Fake Online Personae for Propaganda [2]
DARPA Social Media in Strategic Communication (SMISC) [3]
[1] http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2011/02/revealed-air-force-ordere...
[2] http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2011/mar/17/us-spy-ope...
[3] https://www.fbo.gov/index?s=opportunity&mode=form&id=6ef1255...
To add to this, let's not forget GCHQ's Joint Threat Research Intelligence Group (JTRIG). As a member of FVEY, they are part of the "help our allies by spying on each other" game that happens to get around constitutional restrictions.
https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/07/14/manipulating-o...
JTRIG's toolbox is particularly interesting. While some tools are general-purpose or have plausible uses for traditional spying, quite a few tools are not useful for "finding terrorists" or other nation security purposes. These tools would be useful for spreading propaganda:
• “Change outcome of online polls” (UNDERPASS)
• “Ability to artificially increase traffic to a website” (GATEWAY) and “ability to inflate page views on websites” (SLIPSTREAM)
• “Amplification of a given message, normally video, on popular multimedia websites (Youtube)” (GESTATOR)
So yes, manipulation and paid posts are certainly going on. There are also far more technically sophisticated tricks being used as well. Unfortunately, this is something w4e need to keep in mind in most internet discussions - even here on HN. There has certainly been a lot of discussions here and elsewhere that were derailed with wedge-issue distractions.
The rabidity of the Israeli shills isn't even the problem-- they're easy to spot, and their attacks on almost anyone discussing the issue are transparently biased. The real problem is that even when Israel is not in wartime, the shills still operate at a reduced level, trying to shape a public discussion milieu that is pro-Israel and refuses to recognize any kind of subtlety.
People notice that they get attacked when they criticize Israel online, and eventually they keep quiet.
I haven't seen examples of this. I post quite critical stories about Israel's policies (some from the press in Israel, others from places around the world) on my Facebook wall, and not even my Facebook friends who occasionally display Israeli flags as Facebook profile photos seem to mind. Here on Hacker News, the one country that people can "attack" almost with impunity is the United States, but of course every United States citizen, including me too, has plenty to criticize the United States about, so all I ask is that criticism be factual and made with some international perspective. I think most Israeli citizens, and for the most part operatives of the Israeli government, have the same approach: criticize what deserves criticism, and give us a chance to discuss the policies of our country openly, but don't ignore the rest of the world in the process.
These are the successors to cold war game theory think tank people after all.
- Every one of these organizations is in some secret or not-so-secret budget under "psychological operations." In one form or another this has been considered a normal part of warfare since Sun Tzu.
- Every one of these organizations would say that "criticizing our country online means attacking its reputation" and that "we are defending our country by posting counter-arguments."
- Serious long-term damage happens to any PSYOP group that habitually spreads false information. The fact that the people at many of these organizations certainly know this does not mean that they would never spread false information, just that doing so would make them very bad at their jobs.
[0] http://digitalcommons.kennesaw.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?artic...
Or maybe it's that the people who claim they're just attacking Israel are really attacking Jews in general, and most people don't respond well to having anti-Semitic turds dumped in their conversational punchbowl.
Israel and Jews are not the same entity, it's entirely possible (even probable) to disprove of Israel and approve of Jews.
As an example, I am married to a Jew, but detest Israel's foreign policy and the way it tends to drag the USA around.
That said, I'd be pretty unsurprised if we employed people to do it on specific, foreign sites in places like Iran, China, Syria, Lybia, etc. Monitoring + Posting + Commenting. That would be smart and part of normal intel gathering.
More interesting than the human commentary, however, would be bots running analysis on posts and comments, and then upvoting, downvoting, or spamming in the comments (with intent to ruin experience) based on content and sentiment -- allowing programatic and rule-driven propaganda effects.
Call me a conspiracy nut, but now that social media is how most young people get their news, I wouldn't be surprised if the US gov paid people to post and promote bullshit fluff to keep people distracted from major events in the world. When those major stories do make it to the masses, there are people to comment about how it's a "non-issue" and "we need to focus on more important things" or that the US is doing what's necessary to protect its interests and the world's.
Just a couple examples:
All throughout the build up to the Manning trial, I distinctly remember most commenters on tech news sites supporting Manning. Upon conviction, I checked the comments on Ars Technica and the comments were overwhelmingly along the lines of "Let this be a sign to all future traitors.", "Lock HIM up and throw away the key!!" There was a comment about how suspicious the shift was, and the next three pages of comments were along the lines of, "How do we know YOU aren't working for someone?", "We never supported TRAITORS like YOU.", etc. It was bizarre.
The overwhelming coverage of The Interview days after the CIA torture report came out. People were outraged, but then every corner of the internet was plastered with patriotism and how we need to release some awful comedy to stick it to some dirt poor totalitarian state. Now people have forgotten about that movie, as well as the CIA's issues.
I also recall a huge amount of support for an invasion and increased funding of rebels in Syria back when the US government claimed Assad was using chemical weapons against his people. What shocked me was that the people most calling for war was liberal/feminist discussion circles. That all seems to be forgotten now that a group of rebels called ISIS is our enemy of the week.
Why pay people to do it when everyone else is already posting bullshit fluff anyway?
Team Themis was developing a “persona management” system — a program,
developed at the specific request of the United States Air Force, that
allowed one user to control multiple online identities (“sock
puppets”) for commenting in social media spaces, thus giving the
appearance of grass roots support. The contract was eventually
awarded to another private intelligence firm.
http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/06/14/the-real-war...North Korea isn't dirt poor. All the wealth is concentrated at the top, and in the military-spending though.
North Korea -- Population 25 Million -- has the same estimated GDP as Botswana -- A poor African country ravaged by HIV with a population 2.1 Million.
I don't even bother visiting the site anymore.
> Within the State Department, a Silicon Valley veteran has quietly launched an improbable new initiative to annoy, frustrate and humiliate denizens of online extremist forums.
Not exactly the comment section of BBC, is it?
http://www.linuxjournal.com/content/nsa-linux-journal-extrem...
Anything that swayed public opinion. For one example posting negative things regarding the Edward Snowden controversy. There were people calling him a "traitor" who "got people killed" with zero post history.
As I said, the evidence that the USG does this is not strong, although there have been reports that discuss doing it (and methods), and the USG almost certainly do have strong influence over the popular media (e.g. evening news, newspapers, etc) and have since the cold war (when newspapers would have a CIA employee in every newsroom, providing "feedback" on certain stories and some claim pushing US puff pieces).
Eventually, but eventually can be a long time. Didn't Project Mockingbird fly (hah) under the radar for 14 years?
http://media.ccc.de/browse/congress/2014/31c3_-_6184_-_de_-_...
Like how the NSA shenanigans got the whistle blown on them before they got very far?
We had evidence that the NSA program was going on since 2003 and in 2005 anyone who was paying attention knew that they had hooks into major telephone hubs and under-sea cables with most of the major carriers (and there were already several whistleblowers). We also knew they were building huge data centres.
But many people ignored it because "the US Government would never do such a thing!" It literally took Edward Snowdon to spell it out to these people before they would believe, but if your head wasn't buried in the sand nothing in the Snowden leaks should have been a shock or surprise (except maybe the fiber intercepts between private company's data centres, that wasn't known).
I think people will naively pretend that the US Government has no influence over popular media OR social media until it is spelt out to them in plain English from internal memos. However we've already seen enough leaks to know SOMETHING is going on, we just don't know the scale (kind of like the 2003 version of the NSA scandal, we aren't at the 2005 level of knowledge yet).
In fact the big snowden shocker turned out to be bullshit. The report that the NSA had direct access to facebook and gmail. Turns out that was just a misinterpretation of a powerpoint slide.
The only new and important info Snowden leaked was the metadata from phone companies that included everyone.
Seems like a sound practice to me! The Israelis would never break the terms of such a contract!
You immediately came up with an idea to ruin certain conversations using technical know how not available to the general public.
Now imagine you work somewhere with the budget and means to actually do it, and you are the type of person who is just as techy and also is fine with your career working with the people who got burned in the Snowden leak. Why wouldn't you actually do it?
You probably would: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20140714/10462727873/lates...
In my view, they don't really have to post anything of substance. All they might have to do is degrade the discourse through trolling, to the point where thoughtful views from either "side" are lost in the noise.
Here's an okay link describing other tactics: http://vigilantcitizen.com/latestnews/the-25-rules-of-disinf...
In addition to pro-government positions, there appears to be a pro Obama bunch that is strident beyond reason. I mean... Obama could eat a baby and they would be there 24-7 arguing that it was the best thing to do.
Cohen’s directorate appeared to cross over from public relations and “corporate responsibility” work into active corporate intervention in foreign affairs at a level that is normally reserved for states. Jared Cohen could be wryly named Google’s “director of regime change.” According to the emails, he was trying to plant his fingerprints on some of the major historical events in the contemporary Middle East. He could be placed in Egypt during the revolution, meeting with Wael Ghonim, the Google employee whose arrest and imprisonment hours later would make him a PR-friendly symbol of the uprising in the Western press. Meetings had been planned in Palestine and Turkey, both of which—claimed Stratfor emails—were killed by the senior Google leadership as too risky. Only a few months before he met with me, Cohen was planning a trip to the edge of Iran in Azerbaijan to “engage the Iranian communities closer to the border,” as part of Google Ideas’ project on “repressive societies.” In internal emails Stratfor’s vice president for intelligence, Fred Burton (himself a former State Department security official), wrote,
Google is getting WH [White House] and State Dept support and air cover. In reality they are doing things the CIA cannot do . . . [Cohen] is going to get himself kidnapped or killed. Might be the best thing to happen to expose Google’s covert role in foaming up-risings, to be blunt. The US Gov’t can then disavow knowledge and Google is left holding the shit-bag.
And I recall reading a couple of years ago about a software that enabled a person to control several user accounts on one site or different sites. And I think the US military or some other US agency actively used it.
The developers went on to form a company[1] "to influence ratings on sites which allow users to rate articles or other items" with $2m in funding from Sequoia. Not sure if they still up-and-running.
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Megaphone_desktop_tool [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collactive
Bush said "see, in my line of work you got to keep repeating things over and over and over again for the truth to sink in, to kind of catapult the propaganda" some see him as a bumbling, silly fool. I see a (perhaps overly) honest and transparent man.
It's probably true that the revisions to the Smith-Mundt Act will not open the flood gates of government sponsored media manipulation. Given that Kenneth Tomlinson [47] (a chairman to the foreign media propaganda arm of the United States) was put in charge of the Corporation for Public Broadcasting (NPR and PBS) before handpicking State Department official Patricia Harrison to supersede him, and that Harrison has brought in Cheryl Halpern, Tim Isgitt, Mike Levy, Helen Mobley, and other State Department officials formerly in charge of US overseas propaganda efforts [48], and that Tomlinson left after an internal investigation charged him with Ethics Violations for breaking the anti-propaganda law Public Broadcasting Act of 1967 [49] (but no arrest...) these things are probably nothing to worry about.
Propaganda exists in many forms in the United States but it is still held at bay to many degrees (when compared to some other nation states; it is by no means the worst) by the sorts of laws that the Smith-Mundt Act used to be. In my opinion every anti-propaganda law we lose or weaken is a big deal for liberty.
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ibrahim_Jassam
[3] http://www.salon.com/2012/04/08/u_s_filmmaker_repeatedly_det...
[4] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/aug/18/glenn-greenwald...
[5] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/28/us/case-of-james-risen-tim...
[6a] https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/09/04/former-l-times...
[6b] http://www.democracynow.org/2014/9/5/headlines#959
[7] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2004/may/29/iraq.usa1
[8] http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/04...
[9] http://www.globalresearch.ca/psyops-media-warfare-and-the-we...
[10] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallujah_during_the_Iraq_War
[11] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Fallujah_during_t...
[12] http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2014/5/14/nyt-nsa-leak...
[13] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayman_Mohyeldin#2014_Israel.E2....
[14] http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/ferguson-no-fly-zone-...
[15] http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/government-elections...
[16] https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/07/14/manipulating-o...
[17] http://jfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg%20Subject%20Index%20...
[18] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2006/03/heroes-error?pag...
[19] http://www.salon.com/2005/02/23/more_gannon/
[20] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armstrong_Williams#.22No_Child_...
[21] http://www.thenation.com/article/bushs-war-press
[22] http://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/13/politics/13covert.html?pag...
[23] http://www.buzzfeed.com/chrishamby/government-says-federal-a...
[24] https://web.archive.org/web/20031025141143/http://www.channe...
[25] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jessica_Lynch#Controversy_rega...
[26] http://thelibertybeat.com/anti-propaganda-law-repealed-state...
[27] http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/09/politics/09intel.html
[28] http://www.nytimes.com/2005/11/06/politics/06intel.ready.htm...
[29] http://articles.latimes.com/2006/jan/27/world/fg-infowar27
[30] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2006/03/heroes-error?pag...
[31] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird
[32] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/10/us/austin-goodrich-spy-who...
[33] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Kearns
[34] http://boingboing.net/2011/02/18/hbgarys-high-volume.html
[35] http://www.marayamedia.com/company.php
[36] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Earnest_Voice
[37] http://minerva.dtic.mil/doc/samplewp-Lieberman.pdf
[38] http://aibrt.org/downloads/EPSTEIN&ROBERTSON_2014-Manipulati...
[39] http://jhfowler.ucsd.edu/massive_turnout.pdf
[40] http://www.pnas.org/content/111/24/8788.full.pdf
[41] http://reclaimdemocracy.org/political_reform_quotes_presiden...
[42] http://www.amazon.com/No-Debate-Republican-Democratic-Presid...
[43] http://www-tc.pbs.org/now/politics/2004MemorandumUnderstandi...
[44] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_Debate_Commission
[45] http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/nsa-releases-12-years-su...
[46] http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/06...
[47] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenneth_Tomlinson
[48] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheryl_Halpern
[49] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Broadcasting_Act_of_196...
I will say a far more common thing from the USG is seeing people edit Wikipedia pages, however those attempts are almost laughably unsophisticated (often being trivially traceable to the offices of the people they're editing).
I strongly suspect a certain controversial country in the middle east does it, as every time they come up in any discussion you get inundated with pro' people who have little posting history (or none) and who come across very unnaturally pro (like talking heads). I won't name the country since the same thing might happen here.
PS - I'm neither pro nor anti this middle eastern country, I've just noticed very unusual posting patterns when they're discussed. Particularly during large scale controversies (which seem to occur about once a year).