His 3rd year was already blown (and that sort of thing happens when you get in the lab of an incompetent†); instead of putting the interests of the patients first, he submitted a false affidavit to the Howard Hughes Medical Institute in a go along, get along attempt to get funding to redo his 3rd year (I surmise from the article that he was unsuccessful).
I'd be a lot easier on him if this wasn't feeding into patient care at the same exact time he was reporting this. I don't insist every scientist who discovers "misconduct" do a Margaret O'Toole† and move from the lab to answering phones for her brother's moving company (Gentle Giant, they were great in the early '90s), but there was a lot more at stake than research that would get invalidated in due course as people tried to build upon it.
I suppose it's only fitting that currently his life is being turned upside down as a star witness for the inevitable lawsuits.
† I had a girlfriend who found it impossible to do undergraduate research (UROP) in Imanishi-Kari's lab, it was very poorly run. I doubt Imanishi-Kari committed fraud then, just shoddy, incorrect research, but per the Secret Service, the government's experts on paper and inks, she certainly did when the investigation got serious.
You're basically asking the junior developer to question all the senior developers, the lead developers, and the executive managers. There is only so many people a person can say are wrong. It's not possible for him to know everything, for all he knew he was wrong, and the professors were merely unwilling to take the time to explain it (or bring in an outside professor to explain it). That smelled wrong enough for him to get out, but he probably had a nagging thought in the back of his mind that he simply didn't understand.
There's also the responses of the PI and the PI's mentor. A real scientist doesn't take such questions as "a personal insult" as the now almost completely disgraced PI did (state medical boards that are desperate like North Dakota will still license the PI as a doctor, at last count). The PI's mentor wasn't that sort of unprofessional, but the article says he didn't respond well to this. Note also one of the Duke higher ups, apparently unprompted, introduced the word "misconduct" in all this.
If you're going to be a "life and death doctor" as I put it, for him one of the harshest examples of that, oncology, you're going to be making a lot of decisions that patients lives hinge on. A degree of certainty and decisiveness, what some call doctors' "God Complex", is required. I judge that he was sufficiently certain in his judgement of the research, and its implications for patients being treated based on it at the time. It's that last bit that I believe requires you to go above and beyond in determining if you're correct or not, and then doing what's right for the patients.
And for that matter it's inverse: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
It's the false affidavit that makes this crystal clear to me. He knew the situation was a lot worse than he stated in it---and note that at least as this article is framed, he allowed himself to be silenced.
... yet she still goes to work, doesn't she, mr moral absolutist?
She quit that career when she was pregnant with me, the eldest of 4, in 1960.
My relationship with those doctors ended when I went to college in 1979, and my family transitioned out of that business in the early '80s. So except what we read, and learn from and experience with our doctors, we're as out of touch with the modern medical scene. For that matter, since I'm disabled, and my parents are old, we're all on Medicare, which has it's own weird rules.
So, no front row seat.
I would say "nice try", except for the epic failure in reading comprehension in your rush to DISQUALIFY me.
A large number of doctors don't take -any- oath, as such.