Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by ohazi on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:12AM
(#8861704)
Also how are these guys a public company? They're acting like some hotshot new startup, but they're a public company with nothing to their name but a patent and the fuzzy goal of licensing this pipe dream to other companies. The executives seem to have impressive bios, but the only ones that are taking a salary are the CEO and CTO. They supposedly have 9 employees as of 2014 (there are 6 non-independent board members, so three engineers?).
It just keeps getting weirder... this is starting to look more like fraud than your average startup-peddling-snake-oil.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by jrockway on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:08AM
(#8861695)
Are they ignoring the FCC's EIRP maxima (and beamforming penalty) on the 2.4GHz ISM band?
If they aren't, they can still get 1W theoretically, which is actually useful: it can kind of charge your phone in 8 hours. Assuming 100% of the power is captured by the antenna, that is. (Note that I say theoretically: the real world is very bad for theoretical models.)
Also something to worry about: the FCC's maximum permissible radiation exposure. For 6 minute controlled application (people near the transmitter know it's on), you're allowed an energy density of 5mW per square centimeter. An iPhone 4 is about 55 cm^2, so that would mean a maximum of 275mW. That would charge the phone in 24 hours. (These are guidelines for amateur radio operators, not Part 15 devices; I don't know what the regs around Part 15 say about power density. The regs also cover far-field effects, not near-field effects, so perhaps they can get around these.)
Finally, if you want to play with beamforming and figure out how to get 100% of the power to a 55 cm^2 area, try: http://apenwarr.ca/beamlab/
"To demo its tech, Energous has turned a casino suite into a faux home full of wireless power, which we dropped by to allow the company's founder Michael Leabman to put on a show for us."
If there is one thing that sets off my spidey sense during due diligence on new products it is demos in controlled environments.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by pmontra on Friday January 09, 2015 @04:55AM
(#8861494)
The post and the product page at http://www.energous.com/overview/ don't have much details. However the product pages has some data about the power output:
> Power Delivered to a Consumer Full-Featured Product
> 4W delivered simultaneously to 4 devices, 0-5 feet
> 2W delivered simultaneously to 4 devices, 5-10 feet
> 1W delivered simultaneously to 4 devices, 10-15 feet
> Delivering on average 2W to 4 devices simultaneously within the charging envelope
Things that concern me are, in random order:
- Is it safe to keep the device (let say it's a phone) in a pocket or close to one's head while is it charging?
- Is it safe to sit/sleep for hours in between the charger and a (possibly somebody's else) device?
- How focused the power beam is?
- What are the safety measures to prevent other people stealing the power? Think about the family living on the other side of the wall. Probably Bluetooth pairing, but I'm not 100% sure.
- Does it cause reduction of bandwidth for WiFi? (it uses the same frequencies)
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by davej on Friday January 09, 2015 @04:50AM
(#8861478)
Surely this would mean sending very high powered microwaves around a living space. Does anybody have more information/knowledge about the medium to long term safety of this approach.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by Mithaldu on Friday January 09, 2015 @04:04AM
(#8861375)
They claim to reach 70% efficiency, by transmitting power on the wifi bands, and compare it to a charging mat (90%), and tout 15 feet distance, but leave out one detail:
How quickly efficiency drops off.
I suspect you only get 70% if your phone is literally on top of the router, and that the efficiency drops of very quickly to 0 as you approach the range limit.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by richardwhiuk on Friday January 09, 2015 @05:08AM
(#8861542)
The suspicion is that the 70% efficiency is how much of the power arriving at the phone can be used for charging it, not much the transmitter is supplying.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by toomuchtodo on Friday January 09, 2015 @10:58AM
(#8862737)
The port wears out over time. I'd rather use the less efficient wireless charging rather than have to replace a port on a device at some point in its life.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by gpvos on Friday January 09, 2015 @04:54AM
(#8861493)
And if you have your phone in your pocket and happen to be in the beam, your testicles get microwaved. (Well, I hope and may assume that they addressed that in some way, but the article doesn't mention it.)
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by Kenji on Friday January 09, 2015 @05:52AM
(#8861656)
Please stop it already with the wireless powering. That stuff was discovered by Tesla ages ago, it's a very well known technology and it has very well known drawbacks like that the efficiency drops proportionally to distance square and that these kinds of electromagnetic waves actually do have a negative impact on human health.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by jrockway on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:10AM
(#8861699)
Wireless power has worked fine for a hundred years. Ever use a crystal radio?
Your health effects are very clearly in the [citation needed] area. The only negative effect from long-wave radiation (not gamma or UV) is that it heats things. If you heat a human too much, they die.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by mmagin on Friday January 09, 2015 @02:24PM
(#8863899)
While significant risk to internal organs seems unlikely, there have been studies for decades suggesting RF exposure may increase risk of cataracts in the eye.
e.g. http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/scc28/sc4/Ocular.pdf (see also the references)
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by Kenji on Friday January 09, 2015 @06:25AM
(#8861730)
Ever sat in a microwave while it was running? That is exactly what is happening to your body if you are between this charging router and a device that draws a lot of energy. Ever put a lightbulb in a microwave? That is exactly what will happen in your apartment between this charging router and the charging device. It's a safety and health hazard and it provides little to no benefits.
And please, that high powered electromagnetic waves are a health hazard does not need a citation.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by minikites on Friday January 09, 2015 @09:01AM
(#8862223)
Ever been around a microwave that seems to clobber your wireless networking performance when it runs? Lots of microwaves leak and nobody is keeling over because of it.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by Matumio on Friday January 09, 2015 @07:54AM
(#8862019)
But I'd like to know if the power density of this device can get anywhere close to the "health hazard" limit. We need citation or numbers about that. I'm sure you can already harvest some microwatts from wifi, and most people agree that nobody dies because of that.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by Kenji on Friday January 09, 2015 @07:57AM
(#8862027)
Of course nobody dies of WiFi. I'm not claiming that WiFi kills you. What we are talking about here is transmitting multiple Watts (or else your phone takes forever to charge), or even more, through the air. That's a lot of orders of magnitude more than microwatts.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by icebraining on Friday January 09, 2015 @09:27AM
(#8862319)
Microwave ovens are isolated. They certainly don't output watts to the outside.
"A Federal standard limits the amount of microwaves that can leak from an oven throughout its lifetime to 5 milliwatts (mW) of microwave radiation per square centimeter at approximately 2 inches from the oven surface."
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by jrockway on Friday January 09, 2015 @08:24PM
(#8865462)
Microwave ovens are very leaky. A coworker and I walked around our office with a spectrum analyzer* and turned on microwaves. Much leakage into the upper 2.4GHz wifi band on every one we tested, no matter old or brand new.
* Actually, we were using a Wi-Spy. No need for sensitive lab equipment to detect this much radiation.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by mbell on Friday January 09, 2015 @12:11PM
(#8863112)
> And please, that high powered electromagnetic waves are a health hazard does not need a citation.
We've had AM/FM transmission towers spread around the global transmitting at 100,000 Watts for decades, many in residential areas. Yet we have no conclusive evidence that there are negative health effects on those living next to them.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by ac29 on Friday January 09, 2015 @11:41AM
(#8862958)
> Ever sat in a microwave while it was running? That is exactly what is happening to your body
Microwaves in the US are 1000-1500W or so. This tech apparently has a max of 16W. Conflating the two is like saying that because boiling water will burn you, it is dangerous to take a bath in lukewarm water.
Re:Router can power your devices wirelessly from 15 feet away
by drzaiusapelord on Friday January 09, 2015 @10:25AM
(#8862560)
For low wattage devices like phones and smartwaches, its practical and not a health risk. We're not charging our EV cars with this.
>That stuff was discovered by Tesla ages ago
I'd give that distinction to Hertz on a practical level and Maxwell on a theoretical level. Honestly, I'm getting sick of the loudmouth Tesla fandom. His "internet celebrity" is largely ahistorical and detracts from real deserving and underpublicized scientists and engineers.
Anyone remember this?
http://www.engadget.com/2010/01/09/airnergy-wifi-power-syste...
It just keeps getting weirder... this is starting to look more like fraud than your average startup-peddling-snake-oil.
If they aren't, they can still get 1W theoretically, which is actually useful: it can kind of charge your phone in 8 hours. Assuming 100% of the power is captured by the antenna, that is. (Note that I say theoretically: the real world is very bad for theoretical models.)
Also something to worry about: the FCC's maximum permissible radiation exposure. For 6 minute controlled application (people near the transmitter know it's on), you're allowed an energy density of 5mW per square centimeter. An iPhone 4 is about 55 cm^2, so that would mean a maximum of 275mW. That would charge the phone in 24 hours. (These are guidelines for amateur radio operators, not Part 15 devices; I don't know what the regs around Part 15 say about power density. The regs also cover far-field effects, not near-field effects, so perhaps they can get around these.)
Finally, if you want to play with beamforming and figure out how to get 100% of the power to a 55 cm^2 area, try: http://apenwarr.ca/beamlab/
"What are the RF spectrums being used by WattUp?" [1]
- 2.4GHz (Unlicensed) for Bluetooth Low Energy communication
- 5.7-5.8 GHz (Unlicensed Industrial, Scientific & Medical, ISM) band for power transfer"
[1] http://www.energous.com/page-f/
(900MHz has a slightly difference RF exposure calculation that you have to do compared to 1300MHz and up. But 2.4 and 5 are the same.)
http://www.witricity.com/
On HN:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7404884
And this one:
http://techcrunch.com/2012/07/11/disruptive-defined-ubeam-la...
On HN:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4232925
This is a weird bit in the article:
"To demo its tech, Energous has turned a casino suite into a faux home full of wireless power, which we dropped by to allow the company's founder Michael Leabman to put on a show for us."
If there is one thing that sets off my spidey sense during due diligence on new products it is demos in controlled environments.
> Power Delivered to a Consumer Full-Featured Product
> 4W delivered simultaneously to 4 devices, 0-5 feet
> 2W delivered simultaneously to 4 devices, 5-10 feet
> 1W delivered simultaneously to 4 devices, 10-15 feet
> Delivering on average 2W to 4 devices simultaneously within the charging envelope
Things that concern me are, in random order:
- Is it safe to keep the device (let say it's a phone) in a pocket or close to one's head while is it charging?
- Is it safe to sit/sleep for hours in between the charger and a (possibly somebody's else) device?
- How focused the power beam is?
- What are the safety measures to prevent other people stealing the power? Think about the family living on the other side of the wall. Probably Bluetooth pairing, but I'm not 100% sure.
- Does it cause reduction of bandwidth for WiFi? (it uses the same frequencies)
- Compliancy with regulations about electromagnetic pollution? They started the certification process in the USA for a receiver (http://www.energous.com/energous-completes-initial-fcc-part-...) but I'm more worried about the transmitter.
How quickly efficiency drops off.
I suspect you only get 70% if your phone is literally on top of the router, and that the efficiency drops of very quickly to 0 as you approach the range limit.
No, not really. I love my wireless charging pad it's as easy as putting my phone down, which I do when I'm not using it anyway.
I've been careless (charging a phone in my pocket) and broke several cables. The port is still rock solid.
Your health effects are very clearly in the [citation needed] area. The only negative effect from long-wave radiation (not gamma or UV) is that it heats things. If you heat a human too much, they die.
"A Federal standard limits the amount of microwaves that can leak from an oven throughout its lifetime to 5 milliwatts (mW) of microwave radiation per square centimeter at approximately 2 inches from the oven surface."
http://www.fda.gov/radiation-emittingproducts/resourcesforyo...
* Actually, we were using a Wi-Spy. No need for sensitive lab equipment to detect this much radiation.
We've had AM/FM transmission towers spread around the global transmitting at 100,000 Watts for decades, many in residential areas. Yet we have no conclusive evidence that there are negative health effects on those living next to them.
Microwaves in the US are 1000-1500W or so. This tech apparently has a max of 16W. Conflating the two is like saying that because boiling water will burn you, it is dangerous to take a bath in lukewarm water.
Tell me if it's 20 watts worth.
Oh, it was 2000 watts? Yes. Orders of magnitude matter.
>That stuff was discovered by Tesla ages ago
I'd give that distinction to Hertz on a practical level and Maxwell on a theoretical level. Honestly, I'm getting sick of the loudmouth Tesla fandom. His "internet celebrity" is largely ahistorical and detracts from real deserving and underpublicized scientists and engineers.