Surprisingly, it turns out that this is an easy way to make enemies, as last week's action in Paris have shown. It has been shown since 2005 that the islamists that massacred twelve people were, in fact, radicalized by what they learned about the prison of Abu Ghraib.
Job well done, thank you very much guys.
Lastly, the way our own government is supporting the nsa makes me feel nauseated at some times, furious at other times. We have plenty of work to do locally, that's why usually I don't complain about foreign services. Simply allowing the nsa to gain world domination like that though, just because "that is their job", really is hard to accept for me, and it really rubs me the wrong way.
http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/140247/jennifer-sims/...
The USA has no allies, only clients. Some clients get more respect than others but they're all clients.
Remember, the State Department had a mole in the FDP, reporting on the German coalition negotiations. In all likelihood the CIA have a minister or more. The US does not respect anyone's sovereignty who can't and won't make them.
I can't believe it is more likely to you that your government is rolling over and "letting the NSA gain world domination", versus your government is trying to downplay it because they know they may one day be caught in exactly the same situation.
I do believe the NSA overstepped their mandate in domestic surveillance, and should be held accountable, but let's not forget that this world does have bad guy's - plenty of nations would lose no sleep at night if they hurt America.
I have no doubt that the NSA's job is "national security" and that some portion of that work serves the people. Nobody knows what that portion is, by design.
If you bury the difficult, complicated issues under terms like "security", "threat to the country", and "bad guys", you're basically just supporting the NSA on faith.
Forget the terminology and FUD of "threats", and let's ask ourselves what the concrete benefit to the people of the United States (or better yet, the world) is for the NSA to be arming themselves for the destruction of computer systems. Is the benefit Cold Waresque deterrence through keeping the rest of the world in fear? Is this the strategy we want our work and taxes to support?
Maybe it's too complicated to think about, and even if we wanted to critically analyse the situation, secrecy prevents us from knowing anything besides what the government desires the people to know. It's easier to just trust in benevolent "national security" protecting us from Eastasia. Let's not forget that the world does have bad guys, and besides, we've always been at war with Eastasia.
They've been doing it longer than the Internet. The "Five Eyes" have existed for a while, so that they can have a legal loophole for domestic spying (e.g. "We can't spy on our citizens, so we'll just ask our allies to do it for us!"). To me this indicates that, while the stated purpose behind the organization may have merits, the execution of that purpose has been flawed for some time.
It specifically explores the conflict of interest that the NSA must work both offensively and defensively. It makes the argument that the balance has shifted so drastically to the offensive that our defensive is being weakened.
Now, the US government as a whole is in a very strong position to actually push for genuine security compliance and to ultimately defend against even the most determined state cyber warfare initiative. They haven't done that because they want a way to get into systems even if it makes people less safe on the whole.
> I would tell him to steer away from anything that isn't a public service — like talking about the ability of the U.S. government to hack into other countries or other people is not a public service. So that's kind of compromising capabilities and sources and methods, basically. That's getting away from the public service that he did initially. And those would be the acts that people would charge him with as clearly treason.
The whole interview is a great read: http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2013/06/16/snowd...
Correct me if I'm wrong, but they said some time ago that only 1% was published. So it would be impossible for Snowden himself to read everything and choose if it should be published.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/exclusive-uks-...
and the Guardian's "haha what":
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/aug/23/uk-gove...
Note that this "leak", as well as NOT coming from Snowden, isn't really in the domestic public interest, is an activity that a far larger percentage of people would support, and presumably is already known by the target anyway. The clear intent is to make people read the article and go "huh, this Snowden ballyhoo is very overblown". I wonder why the so-called "Independent" played along.
It's also important the public realize the NSA is more than just the National Stalking Agency.
I bet there's a room stacked to the ceiling in printed US secret military documents in Beijing that they trade to Russia for cheap oil+gas imports. I realize Snowden never wanted that to happen but there's a reason why state's have strict methods to store and transport top secret data and they don't include using questionable XTS container software and staying in a HK hotel with the entire secret US archive stored on a commercial device.
No, movies have bad guys.
Not so much Blofeld as Klingon: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2421112/NSA-director...
Along with threat deterrent.
I can't think of any good argument for why the US military should have no offensive capabilities in the digital realm. It'd be the equivalent of staying out of the skies when flight became possible.
In any war, the US is going to come under digital attack, and it should be fully capable of responding both defensively and offensively. Besides that, shutting down the power grid of a country you're at war with via digital means, sure beats doing it with hundreds of missiles.
Oh, wait, no, it's not. Your German Shepherd isn't planting bombs underneath the neighbours' porches in case they decide to rob your house.
It seems like a bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy to me, which can be a very dangerous thing.
Vulnerabilities should be searched for, but when discovered they need to be disclosed and fixed, not used to create real world damage.
There is a clear need for defense. But because of lack of oversight, NSA has overstepped its bounds in both foreign and domestic spheres.
The other side of this argument, one made cogently by Snowden, is that we simply have more to lose by escalating the cyberwar.
In information warfare, waiting until conflict begins is too late. The information you collect and systems you exploit prepare you for the conflict.
For example, country A wants to know about country B's new bomber years ahead of the conflict so they can design anti-aircraft defenses to stop it. Country B spends years gaining access to Country A's routers, servers, etc. so they can utilize them the moment conflict begins.
If you wait for conflict to begin to do these things, you will be much too late.
Both may well need similar capabilities but we can't tell the ability of an agency to engage in "cyberwar" just from their activities in "cyber espionage".
Do you believe that backdooring American products will have a positive effect on security?
Ignoring this nonsensical analogy...
> undermine encryption, infiltrate networks, keep exploits to yourself
This is really the MO of any intelligence agency; that is their job.
> you can make everyone secure by patches, standards and encryption that works
Interesting statement, because it shows some things. Firstly, there is a difference in incentives -- why publish a vulnerability when it could be used to further your mandate? For the specific case of NSA though, that also ignores their broader role in securing federal communications (eg, vetting SHA, AES, FIPS, etc). Of course, there are always exceptions (DES, Dual-EC-DRBG, etc) -- but in a way, that precisely illustrates why we have intelligence agencies in the first place: trust no one.
If you think there's some sort of restraint with regards to citizens of other 'five eyes' nations, I wonder how you square that with the "but everyone spies on everyone, including allies" argument that can always be found in these threads.
This persistent confusion between legitimate NSA operations such as preparing to intercept communications of foreign governments and illegitimate such as mass slurping of everyone's email merely serves to discredit the entire privacy defending position, and in the long run will just play into the hands of those that want to read everyone's email for nefarious purposes.