The reason brokers will give you this much leverage is that ForEx (up until a couple days ago) was one of the most liquid markets on the planet. If you hit a margin call, your broker could instantly liquidate your entire portfolio to cover any loss, with very little risk.
And then, the SNB walked away from their Peg, and the earth collapsed underneath all these traders (and brokers in some case) - All these traders/brokers who thought that a position could be liquidated at minimal loss, ran into a market with a scarcity (absence) of buyers, and were wiped for the entire value of their accounts (and more - lots of traders ended up with a negative position)
This is a wakeup call that people will remember or a very, very long time (and should have been learnt in the 2008 Mortgage collapse) - the potential for a black swan event is everywhere.
[1] http://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/06/forexleverage.asp [2] http://www.investopedia.com/articles/forex/08/margin-leverag...
Not to mention that the roman system is not multiplicative but additive.
- CHFEUR floor is 1.2 (or that's what everybody thought)
- so you short the CHF @ 1.2
- side effect: your money is essentially stored safely in a position that has no downside but has upside (or so you think)
- if, for any reason, CHFEUR is >1.2, then you exit your short position with some profit
- when CHFEUR is back to 1.2, then do the same again.
Works brilliantly, until the black swan flies through your window, and everything is full of shattered glass. So in short, people relied on the SNB's promise, they thought there's zero risk of this thing happening (i.e. removing the floor without notice), and took positions that had small upside with ~1 probability and huge downside with ~0 probability. At least they have a good story to tell now.
In lower-end forex shops, you're simply authorizing your broker to calculate how much money you would have won or lost had the trade actually occurred and debit/credit your account accordingly. No foreign currencies change hands and no financial instruments are implicated.
These are called "bucket shops" and they're so slimy that Bitcoin exchange operators feel obligated to describe that they're not like them.
More than a century ago, Jesse Livermore[1] made and lost several fortunes trading stocks via bucket shops. Not unlike what happens to current day card counters, the bucket shops banned Livermore. Bucket shops (at least for stocks) have long been illegal in the USA.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reminiscences_of_a_Stock_Opera...
The original bucket shops were only slimy because they could have real traders at the exchange manipulating the price to wipe out customers in the bucket shop. (as far as I know)
There are other forms of FX trading. For example, you can go to 'betting' sites to bet on currency rate movements -- for example, in the UK this is usually better for retail clients than normal FX trading as the profits fall under betting profits and not trading profits, and the former are lower. (Ridiculous, I know.)
> How do people lose money on this? Are people somehow trading on the CHF/EUR exchange rate? And is so, why? The CHF was pegged to the EUR.
When you currency trade you go long one side of a currency pair and short the other. So you borrow 40000 Euro and buy Franc or vice versa. There is always a specific currency pair involved.
The usual reasons to take a position in a pegged currency is either to bet that the peg breaks (which people being long Euro obviously didn't do), or to extract value from a difference in interest rates (the carry trade, I don't know if that applied but there must have been something attractive about shorting CHF....)
By the way, poorly explained in the main post: most of the stops actually happened way below 1.05. The cross panic-traded down to 0.85 in the hour after the reval announcement, which is where most of the stops were occurring.
1.2/0.85 - 1 = a 41% loss.
Imagine if you were leveraged 100x......
The other people who are exposed are those who took out swiss franc mortgages from other countries[1]. I'm amazed this was even allowed, but up until now the franc was stable and the rates low so it made some sense.
[1] http://www.economist.com/news/europe/21639760-poles-were-slo...
Why do you think people would stop trading Genentech shares?
You're right, you don't, and it's too big a topic to explain in a comment, but basically yes people trade the exchange rates because they can and because if you do it right it's very profitable. You don't ever own either, currency trading is pairs trading where you're long one and short the other to open a position and exiting a position exits both trades which looks like a single trade to you.
George Soros once made a billion dollars shorting the GBP and forced a country to remove a floor, similar to what just happened here.
The EUR/USD has been sinking like a rock for most of the year, so traders short it, wait for it to sink more, and cash in their profits. It's just like trading stocks except you have more liquidity, more leverage, and going long/short are basically the same because these aren't stocks and going short the EUR/USD is identical to going long USD/EUR.
How do people lose money on this? Are people somehow trading on the CHF/EUR exchange rate? And is so, why? The CHF was pegged to the EUR.
It reminds of when people were still trading shares in Genentech for years when Roche had an option to buy all GNE shares at a certain price, which they of course did eventually.
Is this another example of people trading without full knowledge?