News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by adwf on Thursday January 08, 2015 @08:16AM (#8856204)
Note that this paper is heavy on theory, not so much on the evidence. The only "proof" of this conjecture is right at the end where they mention 10 people tried starvation before chemo and reported feeling less side-effects afterwards.

I'm actually trying out an intermittent fasting diet right now for weight loss. I'm just always skeptical of new fad diets when they start claiming all sorts of health benefits beyond weight loss.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by gus_massa on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:32AM (#8856480)
I agree. This is clearly not a double blind experiment [1]. And self reporting studies are more prone to produce false results, because the people are optimistic and want to recover and want to feel better. Also people want to be kind and make the doctors happy, so they unconsciously ignore some of the bad side effects.

And also people confuse normal variations with treatment consequences, so perhaps the persons in the treatment group classify that as an improvement and the persons in the control group classify that as normal. [2]

In this case, perhaps the comparison is worse because fasting has some side effects and you can get answers like: "I fell a little dizzy, but not as dizzy as the previous week while I was fasting." Should you classify that as an improvement?

[1] Is it possible to do a double blind experiment for this?

[2] Do they have control group?

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by Evgeny on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:43AM (#8856536)
I'm just always skeptical of new fad diets when they start claiming all sorts of health benefits beyond weight loss

There is a guy who did a nice work summarising the scientific findings.

http://www.lift-heavy.com/intermittent-fasting/

Many studies are on animal subjects, but there are human studies too which show more than just weight loss

Calorie restriction in humans is associated with weight loss, reduced inflammation and improved markers for cardiovascular and metabolic health in obese (9,10) as well as non-obese (11,12) subjects

In another study, fasting healthy men and women were compared to a matched non-fasting group with regard to inflammation markers and blood lipid status (61). No differences were observed in body weight, total cholesterol, triglycerides or LDL levels. There was however an increase in HDL levels and decreased inflammation – proposing a beneficial effect in the fasted subjects.

In obese subjects, a modified 8-10 week alternate-day fasting regimen resulted in weight loss, reduced blood pressure and heart rate, and improved markers for cardiovascular health, such as decreased total cholesterol, decreased LDL and triglycerides, increased HDL concentrations and decreased oxidative stress and systemic inflammation, suggesting that alternate-day fasting might be a novel strategy for decreasing body weight and improving cardiovascular health in the obese population (64,68).

eight healthy men were maintained on a 20h modified alternate-day fast for two weeks. Despite unaltered body weight and habitual physical activity, insulin dependent glucose uptake increased, and increased adiponectin levels were observed (65).

In another trial, the insulin sensitizing effect of true alternate-day fasting was observed through reduced insulin response to a standardized meal in men, but not women – suggesting a potential sex difference in the effect of alternate-day fasting on glucose metabolism (66).

I'm also doing intermittent fasting - a 36 hour fast each week - and plan to do longer fasts maybe every 3-4 months - for health reasons.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by leshow on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:47AM (#8856555)
In many studies they compare a control group eating a maintenance caloric intake with a fasting group that is in a caloric deficit. The results of positive health benefits of fasting usually have to do with the fact that the subjects are actually in a caloric deficit more than the studies choice of meal timing.

I'd have to dig in to those specific studies to show that, but don't read an abstract and think that it in any way tells the whole story.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by Rainymood on Thursday January 08, 2015 @08:37AM (#8856269)
>I'm actually trying out an intermittent fasting diet right now for weight loss. I'm just always skeptical of new fad diets when they start claiming all sorts of health benefits beyond weight loss.

Weightloss. To me, still means in < out. I tried everything (keto, atkins, low carb, high carb, paleo) and intermittent fasting just seems to work for me.

I fast (skip breakfast/lunch and drink coffee) and start eating when I get back home out of work. I love it because I build up a 'caloric buffer', for when something unexpected happens (random cake/donuts/birthday). IF allows me to adjust my calories at the end of the day as I see fit.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by stoicy on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:22AM (#8856441)
The "in < out" is as silly as saying that Bill Gates is rich because more money enters into his bank account than leaves from it. Both are tautologies and don't explain anything, and are not the root cause. It's always the root cause that really matters, not the side effects.

People get fat because they eat the wrong food, of which the effect of making them hungry and eat even more is only one of the many detrimental effects of unsuitable food for us or other animals.

I don't write this to change your mind, but hope that if someone else reads this, at least this might give them some encouragement, so that they might persist through to read about the issue themselves. It really is not easy to swim against the current.

Our bodies are far more than a simple caloric furnace. But luckily fatness, cancer and a myriad of other metabolic diseases resolve themselves once and for all without calorie counting when one starts to eat correctly. That is, plenty of animal fats, meat, eggs and fish, and very little carbohydrates of any kind. Large portions and infrequently. This makes and keeps you healthy, and you cannot overeat even if you try. Simple and elegant, which is always a prerequisite for any correct theory about nature.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by JeremyNT on Thursday January 08, 2015 @11:15AM (#8857012)
> People get fat because they eat the wrong food, of which the effect of making them hungry and eat even more is only one of the many detrimental effects of unsuitable food for us or other animals.

Counter anecdote: I "got fat" eating slightly too much relatively healthy, mostly home prepared food over a long period of time. I lost weight by noting how much I ate and reducing intake while continuing to eat the same food. I know some people who eat only fast food and maintain a healthy weight because they have a good sense of how many calories they require.

It's probably true that some people eat diets that condition them to eat too much, but you can't simply claim something as broad as "people get fat because they eat the wrong food" and be done with it.

The parent's "in < out" generalization may be broad, but at least it's true.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by leshow on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:43AM (#8856534)
Almost everything you say in this post is completely wrong.

The body is not immune to the law of conservation of energy. If you think you can eat a caloric surplus of any food type and lose weight then you've resigned yourself to not think rationally.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by stoicy on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:52AM (#8856580)
I don't think so and I didn't say so above. I hope you read my text, not only the first sentence of it.
Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by leshow on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:19PM (#8858680)
"The "in < out" is as silly as saying that Bill Gates is rich because ..."

" Large portions and infrequently. This makes and keeps you healthy, and you cannot overeat even if you try. "

the fact is that you can 'overeat' with ANY meal timing frequency or food choice. caloric balance takes precedence over everything else, even macronutrient breakdown is secondary.

You suggest otherwise and you couldn't be further from the truth.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by Lewton on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:53AM (#8856584)
He did not say that you could eat a caloric surplus and lose weight.
Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by leshow on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:22PM (#8858707)
"The "in < out" is as silly as saying that Bill Gates is rich because ..."

" That is, plenty of animal fats, meat, eggs and fish, and very little carbohydrates of any kind. Large portions and infrequently. This makes and keeps you healthy, and you cannot overeat even if you try. "

Making the claim that it's impossible to overeat on specific foods is absolutely ridiculous.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by Lewton on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:38AM (#8856509)
Reasonable post up until the point where you claimed eating right cures cancer
Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by stoicy on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:56AM (#8856595)
Yes I know it sounds absurd.

That just happens to be the topic of the article we're commenting on here. It's also the topic of the book Tripping Over the Truth: The Metabolic Theory of Cancer by Travis Christofferson.

I'm not going to argue about the issue here, but I recommend that book for everyone. If nothing else, it's an interesting read for the history of cancer research and the development of chemotherapeutic drugs.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by leshow on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:44AM (#8856538)
There is nothing reasonable about it, it's completely wrong on every level.
Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by Lewton on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:49AM (#8856567)
What's so unreasonable about saying that different foods can satiate you differently? All calories are not created equally.
Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by leshow on Thursday January 08, 2015 @03:08PM (#8858613)
That's not what the post said,

"This makes and keeps you healthy, and you cannot overeat even if you try. "

implies that you can make food choices which prevent you from gaining weight, regardless of quantity.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by adwf on Thursday January 08, 2015 @08:45AM (#8856305)
Exactly, it's all about "in < out". But it's the psychology that has me trying the intermittent approach. I don't eat excessively normally, so any weight gain I have is due to being 100-200 calories over on a vaguely consistent basis, which leads to weight gain in the long term.

I figure I can stick to a diet better when it's only 1 day in 4 when I have to cut calories. Whereas if I was any good at cutting a moderate amount of calories every day, I probably wouldn't need to be dieting in the first place! ;)

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by mrfusion on Thursday January 08, 2015 @08:59AM (#8856345)
Yeah, I've come to the conclusion that any diet based on will power just won't work. I've done will-power based diets for up to 8 months before but ultimately I just give in again.

That's why I'm hopeful IF might help.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by vinceguidry on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:24AM (#8856447)
I lost 40 pounds eating once a day and walking. 205-165. It was the quickest, most dramatic weight loss I ever experienced. For three months nobody could see me without remarking on how much better I looked.

Yes, it will help.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by s_q_b on Thursday January 08, 2015 @11:23AM (#8857059)
240 -> 195 in three months with portion control and no snacking. For me, I charted what I was eating and when for three weeks before starting. Then I broke down the calories in my diet by origin.

Then I rebalanced slightly by adding more green vegetables (I was eating virtually none), and reduced the portions of each other category by around %30-%50, bringing me about 500 calories below my basal metabolic rate. One slice of pizza, not two, half a sandwich rather than a whole, a salad once every couple days. Even without removing snack foods, changing the amount I put on a plate radically altered my caloric consumption without me really noticing. Now that I'm at a healthy weight (I should note I'm very tall so a healthy weight is 190-205ish for me), I brought consumption levels back up to slightly above BMR, and will probably increase more as I start weight training.

On a side note, soda and Doritos were regular staples in my diet. When I stopped I noticed that there's a sort of "withdrawal" when you stop eating these hyper-engineered processed foods. Might be the brain not receiving the expected jolt of positive feedback from a high caloric treat. Either that or something in processed foods really affects my body chemistry. All I know is that for weeks in the middle the sight of a bowl of Lays made me feel both tempted and queasy.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by mrfusion on Thursday January 08, 2015 @08:57AM (#8856340)
Do you think you'd do better or worse with a 5:2 diet? Want to do IF too but I haven't decided on an approach yet.

Also this NPR article [1] seemed to imply 12 hours of fasting per 24 hours would be enough. That's actually simply skipping breakfast which is really easy.

[1] http://www.sciencefriday.com/segment/12/05/2014/you-are-when...

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by ggrothendieck on Thursday January 08, 2015 @11:01AM (#8856943)
There is a site and free self published e-book of about 60 pages (hard copy is available too) on an IF diet in which one fasts for all but 5 hours a day for the purpose of weight loss. The book describes the author as a retired medical doctor and former researcher in the Metabolism branch of the National Cancer Institute. Cancer is not discussed in the book although there is a brief section on physiology and the three mechanisms throught to underlie the effect. See http://www.fast-5.org/
Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by leshow on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:41AM (#8856518)
Proof is the wrong term here, I understand you put it in quotations but the correct term would be 'evidence'.

In studies like this, there is no proof, there is only evidence for different arguments.

In terms of your intermittent fasting diet. Meal timing won't really affect weight loss, what will affect weight loss is your overall energy balance (deficit or surplus), and to a lesser extent macronutrient intake (possible slight fat burn from thermic effect of feeding with higher protein).

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by moogleii on Thursday January 08, 2015 @10:14AM (#8856689)
Theory would be the wrong term, too.
Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by debacle on Thursday January 08, 2015 @10:03AM (#8856637)
IF is only really about weight loss as an ancillary benefit to the actual benefits. It's incredibly easy to gain weight on IF if you are trying - just eat more - but IF helps you eat less via about a half-dozen different vectors.

http://www.marksdailyapple.com/fasting-weight-loss/

The above is a good meta-resource on how and why IF helps you eat less.

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by mih on Thursday January 08, 2015 @08:59AM (#8856347)
A more scientific study on the benefits of fasting leading to improved cell regeneration was posted on HN a few days ago. Here's the corresponding journal paper http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.stem.2014.04.014 (paywalled)
Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by adwf on Thursday January 08, 2015 @09:29AM (#8856459)
Yeah, that was the discussion that got me going on the intermittent diet ;)

I'm just too used to seeing extraordinary dietary benefits being promoted for all sorts of fad foods/diets like blueberries, grapefruit, atkins diet, paleo diet, etc... So I felt like pointing out that there was very little in the way of experimental evidence in that paper (I'm from a physics background, love my data).

With any luck this won't be another one of those papers that gets perverted in the press to "Fasting cures cancer!"

Re:Starvation Based Chemotherapy: A Novel Approach for Cance... by reasonattlm on Thursday January 08, 2015 @08:28AM (#8856243)