on linux (where you're lucky to get working brightness control at all, let alone one that goes all the way to 0).

* Thermal management is solid on OSX. I can let my laptop build at night and sleep in the same room because the fan controller actually works. Meanwhile, Linux doesn't recognize the fans (you know what that means: max rpm all the time) and windows revs up like a NASCAR driver in rush hour traffic (it bluescreened both custom fan control apps I've tried, naturally).

* It's easy to get a file from Finder into "Open..." dialogs: just drag and drop (e.g. attach file), as opposed to re-navigating through the entire filesystem. Windows has one especially braindead "open" dialog type that almost seems to be designed for the particular purpose of making this difficult (you know, the one that doesn't let you Ctrl+L, doesn't scroll sideways, doesn't remember the last directory you were in, etc).

* Finder knows how to sort alphabetically. For some reason the closest that Windows is willing to do is "Sort by File/Folder status, and THEN alphabetically by name." This has the very frustrating effect that unzipped folders are often very far (both in screen space and keyboard space) from their .zip files. When you have to deal with a lot of them, this gets frustrating FAST.

I'll give Microsoft one thing: the Windows+X menu is a fine piece of work. But I imagine you have a list similar to my own of things that you like about Windows and can't find anywhere else. I'd appreciate a trick swap seeing as I'm stuck in the Windows ecosystem at the moment :)

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by ANTSANTS on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @11:46PM (#8927578)
>Emacs editing and movement shortcuts are built into OSX system-wide. (Ctrl+A and Ctrl+P collide on Win, Linux and keyboard management in ubuntu is messy and unreliable)

Not everyone likes emacs. Like the vast majority of PC users, I grew up with CUA programs and I loath emacs keybindings.

>Modifier-remapping is easy and solid on OSX (Need to run the download.com gauntlet on Windows, Linux is again an unreliable mess)

Autohotkey on Windows. I'll give you Linux, I don't remember exactly what song and dance involving .xmodmap and .xinitrc or some other shit I've forgotten that I had to go through last time.

>Opening a document's parent folder(s) is easy and universal on OSX (command click on document icon in title bar), good luck finding this outside an IDE anywhere else.

Most programs I've used support a "right click->open containing folder" option.

>Turning off a laptop's screen on demand is easy and reliable on OSX. It's frustrating on windows (I need 2 apps and a couple lines of code, wtf) and a nightmare on linux (where you're lucky to get working brightness control at all, let alone one that goes all the way to 0).

I could have sworn this "just worked" with my Thinkpad, but maybe it's different for Macbooks. Ditto for thermal management. Linux of course is a nightmare.

>It's easy to get a file from Finder into "Open..." dialogs: just drag and drop (e.g. attach file), as opposed to re-navigating through the entire filesystem. Windows has one especially braindead "open" dialog type that almost seems to be designed for the particular purpose of making this difficult (you know, the one that doesn't let you Ctrl+L, doesn't scroll sideways, doesn't remember the last directory you were in, etc).

Drag and drop is supported by almost every Windows program I've used. For attaching files in web forms, you're supposed to drag the file onto the "select file" button in the web page, not into the "open file" dialog.

>Finder knows how to sort alphabetically. For some reason the closest that Windows is willing to do is "Sort by File/Folder status, and THEN alphabetically by name." This has the very frustrating effect that unzipped folders are often very far (both in screen space and keyboard space) from their .zip files. When you have to deal with a lot of them, this gets frustrating FAST.

I prefer it that way, because 99% of the time I'm not unzipping a bunch of .zip files, and I'd rather see the directories first if I'm trying to navigate deep into a directory tree.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by WorldWideWayne on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @11:29PM (#8927533)
> ...the more that Windows tries to be like OS X the less I like it.

I am with you! It started with the default Taskbar configuration and "pinning" things. I find it completely useless and I always disable grouping. Furthermore, I use 7+ taskbar tweaker to make the Taskbar act exactly the way I want it to and I have actually written a couple Microsofties in an attempt to get them to buy this company and integrate it :)

The one thing that I'm really disappointed in though is the Ribbon. I just wish that I could hunt through it with the keyboard or mouse as easily as I can with regular menus. Hunting with the mouse is too clicky - you can scroll the middle wheel now, but I'd rather just activate each tab when I put the pointer over it. Hunting throught the Ribbon with the keyboard is ridiculous too because all of the tool-tips just get in the way of seeing what's there. I like classic menus and toolbars way, way better except when I'm on a touch device.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by mark_l_watson on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:10PM (#8924030)
I mostly use OS X also. That said, last week I bought a "signature edition" HP Stremm 11" directly from Microsoft (so no crapware was pre-installed). I spent $200 for this mostly just to play around with Windows 8.1 out of curiosity.

I was surprised how much I liked it. I installed Chrome, and boom, my browsing environment was set up. I installed SSH, GPG, git, IntelliJ, Java 8, and Pharo Smalltalk and I was all set up for Clojure and Smalltalk development. The only complaint I have is that this very low end laptop is not very fast, even with the SSD disk.

When my MacBook Air dies in the future, it is possible that I will get a higher performance Windows 10 laptop.

edit: I have been feeling more warmly towards Microsoft lately because I am in their BizSpark program (free Linux servers for 3 years! Yeah!) and recently switched from Dropbox to Office 365 (for the same $100/year, both my wife and I get 1 terrabyte of cloud storage, and all of the Office if we want it).

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by josefresco on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:28PM (#8924186)
"Windows just feels like an uphill battle to do everything I want to these days"

For example...

For those of us who actually use Windows for work (and not just write about it) the start button was an issue for all of 10 seconds.

I actually appreciate the new start menu approach. Instead of a "dumping ground" of icons, there's significantly less clutter, and a cleaner interface. Can't say I use my start menu much, as most of my commonly used applications are launched from the taskbar (pinned).

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by fluidcruft on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:41PM (#8924276)
As an infrequent Windows user, I also don't bother with the start menu anymore...

My goto is the prominent search (even in the Windows 7 start menu). The only time I like the menu us when I can't remember the specific name of an app and I need to look at the list of names or icons to trigger my memory (which is rare). Otherwise search is so much superior than hunting around with a mouse trying to remember whether a certain app is sorted by name or company or finding where a setting is hidden. It used to bother me when control panel settings moved, but with search honestly who cares?

It's not like we use yahoo's directory or dmoz anymore to browse the web...

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by tracker1 on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:33PM (#8924223)
Personally, I just installed ClassicShell and never looked back.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by abandonliberty on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:16PM (#8924077)
I think a lot of that is switching cost, and that both OSs are pretty similar now.

My recent experience on OS X: - Couldn't find an easy way to get windows side by side[0] - Installed a program, but it just kept crashing on launch until I rebooted the computer - Challenging to figure out how to get Finder to actually show you the drive contents

[0] http://www.howtogeek.com/181681/4-hidden-window-management-t...

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by t0mbstone on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:46PM (#8924303)
I use a tool called "moom" for window management. Gives me the ability to snap windows to edges of the screen (like Win 7 does), plus the ability to snap-size windows to a grid. Can't use OSX without it.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:32PM (#8924593)
Its 2015, if we need 3rd party tools for window management, then someone is really screwing up.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by afandian on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:58PM (#8924786)
I've used Apples since 1993, with a brief (enjoyable) gap of a couple of years writing C#.

It's the Apple way. They decide you don't want something and it's infuriating.

But the rest of Mac OS is quite good, I quite like Finder, and with bash, a JVM, a good browser and text editor, that's enough to overcome the frustration of "Apple knows best".

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by zachberger on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:06PM (#8924439)
"moom" is great but I prefer "Spectale" and its keyboard shortcuts
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by CardenB on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:26PM (#8924546)
I see a lot of people want window snapping, and I avoid switching because of this also. However, after switching, window snapping frustrates me. Occasionally I need it, so I use a tool for it, and I take advantage of it about once a month.

Maybe if windows offered gestures and was POSIX compliant I wouldn't mind switching. Then I would want a laptop that is about as thin/light as a retina with an equivalent display and trackpad plus a MagSafe style adaptor. Then I would want a proper package manager and a time machine style backup solution.

Then I could try to find a way to integrate iOS services into my workflow properly, but I still won't have iMessage, which is a bummer. I would consider that a point against apple if I didn't like iMessage/FaceTime so much. I guess that could be factored into switching cost. I just don't care to leave iOS at this point.

I will agree that finder is really unnecessarily frustrating and that there are a few drawbacks to OS X. Especially with a couple random bugs lately. However, the experience, for me, has been overwhelmingly net positive, and there are just so many things I would miss by switching right now that I don't see it happening.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by abandonliberty on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:54PM (#8925247)
An old comment of mine is relevant again:

As a veteran system builder, I was rather surprised when I looked into laptops recently to find macbooks very competitive.

I dislike Apple as an organization due to their marketing practices, closed ecosystem, and apparent lack of respect for their customers demonstrated in their reaction to bend/antenna gate. Apple even works hard to hide what processors their systems are actually running!

After much digging, though the hardware costs slightly more, MBPs come out far ahead as a package with OS X - a full featured OS with a healthy ecosystem and excellent battery life. I couldn't find a better option for my intended user.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by Amezarak on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:45PM (#8924686)
> Then I would want a proper package manager and a time machine style backup solution.

I don't know specifically what you need from Time Machine, but File History in 8.1 (and somewhat, Windows Backup on 7) does full image backups and incremental backups. It could be integrated better, but you can go back and see your files and folders at whatever point in time you desire. I have it setup on my FreeNAS and it works well enough.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by ronyeh on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:23PM (#8924145)
I use http://www.bettertouchtool.net for window snapping (among other features).
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by moystard on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:19PM (#8924108)
Finder has always been disappointing in my opinion. Regarding the two windows side by side, you should have Spectacle a go, it works wonder, but the feature is indeed not included in OSX. I have always found the way OSX manages windows to be confusing, and the new fullscreen behaviour does not help (I know alt clicking the full screen button shows the previous behaviour but still...)
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by krylon on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:07PM (#8924446)
I like OS X - I got a MacMini ~15 months ago, and despite my plan to install Debian, I still haven't.

But it does crash on me every ~6 weeks. A - halfway - modern operating system should not crash, unless the hardware is faulty. I really like badmouthing Windows, But my work laptop running Windows 7 has crashed only two or three times in nearly two years.

Also, as a former GNU/Linux user, I am unhappy about the poor integration of X11. Cygwin's X server is a lot smoother in that regard.

(Let me repeat, I do like OS X, and yes, Windows has plenty of things I intensely dislike, which is why I do not use it on my private computers.)

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by munificent on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:17PM (#8924964)
> But it does crash on me every ~6 weeks. A - halfway - modern operating system should not crash, unless the hardware is faulty.

Obvious follow-up question: are you sure your hardware isn't faulty?

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by krylon on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:42PM (#8925157)
Let's say I am confident, but not 100% sure.

I found an app a couple of months back that lets me monitor the CPU temperature and adjust the fan speed (at least the minimum fan speed) - I upped it from 1800rpm to 4000rpm (above 4000, it gets noisy), and crashes have become somewhat less common. So maybe it was just a heat problem.

But I did notice that most crashes happened when I was trying to watch something on YouTube, so it could also be a problem with Flash or the graphics driver. (Then again, YouTube has worked fine for me recently, so maybe it really was a heating/cooling problem.)

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by revscat on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:04PM (#8923987)
So long as OS X has the unix-y goodness underneath it, I can't imagine switching back, either. I hope Windows continues to improve, but I can't imagine choosing to use it again.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by slantyyz on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:07PM (#8924445)
I just switched back to Windows after about a decade on OSX (I was on Windows the decade before that and MacOS the decade before that). My reasons for switching are more hardware related, so I won't get into that.

For the most part, it doesn't really matter what OS I use, since the tools I use are pretty much available everywhere. Before I made the switch, however, I was really worried that I'd have a much inferior user experience on Windows than OSX. But that turned out to be a non-issue.

I thought I'd be concerned about being stuck with cmd.exe, but Cmder is awesome. I don't really need to change any of my OSX terminal habits at all.

I thought I'd miss Gitbox. I still do, but SourceTree does enough of a good job that I can get by.

The one thing I like about OSX is the level of polish of the UI and of apps that run in the OS. Things on Windows aren't at OSX's level, but they are generally way better than they were when I switched to OSX. Faint praise, I guess.

The Windows 8 Start Menu thing. I thought I would hate it. But here's the thing, I switched to using Spotlight to launch everything in OSX, and it's pretty much the same thing on Windows, just hit Windows key, and type the name of the app I want to launch. Having said that, Windows local search is horrible vs. Spotlight. There is a (paid) fix - Listary is a great substitute for Spotlight on Windows.

I hated Windows Explorer post Windows 2000 (but I still hate Windows Explorer less than Finder). It still sucks. But Classic Explorer restores things to the way I preferred back in the day.

My day to day tools are pretty much cross platform, Sublime, DBVisualizer, PGAdmin, Evernote, Postbox, etc. So there were very few hiccups there.

Windows is far from perfect (although Windows 10 definitely looks like it addresses my biggest annoyances), but it's not a huge downgrade from OSX in the way a lot of people think about it. I still prefer Windows over Linux Desktops, probably because the way it works is a lot more familiar to me than Linux.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by scardine on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:47PM (#8924312)
GoW + ConEmu make Windows 8 acceptable for me.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by Igglyboo on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:25PM (#8924157)
This is the killer for me as well, unless Windows somehow becomes POSIX compliant I just don't see me switching back.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by ksk on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:34PM (#8924229)
Windows has been POSIX compliant for about 20 years.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by agildehaus on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:00PM (#8924396)
Services for UNIX has always been optional, was depreciated in 8.0 (and only available for Enterprise SKUs), and removed entirely in 8.1.

Modern Windows is decidedly not POSIX-compliant.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by ksk on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:24PM (#8924531)
It has been optional because you have to pay for it. POSIX compliance has a cost associated with it. Not that I think POSIX compliance has any value anymore, mind you. I was replying to someone for whom POSIX compliance was a make or break feature.

Anyway, I sense an argument drift from "Windows" to "Modern Windows". Nice. I guess earlier versions of Windows stopped being Windows once version 8.1 was released.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by derefr on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:15PM (#8924945)
> I guess earlier versions of Windows stopped being Windows once version 8.1 was released.

Well, yeah. We're (presumably) talking about software architecture choices here. Are you telling me you'd purposefully build a new system on top of an old version of Windows, and specifically on old features that have since been deprecated+removed? If not, then it doesn't matter what old Windows does; "Windows is not POSIX-compliant" is the fact that you are making a choice based upon when you design a system right now.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by ksk on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @03:01PM (#8925299)
POSIX compliance (which probably only serves as a checkbox for some arcane procurement guideline) is only relevant in niche markets. You are trying to apply a general software design thought process which unfortunately doesn't work there. People still ship WinCE and '95 software. Software targeting old UNIX systems is still being written today.

BTW, I can purchase a copy of windows 8 today (which is going to be supported by Microsoft till 2023) that is POSIX compliant. So the argument is moot anyway.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by RadioactiveMan on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:53PM (#8924356)
Could you elaborate? In what I've learned (in the past few minutes) it looks like it hasn't has POSIX compatibility since an optional subsystem up to Windows 2000. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/POSIX#POSIX_for_Windows
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by ksk on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:30PM (#8924578)
Elaborate on what? You have to purchase a version of Windows that has the POSIX layer because POSIX compliance costs money. From what I gather it has been dropped in Windows 8.1.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by antr on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:10PM (#8924027)
Back in 2010 I gave my dad the basic Macbook Air as a xmas present. Until then he was working on decent Dell laptop, but after seeing how much he struggled when trying to do basic stuff (e.g. connecting to a wifi network, browsing the web with a PC full of adware, etc) I decided to get him a Mac. I can't say how many times he has told everyone how much he likes Macs... and at the end of the day, it's all thanks to OSX's (most of the time) small and polished UX details. He, for sure, won't be going back to Windows.

Still, I can't wait to see Windows do a comeback... I don't know if W10 will be the answer, but I sure hope they make a come back for consumers' sake.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by pjmlp on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:25PM (#8924538)
I will consider a Mac the day Apple wants to sell me a CPU/GPU combo I want to buy, at a price it makes sense.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by CardenB on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:28PM (#8924565)
This has honestly been my biggest overall frustration with Apple since I began using their products. I've got a hackintosh, but it's been a nightmare to setup and maintain. It's currently out of commission because Yosemite broke iMessage and I would rather not switch back to Mavericks.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by berberous on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:06PM (#8923997)
Agreed. I recently started using Windows 7 Enterprise for work, and I'm surprised at how often I need to reboot to make things work or to avoid slowdowns. Granted, that's usually due to Adobe and Java hanging, but even killing those processes in task manager won't fix it. Maybe there's a better solution, but I just reboot.

I don't think I've ever had to reboot OS X for similar reasons.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by cwbrandsma on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:25PM (#8924156)
I've been running on a Mac for the last 2 years, after 20'ish years of Windows work. At this point I'm 50/50. There are things I HATE about both system.

* Window management in OSX is a complete joke (docking and sizing), I've lost all faith that Apple will ever get that right. * The shell and terminal support is better in OSX (yes, powershell is there, but not by default, and the standard DOS shell sucks) * I have to reboot both systems once a month to keep them working. Others disagree here, but I find OSX no more stable than Windows. * OSX Sound Drivers (WTF! -- I constantly lose sound support on my MacBook Pro) * Microsoft is much faster at fixing issues than Apple (I have a bunch of long standing OSX bugs that span multiple versions, and a couple of new ones with the current release) * I no longer feel the love for Apple hardware. Every iteration is made harder to upgrade than the last. * The Apple App Store is so much better than Microsoft's Store. * Safari is IE: they are both browsers you should only use to download a better browser.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by ashark on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:52PM (#8924737)
>Safari is IE: they are both browsers you should only use to download a better browser.

Safari's great for battery life. I've switched from Chrome for that reason. Judging from the system-wide beachballs and frequent fan spin-ups for no obvious reason back when I used Firefox, I assume it would be even worse than Chrome.

Its developer tools aren't that different from Chrome's, either, and it's got a decent selection of plugins. I have Chrome installed and occasionally use it, but close it ASAP.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by wvenable on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:33PM (#8924603)
That's crazy. I haven't rebooted my home Windows 7 desktop in forever. Even when I install new graphics card drivers (AMD pumps out a new one every month) my screen flashes for moment and I keep working. The installer recommends I reboot but it's never at a good time.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by ksk on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:45PM (#8924298)
That's crazy. I don't know how technical you are, but personally I'd never ever trust my data to such a machine without fixing it or replacing it. I have a zero tolerance policy when it comes to stuff like that.

FWIW I've never had to reboot windows beyond once a month for the updates, if at all. I run Win8 and it runs well, pretty much like my other machines - OSX on my MBPro7,1 (Snow Leopard b/c anything else degrades the performance and/or has bugs) & CentOS 6.4 which has been rock solid on my 8 year old repurposed desktop-as-server.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by krylon on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @02:57PM (#8925266)
My work laptop runs Windows 7 Pro, and I usually reboot it once a month, when it installs updates.

It is slow as a turtle, but rebooting does not really help with that. (To be fair, it slow at least in part because it is five years old, has only three GB of RAM (remember the days when we would have drooled at the thought of that?), and I installed way too much software on it, a good part of it usually running when I use it.)

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by moystard on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:16PM (#8924078)
I am an OSX user primarily but I have never seen this kind of behaviour on any of my Windows installation. There is something wrong in what you describe.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by leoedin on Thursday January 22, 2015 @04:18AM (#8928266)
I've had a very different experience to you. On my home PC running Windows 7 I only have to reboot every few weeks, normally due to a Windows Update requirement.

There are times when the system slows down, but normally that's temporary and due to a misbehaving program rather than a system wide issue.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by plikan13 on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:42PM (#8924663)
My main gripe with Windows at the moment is the amount of time I'm staring at Windows updates. It gets ridiculous at times.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by amalag on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @11:56AM (#8923930)
I am also completely spoiled by Mac's now. I don't know how I could go back, especially the trackpad.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by fluidcruft on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:10PM (#8924031)
Well, I know it's unpopular, but I could never manage the transition from Linux to MacOS (and this from someone that was excited about OpenSTEP returning to the limelight). Way too much effort required to work around idiotic design decisions and iFads and central policy forced down my throat and outdated userland and broken Motif. Life is just so much easier on debian/ubuntu even with a windows sidekick VM for when absolutely necessary. And honestly, I like the direction Windows has been going overall when forced to use it. It at least seems to be getting lower maintenance. Not the "run it from a live-cd" sort of low maintenance, but still getting closer.
Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by ftfish on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @12:52PM (#8924353)
"I could never manage the transition from Linux to MacOS"

I feel the same way. I recently started using a MacBook at work. It's a mid-2014 MacBook Pro w/Retina display and there is a lot I like about using it.

But it seems rather hostile to developers. The keyboard shortcuts don't make a lot of sense -- most of it really is just about what I'm used to, but for example ⌘+SHIFT+3/4 to take a screenshot? And the CTRL+SHIFT+POWER KEY combination to lock the screen is a very odd choice.

⌘+C and ⌘+V work on files/folders, but not ⌘+X?

I only had to setup MAMP here so far, but it wasn't quite as smooth as LAMP on my Ubuntu machine.

I am in the market for a new laptop -- I considered everything from Chromebooks to even getting my own MacBook. But I keep going back to a Ubuntu/Windows dual-boot setup. There are just too many little annoyances with OSX for me.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by slantyyz on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @01:13PM (#8924481)
I'm probably in the minority, but while I hate Apple's trackpad less than the ones on its competitors, I still hate it.

I constantly struggle with right clicking items on Apple trackpads (and the PC trackpads that attempt to copy Apple's).

I would prefer to have two distinct buttons below the pad. To me, the new trend of pivoting pads as buttons don't work for my clumsy hands.

Re:Windows 10: The Next Chapter [video] by interdrift on Wednesday January 21, 2015 @11:57AM (#8923934)
Depends on what Microsoft will put on the table ;)