Re:Duke Officials Silenced Med Student Who Reported Trouble ...
by SolarNet on Tuesday January 13, 2015 @01:26PM
(#8881613)
Ever hear of Imposter Syndrome? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impostor_syndrome
And for that matter it's inverse: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
There's also the responses of the PI and the PI's mentor. A real scientist doesn't take such questions as "a personal insult" as the now almost completely disgraced PI did (state medical boards that are desperate like North Dakota will still license the PI as a doctor, at last count). The PI's mentor wasn't that sort of unprofessional, but the article says he didn't respond well to this. Note also one of the Duke higher ups, apparently unprompted, introduced the word "misconduct" in all this.
If you're going to be a "life and death doctor" as I put it, for him one of the harshest examples of that, oncology, you're going to be making a lot of decisions that patients lives hinge on. A degree of certainty and decisiveness, what some call doctors' "God Complex", is required. I judge that he was sufficiently certain in his judgement of the research, and its implications for patients being treated based on it at the time. It's that last bit that I believe requires you to go above and beyond in determining if you're correct or not, and then doing what's right for the patients.